News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by Amezarak on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:13PM (#12316005)
The trouble with lobbying is - where do you draw the line?

Do I, an individual citizen, have a right to petition my elected representatives?

Do I, an individual citizen, have a right to organize with fellow citizens to petition my elected representatives?

Do I, an individual citizen, who owns a business, have a right to organize with fellow citizens who own similar businesses to petition my representatives?

The problem with lobbying is a fundamental issue with representative democracy, not with the American political system. Lobbying by monied interests is simply more overt in the American system. I can't think of a Western democracy where industry interests don't have a huge say in the legislative and even executive processes. From the perspective of the politician, they are looking out for their constituents by helping out industrial interests, because in their eyes, that means jobs and development.

I agree there is a huge problem with the outsized influence of industry in the political realm, but I think it's a very complicated problem to untangle. The only way we have to fight it is to organize ourselves, which is usually extremely difficult.

Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by milcron on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:29PM (#12316102)
Lobbying as a citizen who happens to own a business is different from a business itself lobbying. I'm perfectly fine with the former.
Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by Karunamon on Thursday August 18, 2016 @05:17PM (#12316388)
But then you somehow need to encode that belief into law in a way that doesn't trample on the constitution.

And maybe this is a bug in the system, but trying to fix it has some truly scary question marks attached.

Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by milcron on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:53PM (#12316860)
I don't think this boundary would be that difficult to delineate and enforce. Political donations ought to come from personal bank accounts rather than corporate ones. Is it any more difficult than that?
Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by Amezarak on Thursday August 18, 2016 @08:37PM (#12317262)
So then you don't believe individuals have the right to organize to petition their representatives? Because any organization is going to mean pooling resources into a legal structure...like a corporation.
Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by milcron on Saturday August 20, 2016 @03:38PM (#12328017)
That's a good quibble. People should be allowed to organize. I suppose there should be a distinction between political organizations and profitable ones.

So a group "Whigs for America" pooling donations is fine, but a for-profit corporation spending millions on lobbying would not be fine.

The difference being that the former group is a non-profit collection of people concerned about some aspect of government.

Whereas when for-profit entities funnel millions into lobbying, and we get profit-oriented results like this http://abcnews.go.com/Business/turbotax-lobbies-lawmakers-ta...

Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by dredmorbius on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:43PM (#12316823)
There's nothing about the US Constitution that says that different elements of it don't conflict. The question precisely is working out where boundaries exist, and what trade-offs to make.
Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by Karunamon on Friday August 19, 2016 @10:04AM (#12320057)
No, but changing the constitution is not a minor affair. You can't just propose one amendment through the legislative process, you have to launch a convention, and the country you get on the other side of that may not have much in common with the country now.
Re:Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons by Amezarak on Friday August 19, 2016 @06:30PM (#12323975)
You certainly can change the Constitution without a convention. The federal legislature passes it with a 2/3rds vote and then the states ratify it.