Re:Are we really so modern?
by throwanem on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @10:38AM
(#12390552)
I'm not sure I see the value in this article's protracted digression into a bestiary of philosophers. There is, though, much truth in the statement that to conceive of ourselves as detached from history is to conceive of ourselves inaccurately.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The article is, at it's base level, a review of a book called 'The Dream of Enlightenment'.
Re:Are we really so modern?
by user202020 on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @11:58AM
(#12391263)
Yeah. If it told me it would be that in the title, I would be fine, but it didn't, so now I'm left yearning for thoughts on how or why we think of ourselves as being so modern, or how we aren't all that different at all. :(
Oh. Well, the presence of that latter two-thirds makes much more sense now. Thanks!
I think actually one of the most thoughtful points preceded the (unnecessarily long, IMO) discussion of the various philosophers.
"[...]the loss of contact with the past. Depending on your point of view, this can be seen as either a disinheritance or an emancipation; much of modern politics is determined by which side you take on this question"
I suppose that's true. For most of my life I was, however unconsciously, on a side which considers ignorance of history to be emancipation; without speculating on whether or not that's accurate, I will say that, in discovering and gaining what knowledge and understanding of history I have, I found also that with greater knowledge of the past comes greater understanding of the present. But perhaps that's not true for everyone.