Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic...
by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:07PM
(#12269375)
It's more the gap between experts and non-experts. Pop-sci has turned Dunning-Kruger into a religion, but pop-journalism of all kinds delights in reporting that experts are corrupt and/or hostile and/or wrong.
And often they are, especially in some fields. The problem is that non-experts see "science" and "experts" as single classes, with no understanding of the difference between a professional researcher at the Perimeter Institute and some paid-for PR shill wackjob dredged up to fill airtime on a talk show.
Let's not forget that "medical experts" literally promoted the health benefits of smoking, and of products that encouraged people to consume radium.
To an outsider, it must be very confusing. It's easier, as a heuristic, to dismiss everyone's expertise than it is to take the time to try to assess relative competence.
Unfortunately physics has a huge problem, because it's been made to seem sexy and mediafied.
It's been popularised to an extreme degree, and people who don't know what a differential equation is and would have no idea how to start a practical engineering project, whether it's bridge building or aerospace or electronics, believe they can talk with authority about quantum theory.
There's a subtext which is even more disturbing - the idea there's a democratic right to have opinions about these things (which is fair enough) and to have the opinions taken seriously by professionals (which isn't.)
And often they are, especially in some fields. The problem is that non-experts see "science" and "experts" as single classes, with no understanding of the difference between a professional researcher at the Perimeter Institute and some paid-for PR shill wackjob dredged up to fill airtime on a talk show.
Let's not forget that "medical experts" literally promoted the health benefits of smoking, and of products that encouraged people to consume radium.
To an outsider, it must be very confusing. It's easier, as a heuristic, to dismiss everyone's expertise than it is to take the time to try to assess relative competence.
Unfortunately physics has a huge problem, because it's been made to seem sexy and mediafied.
It's been popularised to an extreme degree, and people who don't know what a differential equation is and would have no idea how to start a practical engineering project, whether it's bridge building or aerospace or electronics, believe they can talk with authority about quantum theory.
There's a subtext which is even more disturbing - the idea there's a democratic right to have opinions about these things (which is fair enough) and to have the opinions taken seriously by professionals (which isn't.)