More than that, however, Cengage (and I'm sure the other publishers as well) have been making a hard sell for their online interactive stuff and their ebooks. A year or so ago they came and made a pitch to us talking about how much cheaper they are for students (of course the students can't sell the ebooks back and can't buy used copies and their access to the book goes away after a year...) and how awesome the interactive online stuff was.
Luckily, the course director is kind of a self-professed Luddite and didn't really care for it but other people at the meeting bought the sales pitch completely so if we had a different course director I could see being forced to use this drmed junk.
The department head has decided to switch us over to Cengage (with all of its interactive features) next semester.
My suspicion is that the students aren't going to use any of interactive products.
Do the schools get some kind of kickback from the publishers?
Like I said the sales pitch convinces them how awesome it is and how it saves money. I also think the fact that a lot of the online stuff can automatically be graded is appealing to some profs.
I also think that some people are not that tech savvy so they don't see the downsides of drm that are so clear to most of us that read hacker news.
The class asked the instructor, who said: "Access codes? No, you don't need those. And a $40 past edition of the text will be just fine."
I'd love to hear your perspective on the state of OER resources and their likelihood of adoption. Particularly if you think outside your institution.
Basically, they took a book that existed and added at least 2 chapters and then customized the rest. I don't know to what degree they customized it but I do know that wherever possible they added links and references to campus resources to make the book more relevant.
I think my AI and Algorithms classes may have used some preprepared slides for Russell and Norvig / CLRS. My Theory of Computation lecturer set assignments based on questions from the Cindarella book (which initially bit a few people like myself who had imported "international editions" from India where they swap the questions around subtly). Some of our first year maths courses (though I don't think they included the ones that I took) use MyMathLab.
Those are the only times I can remember seeing those extra textbook resources being used during my >5 years at the Australian National University. In the courses that I tutored/TAed, we barely touched the textbooks at all, let alone even thinking of these extra resources.
The textbook industry maliciously engineered this market in whatever way they could to kill used book sales. You're out to screw students whether you like to admit it or not. Planned obsolescence is a core element of your business strategy.
So now who choses what text? And doesn't that drive why you print what you print? What happens if prof doesn't like chapter 10, say?
Regarding your question about what happens if a prof doesn't like a chapter, we're starting to see decent growth in customized books. So for instance, for one class they might only want 3 chapters from one book and 4 from another. This is similar to course packs that have been around forever, but created by the publisher. Publishers love it because it means the "book" is custom for the course and you can't easily just buy/rent a used version. These are often sold much cheaper because the publisher is guaranteed 100% sell-through for a course.
That being said, we don't have any control over them releasing a new version. I've had the book store tell me I had to order a new version because they couldn't get the previous one. (and of course the only difference was one or two paragraphs per chapter...)
As far as the scenario of "what happens if prof doesn't like chapter 10," more and more publishers are pushing "customized texts" which we can decide what chapters we want and they will publish it on demand. My last year at my phd program they switched to a book which was combined from readings and chapters from a variety of books.
The reason publishers love this is, of course, that students have to buy the book from them because the book we use at Any Town State is unique and can't be bought used from Amazon or something. So instead of being a benefit to the student it is just another scam to squeeze more money out of students.
The dirty secret of modern textbooks is that there has been a huge arms race in developing material that makes it easier to teach a course with less work. I don't really think that truly benefits students, since most of this material isn't for the student, it's for the professor (or more cynically for the free labor of grad students used to do a lot of the teaching). But you can't sell a textbook these days without it. I wish there was a universe in which you could sell a simple Psych 101 textbook for $50 and have that be that. But the market won't adopt a simple book like that without the myriad of extras. And since the market here is wonky, meaning the person making the decision (the professor) doesn't bear any of the cost (and might in fact benefit if it's her book), we end up where we are.
This isn't to say that the whole new edition thing isn't worth criticism. Or that there aren't all sorts of things wrong with the industry. But the percentage increase you see in the cost of a textbook for students doesn't just equate to the same percentage increase in the profit margin of textbook publishers. They're not just making the same product from 40 years ago and jacking up the prices 1,000% as the article implies. The product is a whole different beast.
(source: I sit on the board of my family's textbook publishing company)