The NSA is spying for a reason, and it's not just because they enjoy the challenge. Rather, they want to effect change.
How can spying effect change?
1. Providing knowledge to the US to improve our decision making
2. Providing intelligence to the US to change French decision making
3. Using (1) and (2) effectively so that 100% spying is not even necessary. That is, France chooses the path that would result from spying anyway
4. To give American companies unfair advantages in the workspace.
Yes, but I don't buy into the premise of French (or any particular government's) policy being primarily influenced or directed by a chilling effect created by NSA spying.
I'm pretty sure they only black-bag the people typing "Snowden" into DuckDuckGo.
But the main message to me from the leaks is that despite America knowing everything, the government usually decides to act like it knows nothing.
I doubt the French President or any world leader is so cowed by the premise of NSA spying that it paralyzes them into inaction and submission. Paranoid people on the internet who think that the CIA might black-bag them for typing "Snowden" into Google may be that naive, but the actual political elites are likely far more aware of, and accepting of, the global surveillance network than you or I.
>Whether this has "always gone on", though, is irrelevant to whether it is antithetical to democracy.
That's true, but an assertion of a global political chilling effect remains speculative at best. If anything, the constant leaks about NSA spying seems to have the opposite effect.