Re:The Write Stuff: How the Humble Pencil Conquered the World
by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @03:49PM
(#12307795)
And as I've pointed out at times previous when that claim's been made: there are companies whose annual revenues exceed many nations.
WalMart has an annual income of $482 billion.[1]
That's more than the annual GDP of Poland, as measured by the World Bank, the 25th largest economy in the world, and of Belgium, the Philippines, Thailand, Norway, Iran, Austria, the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, South Africa, Hong Kong, Malaysia, ... and 153 other countries (163 total) in the world.[2]
Re:The Write Stuff: How the Humble Pencil Conquered the World
by mseebach on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:31PM
(#12308645)
I think the reason that can work is that (the vast bulk of) Walmart is entirely dedicated to executing on a single, very well defined (and easy to measure) task - their supply chain.
Unfortunately, few problems in the world are like that, and that's why large companies (and governments) fail to address them effectively.
But the fundamental point of "I, Pencil" (and the intellectual tradition it's part of) is that you can't plan the economy at large. It's becoming increasingly clear that you probably can't even plan a single company once it's over a certain size (the essay seems to touch on that point, but doesn't really follow through). It's not that private companies or markets are better at planning, it's that the sheer inherent complexity of an economy is so large that any kind of effective planning is impossible.