News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ethereum Classic Declaration of Independence by geofft on Saturday August 13, 2016 @10:00AM (#12281525)
You bring up a fair point. The only reason I feel the need to emphasize "the current system works" is that so much cryptocurrency discourse seems to act as if the current system is horrible beyond repair and literally anything would be better than it. That's far from true, and it's definitely far from true when you've reintroduced humans caring about fraud--just human programmers writing soft-fork code (that didn't even work right, according to this manifesto) as opposed to people who make a profession out of understanding fraud.

There's a lot to be fixed about our current financial system. But I think both Ethereum-with-fork and Ethereum-without-fork are demonstrably worse than the status quo (which I think you also agree with). Ethereum is great as an experiment, but now we have experimental results from the DAO hack, showing something that clearly needs to be rethought. This manifesto seems to instead be presenting Ethereum-without-fork as a good and complete option, and all of its reasoning could have been written the day before the hack.

There are no comments on this comment yet.