News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by rubidium on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:28PM (#12277301)
Glad to see someone acknowledging the myopic view of most intellectuals.

During my time in academia (PhD), I'll admit now I had very little idea of what life was like for the majority of people.

Since then I've been living among many working class and poverty-level folks. Average household income in my neighborhood is <$22K (U.S.). As a result, my thinking has changed to unions are overall good ideas, UBI is foolish, and ramping up education investment is pretty minimal in its returns. Creating real neighborhood community (work, education, family, etc) is the best solution... it's just really hard to do!

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by humanrebar on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:40PM (#12277387)
> Creating real neighborhood community (work, education, family, etc) is the best solution... it's just really hard to do!

Especially since we've largely abandoned previous institutions that provided this: regular neighborhood hangout spots, social clubs, adult recreational leagues, and especially churches.

> unions are overall good ideas

Maybe. Depends. I frequently see union demands oriented around last decade's operational patterns instead of next decade's. Like requiring specific outdated jobs be filled (like toll booth workers) when it would be more value-added to have the same person clean or provide general customer service. A union looking out for its members would embrace that some jobs would fade away and provide (or demand) retraining for its workers so they're qualified for new jobs, even in other industries if need be.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by idrios on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:35PM (#12277785)
> Especially since we've largely abandoned previous institutions

True, though I think new institutions will come back. Things like Meetup groups seem to be gaining more traction--The groups are just slow to adoption because they're so new that nobody can be grandfathered in yet by friends or family who have been long-term members.

> Unions are overall good ideas -- Maybe. Depends.

I see unions as just another corporation - they're satisfying a need of "workers should not be exploited", their revenue model is "members pay X% and in return get our strength in numbers", and their activity streams are "fight for favorable legislation" and "Threaten uncompliant businesses".

The problem with unions is they are not treated as corporations in their own right, so unions have become monopolistic, heavily involved in lobbying and partaking in generally corrupt behavior--responding more strongly to incentives to survive and make money than incentives to keep its members happy.

Unions are still powerfully beneficial, but I'd wish there were multiple unions for any industry that competed with each other, some with stricter requirements to get in, each offering different freedoms and protections to its workers

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by mbostleman on Friday August 12, 2016 @05:16PM (#12278868)
Unions are monopolies by their nature - it's not something they become. They only exist due to a statutory exemption of anti-trust law. I personally have not been able find a justification for a monopoly of any kind in a free society.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by astazangasta on Friday August 12, 2016 @07:07PM (#12279411)
This is what unions are now, because the NLRB institutionalized them, and Taft-Hartley defanged them, and they became another kind of entrenched power. This is not what they were, when they served as a democratic organ, a way for workers to make collective decisions outside of government.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by cortesoft on Friday August 12, 2016 @11:34PM (#12280124)
If a union was not a monopoly, they would lose all the power they have - the power to withhold labor from an employer. How would a non-monopoly union work?
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by mbostleman on Friday August 12, 2016 @05:19PM (#12278880)
I don't see what benefits unions provide other than relieving their members from participating in a free market. The inefficiencies of such relief being paid for by consumers that have no choice in the matter.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by ryukafalz on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:33PM (#12277341)
>As a result, my thinking has changed to ... UBI is foolish

Could you elaborate on what made you change your mind regarding UBI? It'd be interesting to hear your perspective on this.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by cylinder on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:33PM (#12277771)
Working class wants to work.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dragonwriter on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:49PM (#12277891)
> Working class wants to work.

One of the principal selling points for UBI as a replacement for existing means tested social benefit programs is that it eliminates the perverse incentives created by means tested programs in which benefits are reduced by outside income (especially from work), at a rate that, in aggregate across the programs a person may be eligible for, may even exceed the after-tax income from work.

A selling point it has as a replacement for minimum wage is that it provides a quality-of-life safety net without preventing work that people would willingly do, and which would be economically valuable for employers, by setting a floor on minimum hourly pay.

