News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by staticautomatic on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:34AM (#12406091)
Am I misunderstanding or am I the only one calling bullshit on all these firms for talking about making money where there's no liquidity event. These are mostly paper gains. Shenanigans.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by mathattack on Thursday September 01, 2016 @01:08PM (#12407008)
They can mark to market, but until the cash comes in, you just don't know. The article differentiates this.

Sequoia’s 2010 fund is up 5.5 times and, unlike other venture funds that are mostly sitting on paper gains

It's very hard to value equity when there are funky things (preferences, participation, etc) in the cap tables. Any given "valuation" is higher for some and lower for others, and in a hard to quantify way. And a "valuation" based on selling 3% of a company is very different than 50%. But... The values are non-zero. And the company needs to provide something that's better than no information to investors in the interim.

Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by staticautomatic on Thursday September 01, 2016 @01:32PM (#12407243)
Sure, for Sequoia. But the next paragraph says Benchmark, for example, "has multiplied investors’ money 11 times net of fees in its 2011 fund...It includes blockbuster investments like Uber Technologies Inc. and Snapchat Inc." to which all I can say is...maybe on paper. My point is that the gains are unrealized until you get the actual money. So "multiplied 11 times" is only true of the monopoly money. Whether it's true of the realized gains remains to be seen.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by mathattack on Thursday September 01, 2016 @02:05PM (#12407527)
The chart also shows realized versus unrealized.

It's analogous to GAAP accounting. GAAP accrual based earnings are good, but until you see the cash, it's just a best guess.

Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by mathattack on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:15PM (#12410091)
It appears that a16z agrees with you in their rebuttal. :-)

http://a16z.com/2016/09/01/marks-offmark/

Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by prostoalex on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:14PM (#12406507)
Most of the world's investable assets (real estate, oil wells, corner ice cream parlor, a Taco Bell franchise) have not had a liquidity event but are valued nonetheless.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by boto3 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:22PM (#12406579)
They do have established business lines and are profitable, so the valuation models are supposedly more accurate. The unicorn startup models would have much higher variance, so that leaves a lot of room for hand waving and personal branding to be factored in.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by robotresearcher on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:28PM (#12406626)
Don't all those example assets change hands for cash (or equivalents) pretty regularly?
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by prostoalex on Thursday September 01, 2016 @01:00PM (#12406944)
Valuation by comparables is an acceptable model if both parties agree on it.

However, it's still far from a done deal as each transaction has its own minuscule details, and in commercial property, e.g., one party might value such things as location, quantity/quality of parking spots, proximity to traffic flows, quality of neighbors, recently incurred maintenance, etc. differently from the other.

With that said, a 409a valuation firm (or potential acquirer) is likely to look at the peers, current and historic ones, to at least start at some ballpark figure.

Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by ericd on Thursday September 01, 2016 @01:56PM (#12407459)
Comps are a lot easier with those assets.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by kinj28 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:55PM (#12406901)
How about securitising the assets in clusters just like MBS.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by hugs on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:56AM (#12406332)
Yes, it's bullshit, but when their LPs ask "How's it going?", reporting paper gains is how they get off the hot seat and/or raise the next fund.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by __derek__ on Thursday September 01, 2016 @01:18PM (#12407106)
That sounds curiously similar to a certain geometric scheme.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by cloudjacker on Thursday September 01, 2016 @05:45PM (#12409149)
nobody with connections gets their funds frozen in an SEC emergency asset injucture, or FTC investigation

the only way to get your liquidity ponzi scheme funds frozen by regulators is to:

a) lose money

b) not know any regulators

If you got a) and b) covered, then you can start as many funds as you want, issue or rollover as many bonds as you want, dilute as much equity as you want

keep the gravy train rolling

Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by paulpauper on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:31PM (#12408188)
So I guess the VCs who invested in Facebook and Google early on must feel pretty poor because it's only 'paper'. Most of these bets are 'binary' - if they succeed, there will more than enough liqudity to go around; if they fail, it's just a small part of the portfolio
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by Kinnard on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:49AM (#12406277)
There seems to be a growing amount of "liquidity" outside of IPOs . . . almost a transition from "liquidity events" to simple . . . "liquidity" . . .
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by staticautomatic on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:00PM (#12406370)
"simple liquidity" - whatever that even is - does not turn paper gains for the likes of Uber into real gains.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by jsprogrammer on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:40PM (#12406745)
I believe new AH funds offer liquidity events to established funds.
Re:Andreessen Horowitz’s Returns Trail Venture-Capital Elite by LA_Banker on Friday September 02, 2016 @05:15PM (#12416341)
a16z is getting punished (at least, in the article) for marking their paper gains more conservatively than other funds.

Their LPs are likely smart enough to realize this.