Re:Airbnb Law Enforcement Transparency Report
by SOLAR_FIELDS on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:26PM
(#12417425)
Why does everyone make such a huge deal about a warrant canary when LE is clearly aware of them and a true gag order would obviously preclude you from removing any such canaries?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Airbnb Law Enforcement Transparency Report
by gizmo686 on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:36PM
(#12417455)
Because it is not obvious that a gag order would preclude one from removing a warrent canarie.
There has been no test cases on the subject, and there are few instances of the court upholding compelled speech. Further, the precedents that we do have for compelled speech have been based on the compelled speach being truthful (as well as a legitimate government interest in compelling the speach).
This means that, irrespective of the law of the gag orders, one could make a very strong consitutional arguement for being allowed to remove the canary, and would have strong precedent.
Re:Airbnb Law Enforcement Transparency Report
by shalmanese on Saturday September 03, 2016 @12:09AM
(#12417672)
Given that warrant canaries have already tripped, clearly it's not SOP for law enforcement to force warrant canaries to stay.
Re:Airbnb Law Enforcement Transparency Report
by notyourwork on Saturday September 03, 2016 @09:45AM
(#12419162)
You should provide a reference, it would be helpful.