Money (for the school) is a more likely explanation, as I argue elsewhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12298579
I had a friend that skipped a grade, and the age difference affected her. She was 17 in her first year of college, unable to fully participate, for example. Many kids that are held back a year find other sorts of problems as well - sexual maturity and hormones a year ahead of their classmates, for example.
The other problem i've seen with "advanced" students is complete seperation from other students, with the implicit expectation that the students should be more mature because they were smart. One school system did this from a young age, and in high school there were multiples that simply had trouble socializing with 'normal' students. Really had a detrimental effect on some of them.
I would approve of specialized sorts of schedules for such 10 year olds, however. Part of the day in the classes needed for their level, while going back to enjoy the other classes with their emotional and developmental peers. Art, music, physical education, lunch, recess, and some of the reading (after all, it would be fun stories at an emotional level they understand), etc. Perhaps even special advanced classes with a lighter homework load designed for the advanced student, for example, could be worked in.
I did occasionally get in to some 'trouble' with 'peers' (not really my peers, but others in the school) being 'advanced'.
Example: 4th grade - teacher gets sick - our class is split in to 2 to go sit with 5th grade classes for the last 2 hours of school. "just sit and read". Fine... but the 5th grade teacher was covering math lessons, and was asking questions - "who knows ... (fill in the blank)?". Silence in the room, except for me raising my hand. "I know!" She was thinking I wanted to leave the room, and kept ignoring me, until I spoke the answer. Pissed off the other 9-11 year old kids having a 8 year old answer their math questions (it was something to do with fractions).
I got a scratch-n-sniff pine tree sticker for my answer, and was told to keep reading my book and not disturb the class any more...
Still had that sticker until a few years ago (it didn't smell any more).
I was not prepared to socialize well with either group of people: I was an odd duck in both groups. The place I found best to socialize with was with the Quick Recall-type kids, or with those who could have gotten into college a little early. The socialization argument cuts both ways.
Prior to middle school / junior high (starting usually between 6th and 8th grade, depending on the particular school system), the norm in the US isn't to have distinct subject-matter classes, but classrooms with a single teacher for all subjects for one grade, which may not use a strict fixed allotment of time slots for each subject, and even where they do it may not be the same time slot for the same subject area in different classrooms in different grades in the same school (and even the set of subjects may change somewhat in different grades.)
This makes per-subject variations in grade level for a student logistically difficult to accommodate.
OTOH, once you get to middle school with per-subject classes being the norm, this is fairly easy to accommodate, and its just a scheduling and resource problem (e.g., in a middle school, do you have enough qualified students to support a Calculus class) at that level.
I suspect uniform testing at 'grade level' becomes harder to use for comparisons against other schools.
The only way I would expect to see that is if the school was tailoring all of those subjects to a certain kind of student. Which, admittedly, is common. But I'm talking about a more universal advancement system where Art 12 really is for level-12 artists, not level-12 math students who want to do something that resembles art, and be graded on effort.
The nice thing about such a system is you wouldn't have to cater Art-12 to advanced level history students just to keep their GPAs up. Those students could stay in Art 4, and get their A there, while the Art-12 students were subject to the higher standard that really only they could handle. You could expect them to spend 20 hours a week in the studio, which would be unreasonable for a student carrying a full coursework burden in another field. And you could even put that burden on 10-year-olds who were ready for it, of which there are some.
Or, you know, the kid is just more competent. All people may be created morally equal, but they aren't created equal in competence, even in some kind of "advantages in one area are balanced by deficits in others" way.
> To some extent competence is a zero-sum game.
No, its not. (Also, being zero-sum is absolutely binary -- either a thing is zero-sum or its not. It can't be zero-sum "to some extent". It can have tradeoffs to some extent and not be zero-sum, which is the nearest it can get to that.)
> The likelihood that a student is operating at above-typical levels in sports, art, math, and journalism seems small to me.
Yes, students that are above grade level across the board areas will be less common than those that are above grade level in a narrower domain. (Competence is generally a product of innate factors and effort, and even though the innate factors are correlated across disciplines -- general intelligence applies to most, and correlates with talents in others -- effort may or may not be.)
> either a thing is zero-sum or its not.
A game can have both a zero sum component and an unbounded component. Only one person can win the presidency, but everyone who runs can get a reputation boost.
Learning how to shoot free throws might improve your saxophone playing, but 8 hours a day in the practice room could take away from your knowledge of literature.
I was pushed ahead a grade, and as a result, was always a year or two behind everyone else physically, so, almost by definition, I was always "behind" in gym/phys-ed classes, but there wasn't much I could do about that. Looking back, I was normal/average for my age, but not for my 'grade', and had a tough time with that.
I think the term for students like that is "Ivy material" -- or at least, it used to be.