I had a physics teacher in high school who came from Russia and was always frustrated at the lower standards for science education here in the U.S. He would describe what people in Russia were supposed to know by a particular grade level and it was commonly years ahead of Americans -- and he claimed students were expected to take much more time studying overall (although that's not necessarily always useful, and there are presumably also many different kinds of schools in Russia, as there are in the U.S.).
We can surely find some possible tradeoffs and disadvantages of particular educational methods and approaches used in other countries. (People often complain about the rote-memorization issue with the associated lack of conceptual understanding or creativity, and, when we see very difficult educational materials from earlier eras in the U.S., there's the observation that students then may have had to learn many fewer subjects at a time.) But it seems like there's a lot of indication that huge numbers of U.S. students could be learning at a more challenging pace than they are today.
Then again, my US undergrad is probably pretty atypical. My school had very heavy core requirements (at least for engineering), so you had a lot of classes each semester. It tends to be a top-ranked US school, but the classes really weren't very challenging, and because of how many we took, they never seemed to go into much depth.
On another note, it's not often that I reminisce longingly on my childhood, but that's exactly what happened while I was doing Cheryl's birthday. My favorite things growing up were math and logic puzzles in their pure forms, un-obscured by the tedium that accompanies them in real life. I remember Math 24 from Elementary school, Math Counts in middle school, and some brain teasers and logic puzzles sprinkled throughout both times. If you're needing some for late elementary children, I highly recommend "The Lady or The Tiger and Other Logic Puzzles"
For example my school had been admitting everyone for the grades 1-8 but for grades 9-10 there had been a math test. I think about a dozen out of 70 eight graders made to the 9th grade in the same school and the rest had to go to other schools. The class had been replenished with students from elsewhere who also passed the test and went on with 15 hours of math lessons (and 40 hours of homework) per week for the grades 9-10. I don't think something like this could fly in the USA.
The average American who learns a second language also lacks the ability/need to use that language day to day, so even if they do learn, they'll rapidly lose proficiency once they leave school.
There are some secondary benefits from learning a second language [1]. But learning Spanish outside of a few areas in the US brings little direct benefit. There just aren't enough Spanish speakers who don't also speak English in the vast majority of the US.
Furthermore, Immigration from Mexico is falling off, and the percent of Hispanic households who speak English at home is rapidly rising. This means that any direct benefit to learning Spanish will diminish over time.
>If anything, they'd be able to use spanish language programming to help them learn. Which is ironically the same sorts of things that younger kids from other countries learning english have to learn from.
Not even remotely comparable. The amount of material available only in English dwarfs the material available only in Spanish.
To sum up, sure kids in American can learn Spanish, and many do. But there are real tangible and financial benefits to learning English as a second language that dwarf any of the benefits American kids get from learning Spanish. Once you recognize that, it makes perfect sense that Americans are more likely to be monolingual.
[1] Studies show, there are cognitive benefits to bilingualism, but they also show there are benefits to monolingualism. Usually you'll find more benefits to bilingualism over all, but larger single-language vocabulary and faster retrieval time are definitely advantageous. Studies also don't show that the cognitive benefits of learning a second language outweigh the cognitive opportunity costs of studying something else instead.
Additionally, the majority of these cognitive benefits are recorded in children and adults who spent a fair amount of time speaking in both languages. It's unlikely that learning a language in school and then forgetting it later will have the same beneficial effects.
I'm originally from Indiana, and lived there until 3 years ago, upon which I moved to Norway. I lived in small to medium sized towns, and would have found it to be a benefit for many jobs, especially low-paying or lower-management jobs. I imagine it is the same for much of the midwest, the south, and the southwest. You are correct on the immigration from mexico, however, and it may bring dimishing returns as time goes on.
> The amount of material available only in English dwarfs the material available only in spanish. You don't need the same amount of material, nor do you need only available in spanish. You just have to find the material. Harry Potter is generally a good series to read when learning a foreign language because it is available in so many, for example. Outside of English, however, spanish language television and reading material is one of the easier to obtain in the US. Norwegian, for example, is a little trickier to find as it isn't nearly as widespread.
