News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by ascorbic on Friday September 02, 2016 @07:27AM (#12412260)
Now that LetsEncrypt exists there's no excuse for anyone to use StartCom. They've had a whiff of dodginess for ages, and their customer service is among the rudest I've known. This should be the final straw. Their root needs removing from browsers. Give their existing customers a year's warning.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by lucb1e on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:55AM (#12413040)
Their customer service is rude. But they're giving you free certificates, and they have customer service. That's already better than what you get when you pay for Google services or have a Windows license and run into Windows problems or something.

Lesson of the day: public perception of customer support is important. Rude support worse than no support at all. Noted.

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by ascorbic on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:06AM (#12429037)
I've had terrible service when paying them hundreds of dollars. There's no correlation.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by bkor on Friday September 02, 2016 @07:50AM (#12412348)
Wildcard domains aren't supported by Let's Encrypt last I checked.

StartCom provided GNOME with a free account which can create certificates (including the wildcard ones and so on). Those are pretty much mandatory in certain cases (secure Bugzilla attachment hosting).

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by SEJeff on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:53AM (#12413029)
I actually asked Eddy Nigg (startcom CTO) to do the gnome deal and give us ssl certs for free (back when I was able to ssh/irc from work and be a member of the GNOME Sysadmin Team), which they did. As much hate as they get, they are one of the few "secure" CAs of all of them I've ever worked with. One of the more quiet things when it was first revealed Comodo was hacked was that Startcom was also hacked. Eddy went on the record as bragging not a single rogue SSL certificate was issued as they have a human validate every single certificate request (yes seriously) and that prevented any rogue certificates.

So as much as people think Startcom is scummy, they are actually pretty decent people. They're also quite secure. So YMMV.

This was long before the alleged sale to china though, maybe 5-8 years ago? I forget.

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by BillinghamJ on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:32PM (#12414234)
They definitely don't visually check every cert any more. They're issued instantly.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by SEJeff on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:40PM (#12414309)
Oh I wasn't referring to their lame knock off letsencrypt product, but their main ssl cert.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by BillinghamJ on Saturday September 03, 2016 @09:58AM (#12419205)
Their normal ones are issued instantly also.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by agwa on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:03PM (#12413944)
GlobalSign gives free wildcard certificates to open source projects: https://www.globalsign.com/en/company/press/061913-globalsig...
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by bruo on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:32AM (#12412557)
I agree with you, there is no alternative to StartCom right now in wildcard certs. While GNOME got a free account to get those certs, the last time i checked is still the cheapest way to get wildcard certificates (60 usd for unlimited wildcard certs).

It also removes the complexity of having to deploy let's encrypt certificates every X months without storing the LE's account key online. But if they release certificates for anybody claiming to be you there is no advantage in this area.

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by creshal on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:28AM (#12412533)
> Wildcard domains aren't supported by Let's Encrypt last I checked.

But with ACME, the need for wildcard certs is strongly reduced. If you don't need dynamic, on-the-fly subdomain creation, it's trivial to have Let's Encrypt generate certs with all the subdomains you need (especially now that the limits are much higher than during beta).

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by sirn on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:34AM (#12412569)
I believe that's exactly the use case of secure Bugzilla attachment hosting the OP mentioned. IIRC, it will generate the subdomain on the fly using ticket ID in the form of bug12345.bugzilla.example.com to host the attachment.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by creshal on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:30AM (#12412867)
Ah, interesting. Haven't worked with Bugzilla for years, didn't know they added this.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by Jaruzel on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:05AM (#12412705)
I know I'm in the minority on here, but...

LetsEncrypt's certs are not trusted on Blackberrys (including BB10 devices), and because Blackberry's big thing is 'a secure OS' there's no way to side-load[1] a root cert.

Although dwindling rapidly - there's still some big business out there that are still issuing Blackberrys to it's users.

My main home server is behind a StartCom cert... and I use a BB10 device - so no LetsEncrypt migration for me :(

--

[1] Happy to be corrected on this, If I'm wrong!

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by koolba on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:26AM (#12412837)
> LetsEncrypt's certs are not trusted on Blackberrys (including BB10 devices), and because Blackberry's big thing is 'a secure OS' there's no way to side-load[1] a root cert.

> Although dwindling rapidly - there's still some big business out there that are still issuing Blackberrys to it's users.

What business are you in that Blackberry users are a factor? What percent (or total number of users) would be impacted?

Only time I've seen a Blackberry in recent memory is as a stock image on a "Why RIM failed..." article.

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by Jaruzel on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:15AM (#12413560)
Believe it or not - Large Financial still roll out BBs, mainly because they have a big investment in the BES backend, and don't want to replace it unless they absolutely HAVE to. Latest version of BES (v12) supports iPhone and Android now, but it's not as complete as native BB support.

My Blackberry is personal though (I love hard keyboards!).

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by jaas on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:35PM (#12414265)
We have been working on Blackberry 10 support for a while. While we can't commit to a date yet, we have good reason to believe that your issue will be solved with a software update soon.
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by joecool1029 on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:47PM (#12415263)
I manually added their cross-signing cert months ago and trusted them on my BB10 devices. Works fine. Haven't added the new root yet. You'll need to download them manually to the phone then go to Settings > Security and Privacy > Certificates > Import

As an aside, I found this amusing: https://community.letsencrypt.org/t/inclusion-of-isrg-root/9...

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by kstrauser on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:06AM (#12413503)
That's a pickle to be in. Until LetsEncrypt is trusted on BB, you might consider switching to a different traditional CA. For example, Namecheap resells Comodo certs for $9 per year: https://www.namecheap.com/security/ssl-certificates/domain-v... . That's what I was using on my personal domains until LetsEncrypt came around.

If you can afford a home server, $9 is cheap. It's way cheaper than what StartCom will charge you to revoke your cert if you ever need to (security breach, the next heartbleed, etc.). In fact, StartCom's terrible handling of heartbleed is what prompted me to switch from their free-but-expensive certs to Namecheap/Comodo's paid-but-cheap service.

Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by Jaruzel on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:16AM (#12413578)
Yeah, I guess it's time to stump up cash for a proper cert. I actually need about 5 tho...
Re:WoSign's secret purchase of StartCom: WoSign threatened l... by aianus on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:18PM (#12414085)
I would be very surprised if there was no way to side load root CAs on enterprise deployments of Blackberry.

Enterprises love to MITM SSL (and may also have their own CAs to issue certs for internal services). Even Chrome ignores cert pinning if the CA is user-installed for this reason.