UBI is, arguably, more in line with "working class wants to work" than the status quo it is offered to replace.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by justinpombrio on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:04PM (#12277994)
Translation:

Currently, many social benefit programs give people less money the more they work. If a person is eligible for enough of these programs, they can even make less money by working than they would by not working.

UBI (universal basic income) doesn't have this problem because it pays people the same amount regardless of weather they work. Thus, it is arguably more in line with "working class wants to work" than the status quo is.

EDIT: Made translation more precise.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dragonwriter on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:27PM (#12278140)
That's not a precisely accurate translation, as there are plenty of social benefit programs that are not means tested beyond perhaps treating some of the benefit as normal income (e.g., Social Security), and my post was not making the "most social benefit programs" claim, only comparing UBI to those programs which are means tested (and which therefore are obvious candidates to replace with a UBI, given the usual arguments for UBI.)
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dbsjkdn on Friday August 12, 2016 @09:17PM (#12279760)
>(e.g., Social Security),

Maybe true for the standard retired beneficiary, but not for everyone. A friend of mine is on SS disability. His condition changes over time and has improved some in recent years. When he can work, he has to make sure he doesn't work too much, or his benefits go away.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by justinpombrio on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:57PM (#12278336)
Yeah, it was bound to be inaccurate, because you clearly know more about this than I do!

It took me a few minutes (no exaggeration) to parse your post. But you made some excellent points, so I decided to simplify it for other unlettered folks like myself. (We have a hard time picking apart 70-word long sentences.) It would be even better if you could write for us directly. Even just capping your sentences at 30 words would make a big difference, I think.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by sillyarg on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:45PM (#12277861)
That's one of the benefits of UBI over many welfare programs. Because it's universal, it's not cash for not working; it's cash.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by andrewjl on Saturday August 13, 2016 @07:58PM (#12283662)
The working class wants to work because they derive their identity and significant meaning for existence from their jobs.

Replace that with something else and this thinking will change.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by throwanem on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:36PM (#12277791)
"But robots," someone said, apparently distracted by futurism from noticing the existence of manual trades.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by yarrel on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:32PM (#12277335)
Why do you regard UBI as foolish given that real-world context?

I'm interested as opinions for and against it do tend to be from 30,000 feet.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by hahooooo on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:05PM (#12277999)
The danger I see with UBI, is (in addition to possible inflation, etc.) is that commentators on HN tend to be of higher education, curious, and simply "hackers". Most people here would love to be payed money so they could sit and program some cool OSS, start a new company or simply change the world.

For them, UBI is fantastic. How many more Googles/GNUs/Apples would there be if engineers could quit existing companies and form, all while guaranteed basic sustenance.

The problem is that there are a lot of people who don't care for that. You pay them money, they'll sit playing Video games, sports, or simply bum around.

And then you start having issues convincing people to go for higher education (even assuming its free).

Wait, what about lower education?

Go to school, get good grades, or else you'll ... get a livable wage anyways?

Why should I write essays when I can play video games instead?

Then, until everything is automatable, you still need to get people to work under the hot sun, picking potatoes.

If you have a livable wage without it, why would you go? And how much will the farmer need to pay workers to go?

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by carapace on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:32PM (#12278171)
A thought experiment: Assume a near-future world where automation can provide a decent standard of living for everyone. Further assume there is a part of the population that just slacks off. Would you be in favor of some sort of punishment to make those folks conform to your standard of not wasting their lives?
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by hahooooo on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:45PM (#12278251)
My main point is that people tend to view everyone as themselves. So intellectuals tend to view everyone as intellectuals.

So we think that if only I'd have guaranteed income, I'd finally get around to fixing Firefox, or making an Open Source Google, or whatever. Therefore, it would be better for society if people would be free to leave "useless work" and innovate instead.

But once you see the "real world," you realize that it's not going to happen. Most people would just sit at home playing CS or chatting on FB.

Now once humanity is retired, and of no more use (singularity), then sure, why not. It'll be the AIs innovating everything, running everything, and no one will be doing anything useful anyways.