English is one of the 'special' languages, and a lot of languages don't compare - it is used as a unifying language in a lot of professions. It really, really helps me here in Norway, especially since there is a high fluency rate here (Console games and adult movies generally aren't translated, for example). I'm pretty lucky that English is my primary language.
Sidenote: I generally think the advantages to bilingualism are greater. Especially if they teach people a different way of looking at the world, which is somewhat the main benefit of a second language. At that point, however, it doesn't matter which language one learns. Klingon would probably work just as well for such cognitive effects. This sort of thing really shouldn't go away, even if the language was forgotten.
I think you may be overestimating the benefit. When I worked as a retail supervisor in college, we paid $0.25 more if you spoke one of a few different languages. It never really made much difference when hiring. I also had many Spanish speaking friends in lower paying jobs and apart from 1 who worked as a hospital translator there wasn't much financial benefit.
If you take the amount of time that it takes to become proficient (and keep proficiency), you'd be much better off spending that time on something more lucrative. From a purely financial perspective, after factoring in opportunity costs, I think that learning Spanish probably has a negative ROI.
>This sort of thing really shouldn't go away, even if the language was forgotten.
We don't really know that though. We need more evidence before we base start taking action here. It could be that learning the violin would have more benefit. Learning a new language is romantic, we can't let that romanticism impact policy decisions.
And my guess is that to get most of the benefits of bilingualism, you have to get to the point where you spend time thinking in both languages. I don't think classroom instruction is ever going to get you to that level.
That's very true today. It wasn't true just 20 and 30 years ago. The Spanish speaking population in the US has skyrocketed in that time. In 1980 for example, the US was about 82% white and almost exclusively English speaking. That's a very rapid cultural change, shifting from a few percent Spanish speaking to 1/4 in just three decades. I'd suggest that over the next 20 years it will be very beneficial for children to be taught Spanish (and they likely will be), however the near-past value of it was not remotely as high as it is now and will become. The point being, it takes time for a nation to adjust to such a rapid change, you're not going to get hundreds of millions of people - across very diverse (in every sense) education zones - to shift to all knowing Spanish in 10 or 15 years.
Where are you getting that? The current percent of native Spanish speakers in the US is only about 13%, and the majority of them also speak English.
Immigration from Mexico has dropped off and the number of Americans of Hispanic descent who speak only English at home is rapidly increasing.
Virtually all immigrant children learn English in school, so it's very likely that the benefits of learning Spanish will decrease over time not increase. Historically the 3rd generation of US immigrants speak only English, and the current trends suggest that will happen with Hispanic immigrants as well.
Mostly due to the recent US economic downturn and the poor distribution of the returns of the subsequent aggregate expansion beyond the upper classes. That's probably not a durable trend unless the US economy continues to be miserable for all but the elites.
Mexico is only about 1/3 the size of the US and surveys indicate only 1/3 of Mexican adults have any desire to come to the US at all.
Of those people, only half indicated willingness to come illegally and given that fact that they haven't done it yet, you can assume most of them won't. (This matters because there are limits on the number of legal immigrants)
Assuming all Mexicans who are willing to actually make the journey here make it, and adding in immigrants from other Spanish speaking countries, it's still not enough to overcome the historical trend towards language assimilation.
Not only do they understand dialects well and learn both official types of Norwegian, they are expected to understand Danish and Swedish. They start learning English their first year in school, and many wind up taking an additional language in high school.
There is no homework in elementary school (and less at higher levels), no grades, and no holding kids back a grade. The school days are shorter. If a kid is needing help, there are programs to help them catch up. A smart kid will make good grades (and work for them): Average actually means average, and that is OK. Good marks mean a kid is learning over and above what is expected of them. If too many students are getting high marks (instead of average) on the national tests, they adjust the tests so they are harder.
A few kids find school boring, but the system itself leaves room for kids to excel as well as makes provisions for those that aren't - which seems like one of the fallbacks of the American system. You are expected to make A's and B's and there simply isn't room for the high acheiver to work for anything.
> A smart kid will make good grades
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Norway#Primary_sc... says, of primary school:
> No official grades are given at this level. However, the teacher often writes a comment, analysis, and sometimes an unofficial grade on tests. Tests are to be taken home and shown to parents. There is also an introductory test to let the teacher know if the student is above average or is in need of some assistance at school.
