News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by __david__ on Thursday April 01, 2010 @11:08PM (#1235908)
Some people are really obsessed with dirt and germs. Some people aren't. Some people find legs stretched out is quite comfortable. Some people really don't care about your dumb hangups and like to be comfortable. Trying to say this is some passive aggressive dominance thing is really, really stretching.
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by sern on Thursday April 01, 2010 @11:30PM (#1235950)
I like to be comfortable and lying down is comfortable, but I don't take my bed in and lie down during a meeting. I like farting but I don't do it in people's faces. Wanking feels good too but I don't do it at work.

Do you really not see how abhorrent it is to be inconsiderate of other people? It may not be passive-aggressive but it's certainly rude.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by justin on Friday April 02, 2010 @12:29AM (#1236002)
Nice. This has me laughing so hard I'm crying.

In all seriousness, I think having a wank at work is a bit more off-putting than putting your feet up. I definitely can see how you'd think this was nasty, being totally anal about other, similar things, but what can I say? I'm just not thinking too hard about how whether I'm pissing someone off. Don't do it in a meeting with someone you're really trying to impress.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by evansolomon on Friday April 02, 2010 @01:28AM (#1236064)
I like drinking coffee, I do that at work. A nice big stretch from time to time is great, I do at least one each day at my desk. Several times each week I'll take off my glasses and rub my eyes a bit, I don't care who's around!

Sure, there are things you like to do that shouldn't be done at work, but the two are not correlated--or at least not as correlated as you suggest. While you've found some very amusing examples, they're tangentially relevant at best and used more for hyperbole, just like most of the article.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by aquateen on Friday April 02, 2010 @06:08AM (#1236247)
I can't make sense of this. What correlation are you talking about?
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by netcan on Friday April 02, 2010 @03:55AM (#1236171)
Why don't you explain why feet on table is a dumb hangup while farting is a rational one.
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by kelnos on Friday April 02, 2010 @06:27AM (#1236261)
Farting smells. Feet on the table doesn't (well, hopefully not).
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by btilly on Friday April 02, 2010 @11:43AM (#1236700)
Feet on the table can make people sick. Farting can't.
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by tjpick on Thursday April 01, 2010 @11:21PM (#1235931)
> Trying to say this is some passive aggressive dominance thing is really, really stretching.

True.

> Some people are really obsessed with dirt and germs. Some people aren't. Some people find legs stretched out is quite comfortable. Some people really don't care about your dumb hangups and like to be comfortable.

A poor excuse for bad manners.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by __david__ on Friday April 02, 2010 @01:16AM (#1236055)
Perhaps, if you consider the gesture to never be appropriate. But I think it is fine. I do think it is very casual and probably not appropriate in certain formal situations. And so perhaps it is "bad manners" merely by being overly casual in certain settings...
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by kelnos on Friday April 02, 2010 @06:31AM (#1236267)
Who said putting your feet up is bad manners? It may be overly casual, familiar, or informal, but that's only bad manners in a setting that requires formality or involves people with whom you aren't familiar.

Manners are relative, anyway. Some people think it's bad manners to put your elbows on the dining table. Others couldn't care less.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by twinwing on Friday April 02, 2010 @08:17AM (#1236329)
Who said putting your feet up is bad manners?

A sizable* chunk of society? We're talking about "social conducts or rules defined by society" here. They may make no sense, you may not like them, but you still have to live in a human and social world.

It may be overly casual, familiar, or informal

And I'm fine with that, just as long as you also understand it's unhygienic and, after being brought up to your attention, selfish (I'm comfortable) and inconsiderate (live with it).

*I do not have exact numbers, but judging from this thread, >15%?

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by kelnos on Saturday April 10, 2010 @06:47PM (#1255862)
> A sizable chunk of society? > I do not have exact numbers, but judging from this thread, >15%

1) 15% is a sizable chunk? Really? 2) Hacker News posters are about as unrepresentative a sample as you can get.

> And I'm fine with that, just as long as you also understand it's unhygienic and, after being brought up to your attention, selfish (I'm comfortable) and inconsiderate (live with it).

How unhygienic is it when compared with the conditions of the rest of the world around you that you interact with (voluntarily or otherwise) day by day? I don't know. I suspect you (and the blog poster) don't either. It may very well be that -- as usual -- humans are just really bad at risk analysis and stuff-from-feet just really isn't a big deal.

Regardless, it's been a week or so since this post, and I've been somewhat-consciously more aware of the situations where I put up my feet. I noticed that I never put my feet up on desks (that's kinda uncomfortable; I tried it [shoeless] out of curiosity), and never on conference tables (ditto?). My favorite kind of place to put up my feet is on one of the lower supports under a table. So it appears in general I avoid putting my feet up on the actual surface of things where people might put food, or put their hands, or rest their heads, etc.

Having said that, I put my feet on top of my coffee table in my living room all the time. But I never have my shoes on in my apartment, so at least that's something.

Still, though, I think the obsession some people have with "public hygiene" is a bit excessive. Being conscious of personal hygiene is great, but the world is a dirty, gross, germ-ridden place. Get used to it, or go around in a giant hamster ball.

On a side note, I noticed that quite a few posts here didn't present hygiene arguments. Many were from people of Indian or Middle-Eastern cultures where showing someone your feet is considered rude (a fact I was not aware of; thanks to HN for teaching me something new). Now, personally, knowing that, I would certainly avoid putting my feet up in front of people who may be culturally sensitive to that sort of thing. But, directed at people of those cultures: you're (presumably) in the US, or a place where your culture is not the dominant one. You have to understand that other cultures are different from yours, and people may not know that things they find innocuous will offend you. The onus is on you to be accommodating toward them, not the other way around. Just as when they are in your country, they should be sensitive of your culture.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by dschobel on Thursday April 01, 2010 @11:16PM (#1235925)
Yeah I don't know about the passive aggressiveness thing but it definitely shows a level of casualness that I'd be surprised to see in an interview or in a meeting with a potential investor.

We once had a candidate bust an apple out of his cargo pants in the middle of an interview and start chomping away.

While obviously we're not hiring people to be polite, it does show a certain level of social tone-deafness which often portends trouble down the road.

Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by nitrogen on Friday April 02, 2010 @03:40AM (#1236164)
Was the candidate diabetic or just inconsiderate?
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by TheSOB88 on Friday April 02, 2010 @10:07AM (#1236472)
Insulint bastard.
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by Confusion on Friday April 02, 2010 @03:22AM (#1236148)
Well, I think it definitely is a cultural thing. I've never seen anyone prop their feet up on a table during a meeting and judging from the appearance of the gesture in various kinds of videos, I don't think it is common anywhere in Europe at all. This means that any explanation that calls on something crosscultural like 'wanting to relax' falls short. There is something more behind it, even if no one that does it realizes it.
Re:Get Your Fucking Feet Off The Table by thomasz on Friday April 02, 2010 @04:58AM (#1236211)
> I don't think it is common anywhere in Europe at all.

It's considered very, very rude.