But until that point, I don't know if we can realistically afford three quarters of the population to just go into early retirement.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by carapace on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:57PM (#12278335)
Heh, cool, I agree with you. :-)

I'm one of those who views UBI as a way of dealing with productivity explosion implied by (some models of) the singularity (as opposed to a form of welfare.) It seems a realistic option, and more desirable than e.g. slavery or genocide, once things are getting closer to the limit, eh?

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by jpindar on Saturday August 13, 2016 @01:25PM (#12282232)
In other words, "those proles are so lazy that as long as they don't starve, they'd PREFER being poor"? People living on only UBI will still be relatively poor.

Look at all the lengths people throughout the ages have gone to to make money. People LIKE money. They like it so much they are willing to work for more of it, even when they already have enough to barely survive.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dragonwriter on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:13PM (#12278047)
The problem you point to is self-limiting. Regardless of the nominal level of UBI, it won't provide a satisfactory income unless a sufficient number of people remain working to provide the goods and services required to provide a satisfying style of life for the UBI-only recipients and sufficient additional value to workers for them to continue working. Prices will adjust to make this the case.

As the quality of life provided on UBI-only declines, the incentive for additional productive work will increase.

(of course, lots of people now continue to expend additional effort beyond what is necessary for a minimally livable existence, so I don't see this as likely to be a great problem.)

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by hahooooo on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:37PM (#12278192)
In other words, the tragedy of the commons.

My biggest concern with the UBI is that looking back at societies with UBI (such as the upper class Europe of the Middle Ages through the 19th century), for every Newton or Voltaire were many more unknown nobles who spent their life grooming their mustaches.

I don't believe our society is that much better now.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dragonwriter on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:17PM (#12278479)
> In other words, the tragedy of the commons.

In a sense, but in this particularly case it operates as a negative feedback control mechanism which prevents the actual feared problem from occurring, so is hardly a "tragedy".

> My biggest concern with the UBI is that looking back at societies with UBI

There are no societies with UBI to look back on.

> such as the upper class Europe of the Middle Ages through the 19th century

A benefit restricted to a particular social class is not a UBI (or, at least, not much like what modern UBI proposals target, and not likely to serve as a guide as to what one can expect from them), nor, even ignoring that aspect, did the upper class of Europe through any of that time have anything remotely resembling a UBI, which is a flat, equal, unconditional grant to all members of a society.

Now, in much of that period, individual nobles had (either by definition or just disproportionately, depending on the particular time and place) either claims to income from substantial properties or family connections to those who did and who would support junior family members with, often quite conditional, support, but that's more the position of a wealthy capitalist or their associates in the modern era than that of a UBI beneficiary.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by noonespecial on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:27PM (#12278545)
We'd have to decide how many mustache groomers each Voltaire or Newton is worth before deciding if it's a tragedy, no?
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by noonespecial on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:24PM (#12278535)
>The problem is that there are a lot of people who don't care for that. You pay them money, they'll sit playing Video games, sports, or simply bum around.

Which is cheaper than housing even a small number of them in prisons. One of the hopes is that by eliminating much of the desperateness from poverty, we'll save a bundle from the accompanying reduction in crime.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by yarrel on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:09PM (#12278420)
Thank you, this is a great conversation.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by robocat on Friday August 12, 2016 @06:05PM (#12279124)
People over a certain age get a UBI (in many countries).

Maybe extrapolate from what they do...

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dragonwriter on Friday August 12, 2016 @06:09PM (#12279153)
> People over a certain age get a UBI (in many countries).

> Maybe extrapolate from what they do...

People over the age for drawing public pensions (whether or not those are UBI-like; most I'm familiar with are not) are probably not representative of the broader population in their decisions with regard to engagement in the labor market, entrepreneurship, etc., and how those decisions are impacted by changes in available resources.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by klank on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:36PM (#12277364)
> ramping up education investment is pretty minimal in its returns. Creating real neighborhood community (work, education, family, etc) is the best solution

I'm confused about your stance on education. At first blush you seem to be diminishing it's impact while promoting it. Care to elaborate?

