News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by nibs on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:43PM (#12346851)
0-60 is what matters. Top speed is not a bottleneck anymore unless you are track racing. It has a 0-60 that is comparable to a Bugatti Veyron.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by cheeze on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:47PM (#12346882)
I'd argue that lap times are what matters.

Fastest is a broad term. I'd expect that "the fastest production car in the world" would have no problem winning a race at a majority of tracks.

"Fastest" has nothing to do with getting up to speed on the freeway.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by stcredzero on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:04PM (#12347066)
"Fastest" has nothing to do with getting up to speed on the freeway.

But for day to day driving, getting up to highway speed, and acceleration at passing speeds with good handling while doing so are what I actually need.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by serge2k on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:09PM (#12347112)
Okay, but then don't make comparisons to cars like the 918 and LaFerrari.

Or call it the fastest production car. Quickest maybe, even that is debateable. Quickest 0-60, sure.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by beachstartup on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:16PM (#12347179)
hey, the new tesla fanboys need something to cheer for. they're new to this whole racing-cars-on-the-internet thing.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by qbrass on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @05:31PM (#12347853)
At least they're not bragging about HP/Liter.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by asimuvPR on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:06PM (#12347078)
Fastest is commonly reserved for cars with the highest top speed. A fast track car is very different from that. You can have a car like a miata outpace a porsche 911 turbo on certain tracks.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by beachstartup on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:14PM (#12347162)
> You can have a car like a miata outpace a porsche 911 turbo on certain tracks

this is basically only true on an autocross track. i.e. a bunch of cones in a parking lot.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by asimuvPR on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:19PM (#12347209)
I wish that were true. Notice that I did not mention a stock miata or stock 911. A properly setup miata can and will outpace a modified 911 on certain tracks (not autocross). Of course, the driver is a key element, but will still happen with equal drivers.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by beachstartup on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:20PM (#12347227)
so, if you modify a cheap car, it can go faster than more expensive ones?

as per usual, a car thread on the internet that has yielded another set of incredible insights.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by asimuvPR on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @06:40PM (#12348363)
The issue with this snarky comment is that it fails to take into account the limits of modifying cheap cars. There are cheap cars that may be modified to go faster than an expensive one without modifying the original structure (no tube chassis). But not all cheap cars can achieve that. Only a small list of "cheap" cars can do so. Such as the miata, civic, mustang, etc. In fact, the word cheap is not even the right way to address these cars because price does not define a cars performance or potential.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by flamedoge on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:16PM (#12347183)
None of those matter really in day to day driving
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by untog on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:55PM (#12346958)
Eh. What "matters" is pretty debatable when it comes to cars. I very rarely accelerate from 0-60mph in one single acceleration, same as I rarely reach top speed.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by jonknee on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:56PM (#12346967)
Most people accelerate a lot more than they take a few laps on a track though...
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by forgetsusername on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:00PM (#12347026)
>Most people accelerate a lot more than they take a few laps on a track though...

Lap times give a better "all-around" indication of performance: speed, handling, acceleration.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by jonknee on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:07PM (#12347095)
For production cars top speed doesn't matter, after you get past highway speeds it is meaningless. Maybe it's me, but I'd rather a car that goes 0-60 really fast and can only go 100MPH than one that goes 0-60 slower but can go 200MPH.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by forgetsusername on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @06:15PM (#12348217)
And I'd like one that can corner on rails, which is arguably more valuable than both speed and acceleration (after all, acceleration, after a certain point, is also useless).

Hence why lap times are an interesting metric.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by Godel_unicode on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @05:57PM (#12348073)
This is the reason that the metrics I tend to look for are skidpad rating and 60-0 rating. Turning abruptly at high speed to avoid debris and braking abruptly from highway speeds are both things I do depressingly often.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by galdosdi on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:06PM (#12347076)
I often do, nearly every time I stop at a toll booth (toll roads, bridges, and tunnels are very common in my area -- I'm guessing they're uncommon in your area, lucky you).

(Of course, being able to do that really quickly, while fun, is not so /useful/ in real life, so it's still pretty debatable what "matters")

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by vonmoltke on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @06:01PM (#12348115)
I rarely do 0-60, but I do ~25-70 almost every day getting on highways.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by wtetzner on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:10PM (#12347118)
I find it very useful when merging onto busy roads that don't have a merging lane.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by FireBeyond on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:47PM (#12346886)
Except that they like to point out that the Porsche and Ferrari are "little 2 seaters with no cargo capacity" while the Tesla can carry seven passengers and has exceptional cargo capacity - well, without the passengers in the third row. And the fact that the 0-60 time was with only a driver on board, not the seven passengers + cargo, so it's a little unfair to call out the others for that.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by dragontamer on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:55PM (#12346962)
Cadillac CTS-V is the actual luxury vehicle Tesla is competing against.

Roughly the same price. CTS-V has significantly better laptimes on Laguna Seca (roughly 10-seconds faster) than Tesla's best lap times. Tesla has better 0-60 acceleration but that's about it.

CTS-V has better skidpad-tested turning radius, better braking, better suspension, etc. etc.

