Totally independent of Ethereum, this style of argument is kinda weak. We really should be trying to build something better, either by improving the existing system or building a parallel system that will slowly replace what's there. Good enough is the enemy of great.
Unfortunately, building better stuff winds up requiring building a bunch of stupid stuff that doesn't work out.
It's smart to avoid being an early adopter, unless you have some unique interest in whatever the topic might be, photography, self driving cars, or Ethereum.
Back to Ethereum, yeah, i agree smart contracts aren't a good idea. They may be a good idea in the future, but today they're a mess. I think, in general, some sort of blockchain transaction history is a great idea; it should be adopted somehow. I can't say exactly what that might look like though.
While I agree that this style of rethoric is often overused, GP does raise an important question. Now that Ethereum has forked, there is a great deal of uncertainty regarding the real benefits of the system, and about whether the benefit is worth the risk of switching.
The Ethereum project has always marketed the value of the system by emphasizing the predictable, deterministic, and impartial nature of the blockchain. Now that it has failed this first trial by fire, it is up to the project to present a new value proposition for why it is an improvement over the traditional legal system. We as the public must ask questions to analyze and critique this value proposition.
Oh, absolutely. We should always talk about what was good, what was bad, and what was irrelevant.
I feel the "what we have now is ok" argument is dismissive. It actively prevents us considering the good, bad or irrelevant perspective.
After rereading everything, perhaps i was harsh. The OP presented things in comparison to the current system, which is the right thing to do. I think the emphasis on "the current system works" distracted me.
There's a lot to be fixed about our current financial system. But I think both Ethereum-with-fork and Ethereum-without-fork are demonstrably worse than the status quo (which I think you also agree with). Ethereum is great as an experiment, but now we have experimental results from the DAO hack, showing something that clearly needs to be rethought. This manifesto seems to instead be presenting Ethereum-without-fork as a good and complete option, and all of its reasoning could have been written the day before the hack.
Specifically, I have seen a lot of buggy software. I don't think I've ever seen any truly bug-free software. I expect, therefore, that if I put money into a smart contract, that contract is going to have a bug in it somewhere. What happens when the bug is discovered and exploited? If you say "Some humans will decide that's not what was meant," that's wonderful--but I already have a financial system where humans make usually-reasonable judgments about fraud and can reverse transactions. It's not perfect, but I have a decent set of expectations about it, it works well enough, and it's very well-supported. If you say "No, the contract is the contract" (as these people do), fantastic: you have a compellingly different product, not just a bunch of complicated math on top of a system that's as squishy as my current financial system. But why at all should I believe that it's different for the better? Now I have an expectation that a bug will exist, and be exploited, and it will be correct for the bug to be exploited. If the goal is correctness, that's great. But if the goal is getting me to use the system, why would I want that?
Or, as Matt Levine put it in his writeup of the DAO hack (https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2016-06-17/blockchai...):
"Financial systems are supposed to work for humans. If the code rips off the humans, something has gone wrong."