News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gene name errors are widespread in the scientific literature by Tomte on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @12:56AM (#12349770)
I almost lost it at "We hope the date and floating-point conversions will be made non-default options – in deference to the large bioinformatics and biotechnology communities if not for other users."

Sure, the vast biotech community outnumbers those few people who work in some other jobs (or use Excel for private stuff) and enter dates or floating point numbers.

Excel is trying to limit the effect of sloppiness on the part of laypeople. They usually don't set cell formatting to date or number. Excel really does the right thing there.

And if you're a scientist, presumably with a respectable degree and professional responsibilities, learn to use your tool correctly.

Nice how the correct ways to use Excel are listed as cumbersome workarounds.

Re:Gene name errors are widespread in the scientific literature by Dylan16807 on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @03:54AM (#12350441)
Turning SEPT2 into a date in the current year doesn't seem like really doing the right thing to me.
Re:Gene name errors are widespread in the scientific literature by golergka on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @06:41AM (#12351013)
In vast majority of real use cases, it certainly is. Microsoft has one of the greatest usability labs in the world; but they also have the broadest user base.
Re:Gene name errors are widespread in the scientific literature by Tomte on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @07:48AM (#12351302)
Why not?

1. Out of a thousand people entering "SEPT2", how many mean "September 2nd"?

2. How many of them use that shortcut intentionally?

3. How many people mean some gene?

My answers are:

1. almost all of them

2. A respectable part of those in 1.

3. A dozen?

Re:Gene name errors are widespread in the scientific literature by Dylan16807 on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @03:08PM (#12354452)
I would expect almost everyone meaning the date to not type the T, but maybe I'm just weird.

And far more than a dozen people mean the gene, come on.

And even if you want to type september second, trying to guess a year to attach is not the best idea.