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by burkaman on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:58PM (#12277518)
I think the idea is rather than just pouring money directly into schools, focusing on creating communities and resources so that students can actually take advantage of what's available. Buying new textbooks and facilities doesn't help when half the students don't have enough to eat, don't have role models and tutors, don't have anyone telling them that education is important.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by eitland on Friday August 12, 2016 @01:41PM (#12277392)
If by education GP means higher education then I can possibly add something:

IIRC there already seems to be a shortage of craftsmen (carpenters, welders, plumbers etc) and a surplus of people with various higher educations.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by endzone on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:05PM (#12277575)
a shortage that's not reflected in the wages for skilled jobs (outside of powerful unions)
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by dozzie on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:17PM (#12278483)
Quite the contrary. Welders, carpenters, or heavy equipment operators in my country enjoy a decent pay, yet there is a shortage. For some weird reasons those who studied so sought-after political studies or literature can't be bothered with a job that consists of physical work and doesn't require a degree.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by eitland on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:43PM (#12277845)
In some places it has been.

Man I sometimes wished I had a valid mechanicans or electricians certification during the oil boom here ;-)

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by endzone on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:52PM (#12277908)
and now you wouldn't have a job.

in the uk, the plumbers/electricians are lucky to make £20/hr.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:02PM (#12277981)
In the UK, plumbers and electricians can make more than developers do.

It depends where they work - London and the SE pay a lot better than the run down cities in the North - and how good their network is.

I used to know someone with a well-paid City job who retrained as a plumber. He earns almost as much as he did and is considerably less stressed. The only downside is occasional snobbery.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by petra on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:36PM (#12277790)
I know that in Israel there's shortage in those professions, but the pay isn't good. So maybe it's more complex that simple supply vs demand ?
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by endzone on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:50PM (#12277894)
i can't think of any reason why basic economic principles wouldn't apply.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by petra on Friday August 12, 2016 @05:03PM (#12278793)
Say you have a small factory ,employing 50 older welders doing a risky job at relatively little pay.

Say you need 10 more welders - but those guys really don't like risk so they would need a big increase in the salary, maybe 50%-100%. But you know that than the word will get out and the older workers will demand similar salaries.

So it's a big jump in total labor-costs per work-unit. And let's not forget - revenue per employee can be quite limited in many places. So maybe paying low is the better state for the business.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by cortesoft on Friday August 12, 2016 @11:43PM (#12280157)
But demand doesn't come from a single factory... Why isn't another factory poaching those older workers for more pay?
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by redthrow on Friday August 12, 2016 @02:03PM (#12277560)
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by saalweachter on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:18PM (#12278485)
The risk of pushing "education" is that it's either duplicitous -- a well-rounded liberal arts education is a good thing, but doesn't guarantee the mythical "job" -- or just cost-shifting to potential workers: a lot of companies would prefer that a large number of potential workers pay for their own education as welders, machinists, and air conditioner repairmen, increasing their labor pool, driving down their own wages, and taking on the risk (of whether there is a need for their labor) themselves.

Education should be for the sake of learning; companies should be willing to train laborers, from machinists to drivers to software engineers.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by mindslight on Saturday August 13, 2016 @04:47PM (#12283029)
The article is a swing and a miss. The problem is much deeper than the bias of being more educated and intellectual. It's that they believe singular "policy" can be made and then dictated top-down - that effects will be quickly visible and easily understandable. They're up against a hard problem in the computational complexity sense, yet it is in none of their interests to be honest and admit their limits.

Most of their ideas lack intellectual rigor and merely follow the fashions of power. BI in particular is a simplistic continuation of printing money to overstimulate the economy.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by unabridged on Friday August 12, 2016 @03:51PM (#12278293)
>unions are overall good ideas, UBI is foolish

UBI would be much better than unionizing the entire country (the IWW is the only union I know of that would accept all people regardless of skill). Everyone would be guaranteed unlimited strike pay that can sustain them. The effect on employee-employer relationships would be amazing, every degrading/dangerous job would instantly have to 2x or 3x its salary to keep workers. Every worker would be able to negotiate from a position of safety knowing they effectively have 'fuck you money'.