News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by trevin on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:37PM (#12361312)
I'd argue that it's equally as impossible to set up trigger warning policies.

While some trigger warning like the ones you mentioned are valid, the term has been perverted to include all sorts of things[0] where you could get in trouble for talking in public about insects or needles.

It's an impossible task to list out and educate people on everything that might possible trouble or offend. Once you open that door, there is no finite end to a list of triggers.

[0] http://privilege101.tumblr.com/triggers.html

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by acbabis on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:49PM (#12361422)
Many news outlets will say "Warning, the following story contains graphic imagery," and people don't think this is unreasonable; nor do they expect more specific content warnings in the future. This tells me it's possible to be considerate of common triggers while still drawing the line somewhere
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by mcphage on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:14PM (#12362122)
> This tells me it's possible to be considerate of common triggers while still drawing the line somewhere

I agree it is, but right now it's very difficult to have the discussions necessary to draw those lines—supporters of trigger warnings only want to discuss the cases where they're clearly justified (fireworks & veterans) and pretend all uses are similarly valid, and critics of trigger warnings only want to discuss the cases where they're clearly not (slimy things), and pretend that all uses are similarly invalid. Determining where the lines should be drawn will be a long, complicated, painful discussion, but currently there's no way to have that conversation. If your opinion is somewhere in the middle, most internet commentators will lump you into the all-for or all-against group.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by stcredzero on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:42PM (#12363062)
I agree it is, but right now it's very difficult to have the discussions necessary to draw those lines

When something is 1) subjective or very hard to measure and 2) used as an emotional bludgeon then then people are going to call "shenanigans" and even start to exhibit knee-jerk doubt about such things. Often, this is a tragedy, as the issues may well be both real and difficult to discuss.

The quality of such debate and discussion has been hurt by the "Eternal September" nature of online discussion. The internet gives everyone a voice, especially if you have time to waste. Hence, clueless Freshmen and middle-schoolers have disproportionately loud voices online.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by acbabis on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:29PM (#12362223)
That's a good point. Internet commenters tend to overgeneralize. Fortunately, those people aren't strictly needed for a solution. The only party who needs to listen is the content provider (in my example, the news outlet).
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by jpt4 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:17PM (#12362929)
> Many news outlets will say "Warning, the following story contains graphic imagery,"

Since blood leads, this is, in my personal estimation, done primarily to increase immediate viewer count, not avoid - and thus retain in the more distant future - discomfiting sensitive current viewers.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by crazy1van on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:10PM (#12362883)
> Many news outlets will say "Warning, the following story contains graphic imagery," and people don't think this is unreasonable

Yes, but students shouldn't expect that warning before a class on horror films. If you're unable to see graphic imagery, you should drop the class.

Similarly, students shouldn't expect to be warned about a discussion of slavery in a course about the American civil war. And you really shouldn't be able to get a degree in American history if you're unable to study the civil war.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by nradov on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:08PM (#12363183)
No that's totally different. Broadcast news programs are often watched by small children. Parents reasonably want to shield children from graphic content which they are too immature to understand. However university students are almost entirely adults and thus expected to have the intellectual and emotional maturity to deal with the real world unfiltered.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by rsync on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:31PM (#12361781)
"[0] http://privilege101.tumblr.com/triggers.html"

from the list:

- Pregnancy/childbirth

- Death or dying

- Slimy things

It's very difficult not to dismiss this as infantile.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by mdadm on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:49PM (#12361930)
> It's very difficult not to dismiss this as infantile.

Which is, in turn, why many people don't take these things seriously. Of course, perhaps there is a justification for "trigger warnings" and "safe spaces" in colleges, but the issue of whether those 1) belong in the classroom as opposed to elsewhere on campus, and 2) should be a feature of colleges at all, is completely derailed by things like this.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by pyre on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:38PM (#12362292)
At the same time, in a country that values free speech people are allowed to have idiotic opinions. The fact that people are giving those opinions credence because they are "on the Internet" is probably closer to the issue.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by tedks on Thursday August 25, 2016 @09:41PM (#12363798)
Really? You don't think people are capable of being traumatized by pregnancy, death, or insects? Personal injury and insects are among the most common phobias and pregnancy should be fairly obvious as to why it's on that list (I don't want to elaborate because that could be traumatizing).

Maybe you should try having more empathy for oppressed groups and individuals rather than writing off anything you can't immediately connect to your own experience as infantile.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by rsync on Thursday August 25, 2016 @10:33PM (#12363962)
"Maybe you should try having more empathy for oppressed groups and individuals rather than writing off anything you can't immediately connect to your own experience as infantile."

None of the items I listed involve oppression or special subgroups of people. They are basic components of the human condition.

An inability to deal with the basic aspects of being alive is, ipso facto, infantile.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by tedks on Friday August 26, 2016 @09:54PM (#12370513)
Pregnancy predominantly effects women. If I need to argue that women are oppressed, I don't think we can have a discussion. Phobias effect the neurodivergent and your dismissal of this is ableist.

You're inserting your own value system, via the word "basic." It's indisputable that anything is an "aspect" of "being alive," but whether something is too "basic" to warrant consideration is entirely your construction. It is reactionary to dismiss oppressed peoples' self-descriptions of their oppressions. It would be progressive of you to listen to the oppressed and learn how to be a better ally. Do you want to be reactionary and backwards-thinking or progressive and forwards-thinking? How do you want to be remembered?

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by Retra on Thursday August 25, 2016 @11:18PM (#12364066)
Whether or not they can be traumatized is not the issue. If those things traumatize someone, they should be getting personal professional care, not wastefully burdening every institution and individual they interact with.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by jpfed on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:45PM (#12361384)
You don't need a trigger warning policy, necessarily. Just a culture that promotes being aware of common triggers. This notice goes in the opposite direction.

>It's an impossible task to list out and educate people on everything that might possible trouble or offend. Once you open that door, there is no finite end to a list of triggers.

It's not necessary to exhaust the full list. Analogously: it's impossible to list out and educate people on every form of negative externality, but we still have laws to address the big ones, and that helps.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by wang_li on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:06PM (#12361569)
What is really needed is the common sense and personal decision to get help with issues which are distressing so that reminders of those issues doesn't cause anxiety, stress, or a break-down.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by r_smart on Friday August 26, 2016 @11:27AM (#12366898)
>Just a culture that promotes being aware of common triggers.

I'd argue we pretty much already have this. Most people are aware of when a delicate topic is delicate and will treat it as such or avoid it, depending on the context. Trigger warnings seem to be a hammer in search of a nail, or more likely to me, something that was perhaps well intentioned at one point that is now just a means of attention seeking.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by bhickey on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:32PM (#12363294)
> While some trigger warning like the ones you mentioned are valid, the term has been perverted to include all sorts of things[0] where you could get in trouble for talking in public about insects or needles.

This is going to sound like a bad joke.

Fear of needles are more legitimate than might appear at first blush. Those of us with a needle phobia will experience a sudden drop in blood pressure, precipitating unconsciousness. In some cases this leads to death, making it one of the few phobias that can outright kill you.

I had the good fortune to undergo desensitization via allergy shots.