Interesting, anecdotally, I went to three different universities and they all barred this from happening without an explicit override from a professor or occasionally an adviser. Just curious what experience you have that makes you say this?
Also, at least when I was an undergrad, the Banner student system (from ellucian company) had no system in place for barring you from registering from classes. This was frequently the point of discussion between the professors that I TA'd for.
As one anecdote, they once told me I needed to retake intro physics. On the pretest given on the first day of class, I came within one problem of a perfect score. Didn't make a lick of difference - their syllabus differed from the last university in the most minor of ways, and despite the fact that the class never actually covered even 50% of the stuff it claimed to on the syllabus, I was made to retake the entire sequence anyway.
Although I think your situation was pretty special as well, transferring universities is usually incredibly annoying and filled with road bumps. I've found there's a lot more leniency given to students who remain within the same university.
The way to get around this isn't by taking pretests (which don't mean much) it's by writing the final exams. In some institutions you will be able to do this without (full?) course fees if you are attempting to demonstrate equivalence.
I failed to mention I'd also already spent three years as a physics major and had already taken classical mechanics, electrodynamics, and quantum mechanics - so being told to retake the intro physics sequence was quite silly indeed.
It's a bit of a pain, but the point wasn't that they should give you some questions from the old exam but that you should actually sit the new one, under exam conditions. That resolves the problem for everyone without you having to spend the time repeating lectures etc. In the best case you don't pay full rate either.
Do they accept credits from any other institutions? Isn't there a national agreement on accepting credits for certified degrees?
Then find a lower-tier university. In any densely populated region there will be at least one that's happy to take your tuition money to let you enroll in a non-degree-earning course of study.
You'll only have an issue if you want a degree which, BTW, is typically intended to be broader than a narrow course of study in a particular area of expertise.
Assuming you can only invest, lets say, 5 hours on the weekend, it will be 30 weeks per class, summing up to ~1.5 classes per year year. I'd say that if someone can keep that up for 10 years, theirs understanding of math will be far above the average population...
But, I went back and studied Real Analysis, Measure Theory, Combinatorics, Topology, and Stochastic Calculus.
I have found, though, that while I have a decent grasp of the concepts my understanding and ability to solve problems isn't as strong as the math grad students who studied these topics deeply.
I have found the knowledge useful, but I would agree that it would be hard to achieve the same results.
Lots of mathematicians switch to a different subfield within their careers. And they do so by self studying, obviously.
If your compsci or physics undergrad provided you with a decent degree of mathematical maturity, it should be doable. The problem here is that compsci is still young, and there is a lot of variability. So diving into differential forms after attending a Java school sounds like a bad idea.
Humans are capable of great things, don't discourage someone from trying.
And I think the latter category is more important than people realize. When I was a high school student, I benefitted greatly from t'Hooft's theorist.html (like this, but for physics, and put together by one of the Greats of the field). It's part of what got me really interested in physics, it was a whole lot of fun, and it actually did a pretty good job of preparing me for graduate-level coursework. Eventually I left physics and math for CS (I'm in PL, so this is even less drastic of career change than one might think), but I still have warm memories of working along t'Hooft's guide and checking off topics as I finished the problems in each textbook.
I don't think that the author of the post you're responding to is making any sort of normative claim.
> Sometimes the issue isn't time - it's money and access to schooling
I think the author is suggesting that if you have that kind of free time, then you either a) must be independently wealthy, or else that b) trading some of that free time for cash you can use to buy credit hours is a net positive because the guidance is worth it (again, assuming your goal is to learn math as opposed to eg obtain a uni degree).
I agree that's not necessarily a good assumption globally, but it's probably a decent assumption for almost everyone in the west, both in terms of self-learning capabilities and in terms of available funds.
Not at all; I meant in the form of a loan, where free time is time you would otherwise spend retired.
And I was also assuming that you already have a decent job that allows you to work 40 hours or so and make a comfortable enough living to consider spending your free time learning math.
Frankly, I can't possibly imagine trying to do something like learn advanced mathematics while also struggling with un- or under-employment. I grant that there are probably people far more motivated and resilient than I assume :-)
I'll pass on a world where policy and education only deals with the common case.
I interpreted this thread as being about advice to a typical person interested in learning math who exists in the society we (specifically, Americans) live in today. For the exceptional, the appropriate advice is of course different.
I learn different things at different speeds, a course makes me go at a speed I don't enjoy. This is perfect.
And trigonometry is taught in high schools? It's something most children pick up, I don't think it's a fair comparison to say, measure theory.
You miss the point also: I was taught trig in high school, and I remember SOHCAHTOA, etc - but until I looked at lines drawn on a unit circle and worked put what secant, sine, tangent and their corresponding ratios meant I didn't really understand trig.
I think, math, unlike CS, is not a "skill" you use in your everyday work. Whoever does math/science has to dedicate much of their life to it. CS you can learn on the internet, by MOOC's, or just by reading books about it. Math on the other hand, simply doesn't work like that.
To be clear, by math, I mean "advanced" mathematics as the title indicates. Elementary (and intermediate) math is required to learn no matter what.
Going to university part time eats up more time than reading a textbook at home or wherever you are in your spare time. It also locks you in to the specific pace that the class is at which is not optimal for most people, because people learn different things at different paces. There is also the cost of university to consider.
I've done these classes. It's typically 150 hours per class and it's not something you do after coming exhausted home from work either. After those 150 hours you'll get a basic understanding of the topic. You won't be an expert by any means. That will require more exposure, more time.
The lectures themselves are not that useful, I find. The lecturers are mostly useful in guiding you along, telling you which aspects of the theory to focus on and weeding through the study material to deliver you the best bits. The problem sets are indispensable. Exams make sure you actually know the basics in depth instead of just knowing about them.
My advice: enrol part-time, take one class at a time, catch up on the lectures and do the problem sets and the homework over the weekend.