How ever, as the company grows, or uses a system developed and controlled by a larger entity, the data being collected can be combined with other larger data sets and can become much more powerful and potentially hurtful for us. In the same scenario, the power of the government has still remained the same, and given the history of Power, we the common people have some measure of control over them. More control than one would have over the large corporation.
I admit I've really never understood that part of the argument.
To go with your example, ok, you have tracking data with a dozen smaller companies you've done transactions with online. Now they all merge and become one huge company, all that data is combined. How were you hurt by this action?
Or they can sell that data to other companies that will deny you any of these things. So better be careful with out you say, with which books you read, who your friends are and so on.
Or they can make deals with governments to reveal information about you, in exchange for regulatory favors.
Or maybe you're a robot with nothing to hide, but they can still make mistakes or wrong inferences and hurt you in the above ways.
And advertisement can be improved to bypass your cognitive defenses, or catch you at a vulnerable moment (all things that can be detected with enough data) and manipulate you into making decisions against your best interests.
In short, data disclosure can get you killed, poor and/or sick. If that was not the case, why would corporations be so secretive about their own stuff?
By the way, all of the above examples are not hypothetical. They are all based on things that are demonstrably already happening.
Then you have some citations?
http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targe...
http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlenzner/2013/09/23/attveri...
http://gawker.com/5669316/is-facebook-outing-gay-users-to-ad...
http://americablog.com/2013/03/facebook-might-know-youre-gay...
http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/01/why-go...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction
http://bgr.com/2014/01/23/apple-targeted-ads-mood-based/
http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/10/denied-for-that-loan...
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527487046486045756207...
The first one doesn't say anything about harm that I can see from my skimming, and the second one is the government paying the phone companies directly, which is concerning but it has nothing to do with tracking cookies or combining data sets. That's as far down as I went.
I don't think there was ever much doubt information can be used against you.
If you're trying to convince people, saying, "it makes it easier to catch tax dodgers" is unlikely to be very effective. Also, catching tax dodgers on Instagram doesn't require tying together cookie data, does it? I mean tell me if I'm wrong and it does.
It's a really shitty thing to do, and the problem we as a society face are people who are unable to abstract the idea into the dangers we can all face and protect ourselves against dangers we can't foresee.
That's what principles are for. We stand on basic principles of privacy and freedom because if we don't we get into a nonlinear mess of unintended and unforseen consequences- and we don't even know it.
Just like the deer that doesn't even know it's being hunted, we are in this game and don't even know what's eventually at stake. So we should stop it now.
I'm ok with banner ads. I'm not ok with tracking.
It's more-or-less equivalent to if someone spent all their time looking through your trash and monitoring you 24/7 to learn if you're pregnant, what meds you're on, how much money you spend in a week, etc etc.
Why?