> ... When the students enter lower secondary school, at age 12 or 13, they begin getting grades for their work.
Quick, what year did the french revolution start and end?
I said "No, what would even be the point of that? You'll just forget it afterwards."
Then I asked him if they ever discussed the meaning of the text in class. He said they did not.
The East Asian system gets a few things right. We definitely could give students more challenging material (especially in math and science), but the focus on rote learning and endless drudgery (they get soooo much homework) is not something I'm too keen on being introduced here.
http://condor.depaul.edu/sepp/mat660/Askey.pdf
(I can well believe, however, that any current with a current one-party dictatorial government, something Taiwan had the first time I lived there and something China still has today, will lag in teaching history. Critical thinking about history is bad for dictators. Taiwan thoroughly revised the history textbooks after it had its peaceful transition to democracy.)
Multiparty liberal democracies allow much more scope for debating and interpreting history, but they still commonly encourage a teleological interpretation that glorifies the nation and its current political system.
I also get the feeling that understanding history in a meaningful way is hard, and that educational systems generally aren't making much headway against this problem, maybe somewhat independently of how much debate or criticism they permit. One difficulty is the conscious and semiconscious propagandization of many historical issues by many parties, together with the desire to see historical figures or groups we identify with in a positive light and those we don't identify with in a negative light. Another thing is the truth of the "past is a foreign country" observation:
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/L._P._Hartley
Getting inside of the minds and cultures of people from the past is really difficult!
I could go on, but I don't think most people got US #1 outside of being an economic powerhouse.
My Chinese friends would laugh when i asked them if that was true. They said that sure they covered it, but they just memorized algorithms, and no one really understood the concepts.
I don't think that looking at math textbooks is going to tell you all that much about the way math is actually taught. You're not going to see any of the official and unofficial performance incentives that can alter the way material is taught.
I want to say the 1790s and the 1850s. But I can't get more precise than that. In my mind, they're sort of just after the American Revolution and just before the USA-CSA Civil War. And then there was the little failed rebellion in between that was in Les Miserables.
There was also a bunch of Napoleon in there, somewhere. But knowing any of that has had no use for me, other than keeping the plot straight in novels set in that era.
Sorry, I have a compulsion to answer questions that start with "Quick"
Edit: Wikipedia says 1789 to 1799. I was close on the dates but wrong about Napoleon (whom ultimately lost in 1814).
If you have 24 kids total in the district, then maybe you put them all in one classroom regardless of age and teach that way. If you have 300 kids in the school district now you can do separate classes for each age. If you have 900 kids, now each grade can have 3 classes and maybe one of them in each grade can be set aside for advanced students and one for slower students. If you have 25,000 kids in the district, now you can start doing things like an entire G&T school, and/or a school for the students interested in performing arts, and/or a specialized vocational high school.
Unfortunately, the trend in the US is towards micro-catchment areas mostly as a legacy of racial segregation efforts and because of the continuing desire to have socio-economic segregation.
In third grade, I was in a mixed third/fourth grade classroom. It may have been the least boring year I spent in elementary school, although frankly that isn't a high bar to clear.
The school is 500' away. Now, his son is too young to just walk on his own, but that's a couple of minutes to get him to school.
When I was in high school (early 00s) my school was 1.7 miles, had to walk further than 500' to get to the city bus stop (or just walk/bike).
So?
Oh my god, I'm such a bad person for only speaking English. How can I suffer such a life. /s
But I agree with your point, the challenge offered by schools is too low.
https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/education/report/201...
On my part, having lived in another country (Taiwan), I have long suspected that most United States pupils could handle more challenging school lessons, if only those were on offer in United States schools. For example, in almost every other country in the world, it is routine for pupils to begin foreign language study while still in elementary school, and in many countries (including Taiwan and Singapore, a generation ago) the majority of school pupils are attending school with a language of instruction that is not the same as the language they speak at home with their parents. Yet most United States high school graduates are resolutely monolingual English speakers, unless they grew up with another home language besides English. International comparisons suggest that there is still plenty of room at the top for achievable higher standards for United States students, and that students would enjoy school better if their lessons were more challenging.