News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Great Productivity Puzzle by gumby on Thursday August 11, 2016 @04:58PM (#12271490)
Sorry I meant using PPP baskets (same economy but over time) to nominalize hourly production since this is a productivity discussion. The difficulty of coming up with CPI inflators (a very hard job!) is that the basket of goods people purchase changes. But you can see that the labor hours required to manufacture a car has plummeted (forget that today's car is so much better than a car of 1950) -- and forget the fall in maintenance costs too.

I think a lot of the productivity mystery lies is due to artifacts in the shitty tools we have. For example, GDP is like the Dow Jones indices: designed to be easy to calculate with pencil and paper, plagued by necessary changes in their own baselines over time (mostly: what is counted and what is not), not terribly reflective of what we really want to know, and yet it would be stupid to discard them because we'd lose any time series. Everybody knows they are broken but nobody has any idea yet what would be better.

It's not like I have a great idea of what we should be using instead ettither. But I fell it's foolish to say "we have strong qualitative signals but since we can't find them in our model they are bogus". Especially since we all know our current theories are woefully incomplete and perhaps even inaccurate.

Those who don't see the productivity advance aren't idiots: those who, like me, believe in those signals justifiably have a large hurdle to leap.

There are no comments on this comment yet.