I agree (re: favoring Apple's model). Whether server or mobile, there'll be fewer SKUs, and those that exist need to be blockbuster hits.
It may well be that economics is the limiting factor stopping Intel's long run, not the physically limiting properties.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm
by nordsieck on Monday August 22, 2016 @06:19AM
(#12335253)
Intel actually has very few designs. Most of the variety comes from frequency binning and post-test functional unit deactivation as a means of salvaging otherwise defective parts.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm
by digi_owl on Monday August 22, 2016 @03:53AM
(#12334749)
Same as with "peak oil" then. Its not that we run out of physically extractable oil, but that the cost of doing so will curtail our current usage of the substance.
Its pretty much the inverse of the Jevon paradox (or maybe that everything has a bell curve, and we are so focused on the left half we forget its mirror on the right).
Actually, people are looking forward to a long period where a certain node, "20" something nm (not Intel's 20 something), becomes so standard that economies of scale result in it being the one most entities use for their designs, especially non-mobile or otherwise seriously power constrained.
I gather we're already sort of there, with wafer costs in the $5,000 or so range, the trick is of course to limit the NRE to something you can afford. The lowRISC project is going this route, I learned much of this starting from their future production plans.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm
by sliverstorm on Monday August 22, 2016 @12:22AM
(#12334088)
Wafer cost goes up, just not as fast as transistor count, which is why Moore's law holds.
So basically with every node improvement, the "design" cost increase at around 50% - 100%. This heavily flavours Apple's model. You will have to sell a lot more SoCs to balance out that $500M design cost for leading node. Apart from the design cost, does anyone know if the Wafer cost increase as well? And at what rate does it increase per node?
Thinking this in Intel's scale, PC Industry is shrinking in unit, the CPU die size is also getting smaller to keep up with Intel's profit margin. at what point does the cost increase sway the balance to other Foundry's flavour, when Intel 's unit sales takes longer to recoup the cost then TSMC.