News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by makecheck on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @09:08PM (#12309759)
Also, I think that replies accompanying down-votes should be displayed directly next to the comment as a sort of tag (i.e. you can’t click a down-arrow alone, you have to type out something like “not accurate” or “flame” or “I don’t like his hair” or whatever the reason is) and then the comment appears as: foobar_user 1 hour ago | -1:“not accurate” -1:“flame” -1:“I don’t like his hair”.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by enraged_camel on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:21AM (#12310720)
I think providing short reasons isn't enough. If you wrote a long post and I downvoted it with "not accurate" it doesn't help much, does it?
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by nkurz on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:48AM (#12310973)
"Not accurate" may be useful feedback even if it's false. For example, perhaps several such responses in a row would prompt the author to link to supporting data, or reword their comment to be clearer. The real question though isn't whether it's always helpful, but whether on average it's more useful than just a bare downvote. While some of the responses will be "not accurate", others will be an extremely actionable "link broken" or "missing word".

I think the real issue of requiring comments on downvotes is that it would either disallow anonymous downvotes, or encourage anonymous comments. Perhaps de-anonymizing downvotes without requiring a comment might be a better first step: if you aren't brave enough to have your name associated with the downvote, then maybe you shouldn't be downvoting. I'm sure this would cause its own problems, but I suspect it would be a net positive. At times I think it might even be good to have all voting and flagging actions on HN to be public record.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by JustUhThought on Thursday August 18, 2016 @08:51AM (#12312078)
If I add a comment I jnow will be downvoted I simply move on with my day, not bothering to see the responses generated. This is because, even though I work hard to only put forth constructive criticism and in a manner such that my logic / reasoning is plainly spelled out,,,

On HN, unpopular comments are, often, still voted down despite the facts and despite the presentation.

I usually reserve these instances for when I know more than a little on the topic, generally professionally speaking, and often first hand. But, if it is unpopular, it doesn't matter. It's predictable.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by gaius on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:13AM (#12310868)
Like Slashdot, if you remember that, +1 Insightful etc etc
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by michaelmrose on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @11:18PM (#12310212)
I really love your idea
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by ec109685 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @12:58AM (#12310493)
It's like slack reactions.