News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HN Summary by derefr on Saturday April 03, 2010 @12:56AM (#1238188)
In any democratic system, the actual result of taking a vote will be a minimax of sorts: the result with the least aggregate distaste. This is why, if you have a non-niche demography for a vote, the top results will always be completely bland—no one can find a reason to dislike them, so the few people that do vote them up push them "all the way" up. Meanwhile, the contentious items—the ones that some love, and some hate—end up getting pulled down, because those who dislike it dislike it enough to overcome the friction of moving the mouse to the down-vote arrow and clicking (or to going out and putting out propaganda posters against that party, etc. etc.).

It would be a genuine invention, perhaps one of the only things worthy of an "algorithm patent", if someone were to come up with a way to encourage creative focus through the use of democracy. Imagine if "designed by committee" were actually a good thing!

As it stands, democratic voting systems are only useful as trained classification filters (i.e. spam filters where the "spam" is "stuff we don't like"). Actually ranking the "good" results should probably be left to editors.

There are no comments on this comment yet.