Porsche and Ferrari are high standards and all, but they're not commuter cars, nor are they luxury cars. They are race cars that have been converted into barely street-legal form. Its unfair to compare a Tesla against them... as the Tesla is a 4-door sedan.

--------------

Tesla S on Laguna Seca: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F8gJG-wkpdE

Cadillac CTS-V on Laguna Seca: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=la6BZ89Z6bs

Ford Focus ST ($25,000 lol wrong-wheel drive): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PW2rOUFCcyo

Someone claimed a 1:45 time with the Tesla S (maybe it was one of the faster models?), which is the fastest time I'm aware of. But still not close to the 1:38 time of the CTS-V.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by walrus01 on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:47PM (#12347476)
I really don't think the people who buy Teslas would otherwise be buying Cadillacs. The Tesla P90D and similar are competing against the top option package BMW 7-series, Audi A8 and similar.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by dragontamer on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:58PM (#12347571)
The Tesla P90D is $107,700 AFTER the federal credits.

The Cadillac CTS-V starts at $85k, while the normal CTS is around $45k. BMW 7-series is also around $85k with electric / hybrid models flirting $100k.

Tesla is definitely in a higher price class, but not much higher. I think its a fair comparison price-wise and feature wise.

Both the Cadillac CTS and the Tesla S are "fast" sedans with spacious interiors and cost upwards from $50,000+, with racing versions (either the CTS-V or P90D "Ludicrous") just around $100k.

---------

I can agree that the BMW 7-series counts as a competitor, but it isn't considered by anyone to be a "fast" vehicle. Aimed at more luxury. The Tesla 0-60 score has always been front-and-center as part of marketing... as has been the CTS-V.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by mrfusion on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:10PM (#12347119)
Interesting. I'd think the Teslas low center of gravity would be a boost to handling too.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by dragontamer on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:12PM (#12347134)
Tesla's 4500lb curb-weight because of a 2000lb battery is a severe disadvantage. The Tesla weighs the same as an F-150 TRUCK, no lie.

An ICE car zips-around the corner with literally a thousand-pounds lighter than the electric-based Tesla. In fact, the Tesla S barely performs any better than $30k hot-hatchbacks like the Ford Focus ST or Subaru Impreza WRX. (Both of which are 4-door 5-seater sedans for a daily driver)

----------

When you get to $50,000+ ultra-luxury cars, they all have awesomely low center of gravity and optimized suspensions. IMO, it all comes down to weight for why the Tesla fails to perform on the track.

Also, the battery IIRC overheats if held in "Ludicrous" mode too long. The ICE engine virtually never overheat and can be revved high for many laps at a time.

I've heard of more issues of ICE Cars where brakes overheat... forcing the car to stop the track early... rather than the engine overheating. Tesla batteries can output a lot of power, but only for a limited time. I don't know if that "limited time" is one or two laps, but its apparently an issue.

Performance cars don't necessarily all perform well on a track. The Ford Focus ST allegedly has brakes overheat after just a few laps for example. Although, its like they say: front-wheel drive is wrong-wheel drive in these sorts of high-performance comparisons.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by arcticfox on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:50PM (#12346914)
Not really unfair IMO. They're just pointing out the enormous relative versatility of the car.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by FireBeyond on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:00PM (#12347025)
Not playing down the versatility of the car at all. But it's very apples and oranges if you're saying on one hand the Tesla is "better" because of the additional capacity, when both the Porsche/Ferrari were tested using exactly the same capacity as the Tesla (i.e. "a driver"), and saying "but this can carry seven people" without "at quite a lower speed"...

But it's a press release, so it is what it is.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by mikeash on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:50PM (#12347499)
Not at all. They're saying that you can use the same car for hauling the family on vacation as you use to go 0-60 in 2.5 seconds, where with one of these other cars you'd need to buy two separate vehicles. They're in no way implying that the car does both things simultaneously.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by serge2k on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:54PM (#12346956)
The ferrari and porsche aren't meant to be versatile. They will beat the Tesla every time at what they are meant to do.

On the other hand, the Tesla is a much better family sedan.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by tanderson92 on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:07PM (#12347093)
That their purpose isn't to be versatile isn't a point in favor of their versatility. Tesla still wins this point as a net, regardless whether it matters to you personally.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by serge2k on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:17PM (#12347195)
It's like saying a multitool is more versatile than a hammer. It's true, but a multitool still makes a shitty hammer. If I want a hammer and you hand me a multitool I'm gonna be disappointed.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by jsprogrammer on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @03:57PM (#12346979)
The exposition of the relatively versatile features was placed in the same paragraph as the acceleration claim. You'd expect the two to reconcile.

However, according to the disclaiming asterisk, the acceleration claim hasn't even been tested and is only an estimate, making the title claim particularly dubious.

Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by robotresearcher on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @02:32AM (#12350138)
The Tesla has a trunk in the front, too. Where the IC engine would be.
Re:New Tesla Model S Now the Quickest Production Car by cowardlydragon on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:46PM (#12347467)
Americans buy horsepower and drive torque.