News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Large Percentages of American Students Perform Above Grad... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @02:10PM (#12299332)
> If there's a kid who is ahead at everything, the material is not diverse enough.

Or, you know, the kid is just more competent. All people may be created morally equal, but they aren't created equal in competence, even in some kind of "advantages in one area are balanced by deficits in others" way.

> To some extent competence is a zero-sum game.

No, its not. (Also, being zero-sum is absolutely binary -- either a thing is zero-sum or its not. It can't be zero-sum "to some extent". It can have tradeoffs to some extent and not be zero-sum, which is the nearest it can get to that.)

> The likelihood that a student is operating at above-typical levels in sports, art, math, and journalism seems small to me.

Yes, students that are above grade level across the board areas will be less common than those that are above grade level in a narrower domain. (Competence is generally a product of innate factors and effort, and even though the innate factors are correlated across disciplines -- general intelligence applies to most, and correlates with talents in others -- effort may or may not be.)

Re:Large Percentages of American Students Perform Above Grad... by erikpukinskis on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @02:17PM (#12299385)
I appreciate your different perspective on the matter. One quibble:

> either a thing is zero-sum or its not.

A game can have both a zero sum component and an unbounded component. Only one person can win the presidency, but everyone who runs can get a reputation boost.

Learning how to shoot free throws might improve your saxophone playing, but 8 hours a day in the practice room could take away from your knowledge of literature.