News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by e40 on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @03:51PM (#12307814)
It depends on the subreddit. There are many where civil conversation is the norm. r/politics and places like that are horrible. Just remove them from your default set.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by overcast on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @03:57PM (#12307874)
You know, I get this response every time I talk about this topic. I really dislike the "well no one is making you use / buy / watch / listen" to something. People can be critical of something they want to succeed. It happens a lot in certain game communities. What if I WANT to talk about politics, in a civil manner? Any sufficiently popular subreddit, just devolves into complete trash.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by wutbrodo on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:09PM (#12307996)
> You know, I get this response every time I talk about this topic. I really dislike the "well no one is making you use / buy / watch / listen" to something. People can be critical of something they want to succeed. It happens a lot in certain game communities. What if I WANT to talk about politics, in a civil manner? Any sufficiently popular subreddit, just devolves into complete trash.

You're missing the point of e40's response (and others of its kind). It's not "stop whining, don't use it if you don't like it". It's informing you that there are still parts of Reddit you can get value out of if you change your usage patterns a little bit, instead of your blunt-instrument approach that leads to losing gems like (e.g.) /r/AskHistorians just because /r/politics is terrible. There's of course nothing _wrong_ with you deciding that Reddit overall isn't worth the effort, but there's nothing wrong with someone giving you an alternative in case you were unaware.

When Reddit blew up in popularity, almost everyone I know who'd used it for a long time got sick of the default feed (both submissions and comments) and then at some point found out that being parsimonious in your subreddit subscriptions can give you a pretty high-quality feed. Reacting with defensiveness and hostility to someone giving you that advice in case you didn't know is frankly just bizarre.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:21PM (#12308107)
That's probably due to the nature of politics.

It certainly tends to get a lot of people riled quite easily.

What's that thing about polite company not talking about politics, religion, or sex.

The average person, myself definitely included, probably doesn't have much worth listening to on the subject anyway. To paraphrase PJ O'Rourke: though there certainly are many political commentators who might be worth listing to. Under some circumstances. In a crisis. Maybe.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by guelo on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @06:53PM (#12309095)
One of the issues that makes political discussions extra toxic is that because there are hundreds of millions of dollars spent on propaganda using the most sophisticated psychological techniques available everybody is full of outrage-inducing hatreds against "the other side". This makes it really hard to have a constructive exchange of ideas without falling into a minefield of unexamined, implanted mental prejudices, even if you try really hard.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by tbihl on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @10:32PM (#12310059)
My least popular comment ever was downvoted for trying to point out the problem with assuming that the people who fought against the healthcare bill are the same ones who hate the idea of SS/Medicare reform. Are we really so camp-y in our politics that you can just assume that the people who don't like something you like are on 'the other side', and that we can ascribe the opposite of all our other preferences to those people as well?
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by sotojuan on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:52PM (#12308369)
It's not just r/politics—that's just one example.

r/programming is another good example. The community there is very hostile and actively downvote and hate on most new things that aren't C++/Java/.NET/Python sometimes. It's been stereotyped as a bunch of overly angry .NET/Java devs, not sure how accurate that is but the angry part is right. It's just a waste of time.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by rjbwork on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:23PM (#12308588)
I think it's grown that way over time. Used to be very focused on functional and dynamic languages back in the day. Hell, Perl was the hot topic back in 2005-2007 era reddit.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by overcast on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:34PM (#12308669)
Right, which just reinforces my initial statements above. Popularity breeds trash. Forums move from a small group of passionate users, to general population. This is where quality deteriorates quickly.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by overcast on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:33PM (#12308234)
It's just not politics, it's anything sufficiently popular to attract a large portion of the general public. Only niche categories, with a small group of passionate people work. Otherwise, it turns into a free for all.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by pvdebbe on Thursday August 18, 2016 @05:03AM (#12311211)
Agree. Only the small subreddits with a tight focus work for me.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by rndmize on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:33PM (#12308656)
Not so (imo). The neutralpolitics subreddit has grown continually for some years now, especially in the last 12 months, and I'd say that the moderators are doing a solid job of maintaining appropriate discussion and keeping things where they were intended at the start: rational, sourced, with a heavy hand on emotional content and personal attacks.

Similarly, I dropped r/gaming years ago, but r/games has been reliable enough and good enough for such a period that it's evolved into my default place I look for gaming news. (The League of Legends subreddit also does pretty well on content and moderation, for something running at the scale of some of the defaults).

The problem I have with reddit, usually, is discovery - its difficult to find subreddits that are popular enough not to be dead, have the content I want, and are managed in good fashion to prevent the usual content/comment trash.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by iamdave on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:28PM (#12308184)
/r/politicaldiscussion was created as a response to the malarkey that has become /r/politics and they place an emphasis on civil, reasoned debate. May be worth your time.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by overcast on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:33PM (#12308225)
Thanks, just over Reddit in general. Quit about a year ago.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by iamdave on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:34PM (#12308240)
Can't really say I blame you. Found any other interesting communities other than HN, obviously since we're both here?
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by overcast on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @04:45PM (#12308326)
Not really, spending my time on side projects, and hiking.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by deathhand on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:11PM (#12308510)
I don't think this comment adds to the discussion at all. The comment is actually a great microcosm to the dearth of comment quality. 1)You would never know about this reply unless you sought it out. 2) Once you replied to it you said nothing of value to anyone. You even threw in an off topic item. Let me guess, you don't have a TV either? Perhaps you are a vegan....

This is what is flawed about comments. It becomes an ego circle jerk...Which is necessary to even generate comments in the first place ("oo look how much Karma I get") but ultimately destroys a conversation.

Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments by sn9 on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @07:21PM (#12309279)
As a very rough heuristic, it seems that subreddits with subscriber counts below about 10,000 seem to be able to maintain what makes them great (if they can be said to be great) without moderation.

You have a much higher percentage of users who are deeply interested in the raison d'être of the subreddit.

Beyond that, you either need moderation or have to make a new sub.