The FBI has openly admitted to running the server http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2016/01/21/fbi-ran-websit...
This is a pretty interesting argument for the government to make, given its existing legal theory that the children depicted in child pornography suffer redressible harm whenever such an image is viewed. By that theory, improving the site, resulting in many additional views, means the government is actively causing harm to the viewed children, which it shouldn't be doing.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2016/01/21/fbi-ran-websit...
https://www.rt.com/usa/356896-fbi-kiddie-porn-playpen/
https://www.engadget.com/2016/08/23/fbi-improved-dark-web-ch...
http://gizmodo.com/traffic-surged-to-a-child-porn-ring-after...
https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160614/19243034713/judge...
http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-fbis-unprecedented-hack...
> Given the nature of the site, this included uploading large volumes of new child pornography.
or
> During the investigation, logins increased by more than 350 percent to 50,000 per week. The defense attorneys’ motion seeks to discover exactly how the FBI boosted its traffic so much.
That's a massively different picture than what you get by reading the article, and the headline 'FBI's deep web child porn ring'. It wasn't FBI's child porn ring, it was this guy's child porn ring.
> That's a massively different picture...
No, it isn't. The USG treats every instance of child pornography as a separate occurrence of a crime against the child. That is the way they've structured it so that they can convict as many people as possible, not just the individuals responsible for production. In this case the USG, by their own standard, committed an untold number of crimes against these children by keeping the site up and acting as a distributor. There is no difference between this and them setting up a honey pot full of CP.
They kept the site online so they could distribute malware to people who viewed it. What's the actual evidence that they distributed CP?
"...including more than 9,000 files that users could download directly from the FBI. Some of the images described in court filings involved children barely old enough for kindergarten."
In the court filings described by the previously linked stories, one of which I quoted in the comment you just responded to. What do you think they were charging people with, intent to download cp.jpg? Are you having such a hard time believing that the USG would distribute CP that you are mentally blocking all the evidence available to you? Because I have bad news for you, they've done much worse than that.
there are law against entrapment. but when fbi agents get on a chat room anonymously and send someone a link "want to see this illegal content?" now the person who could have zero interest in the matter will just want to check it out to see if it's true, for whatever reason, which could very well be to report to the authorities if it is true. but now, since the person was entrapped, the fbi can just deny the anonymous entrapment and prosecute the person for arriving on the site by their own means and drive.
Entrapment only comes into play if you convince someone to commit a crime they weren't already predisposed to commit. So if you give them a link that says "here's CP" and they download half the site and add it to their collection, it's hard to argue that the cops made you collect CP. In general, if all the police did is provide you a chance to commit a crime and you did so, you were busted, not entrapped.
I suggest this as an entertaining introduction to the law on the concept: http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633
Please do not assume you'll be fine if you self-report to the police.
Yeah, sure. I see a link saying 'child porn click here' and I click that link just out of curiosity. Sure.
> which could very well be to report to the authorities if it is true
You can report it to the authorities without needing to click the link (as any sensible person would do).
remember that there was a famous uk singer that was entrapped just like that since 4 years or so ago. can't remember the name though... he had a foundation to fight child abuse. he spent years reporting links he found to no effect, so he started to collect hard evidence and was busted for possession of that material. he had a hard time fighting the charges, and he might very well be really guilty after all, what I'm telling if just the news as I've read at the time.
If this were even slightly true, there would be reputable news sites all over this story by now.
Edit: http://thehill.com/policy/transportation/294341-fbi-denies-s...
> In February 2015, the FBI seized control of the site and operated it for two weeks so that the agency could distribute malware to users with the intention of identifying suspects.
> The Department of Justice (DOJ) denies that charge, writing in case documents, “The Government Played No Role in Creating the Crime for Which Chase is Being Prosecuted or Otherwise Encouraged His Criminal Conduct. Chase created the Playpen website, not the government.”
> The FBI has also denied claims that during their operation of Playpen, agents improved the site’s performance, helping it run faster.
> “Chase claims absent actual factual support that the government enhanced or improved the website’s functionality,” the DOJ said.
> Even if the FBI did upgrade Playpen’s performance, criminal defense attorney Norman Pattis says, it would have little impact on the case.
> “I don’t think there would be much implication at all,” Pattis said. “I think the defense is misapplying entrapment.”
> “Speeding up access doesn’t create the desire to do it,” he added. “The fact that people come to the market looking for it already doesn’t make it entrapment.”
> The DOJ justified the FBI’s actions in continuing to operate Playpen after arresting Chase. They wrote that shutting down Playpen immediately “might have answered the immediate issue of child pornography trafficking on Playpen, it would have done nothing to address the larger problem.”