News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by erroneousfunk on Thursday August 11, 2016 @11:45AM (#12269158)
I'm hardly a physicist, but I have a degree in "general engineering" (long story about how I managed to escape specialization there) and a master's in software engineering, and I've taken a few advanced math courses, including partial differential equations, computational theory, scientific computing, and a math-heavy course on relativity. I also spent a year and a half working for a Harvard physics professor, alongside his team of grad students. So, while I can't "do physics" I think I know enough to understand a little about what it takes to _be_ a physicist, and appreciate the work that they do.

My husband and I were listening to a radio program (http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/293/a...) about a man convinced that he had found a mistake in Einstein's theory of relativity, and trying to communicate this idea to a physicist (futilely, obviously). My husband, who was a music major for a year before dropping out of college, and I started getting in an argument about this episode that was so heated, I felt like we were listening to two completely different stories!

I kept insisting that the advanced math and education wasn't just some funsies shibboleth the physicists had to keep the hoi polloi out of physics -- the devil's in the details and the man in the story didn't even understand the big picture correctly. My husband was angry and insulted that the physicist dismissed the man's theory out of hand, and felt that anyone could make a contribution to physics with perhaps a little help from a calculus book -- just look at history! I thought the hero of the story (if there was one) was clearly the physicist, while my husband was solidly on the side of the electrician with a little learning, trying dangerous things.

I was really shocked. We don't usually fight like that, and especially over something so seemingly trivial, but, in retrospect, I thought that it displayed huge tension in society as a whole, between academics and non-academics. We hear so much about the "one percent" and income-based class distinctions, but relatively little about academic barriers in society, whether real or artificially imposed. Should physics open up in a real way (not just "pop science" articles and occasional books for laymen)? Should we put a stronger "academic" focus in early public and high school education? Should we provide more resources for "physicists who just need a little help with the math" whether they're right or wrong?

Although I was staunchly in favor of the hallowed halls of academe, and it still holds a special place in my heart, I suspect that the correct solution lies somewhere in the middle. Anyway, fantastic article, and it really brings up an important point that is too seldom addressed, by physicists, or society as a whole!

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by zerohp on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:21PM (#12269514)
Just a nitpick, but Bob Berenz is an electrician not an electrical engineer. Electrical engineering is firmly rooted in modern physics and an educated electrical engineer would not need "help with the math." Out of all engineering disciplines, an electrical engineer is possibly the most prepared to work side by side with a physicist.

As to your questions, no, I don't think academics should provide more resources to "physicists who just need a little help with the math." They are not physicists and there are plenty of resources at community colleges that can help them. We should not entertain the notions of those that refuse to learn the tools necessary to develop a deeper understanding. Math is not optional, it is the language by which we describe the structure of the universe.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by 77pt77 on Thursday August 11, 2016 @08:54PM (#12272825)
> and an educated electrical engineer would not need "help with the math."

For doing EM no. For doing GR or QFT, he would most certainly need help with the math.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by posterboy on Friday August 12, 2016 @11:42AM (#12276535)
you missed the more general question

> Should physics open up in a real way (not just "pop science" articles and occasional books for laymen)?

The problem with the whole paragraph is, IMHO, maths and physics cannot be separated. There is no pure physics and neither pure mathematics.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by erroneousfunk on Thursday August 11, 2016 @01:31PM (#12270143)
Yup, sorry, just misspoke/typed. Will edit.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:07PM (#12269375)
It's more the gap between experts and non-experts. Pop-sci has turned Dunning-Kruger into a religion, but pop-journalism of all kinds delights in reporting that experts are corrupt and/or hostile and/or wrong.

And often they are, especially in some fields. The problem is that non-experts see "science" and "experts" as single classes, with no understanding of the difference between a professional researcher at the Perimeter Institute and some paid-for PR shill wackjob dredged up to fill airtime on a talk show.

Let's not forget that "medical experts" literally promoted the health benefits of smoking, and of products that encouraged people to consume radium.

To an outsider, it must be very confusing. It's easier, as a heuristic, to dismiss everyone's expertise than it is to take the time to try to assess relative competence.

Unfortunately physics has a huge problem, because it's been made to seem sexy and mediafied.

It's been popularised to an extreme degree, and people who don't know what a differential equation is and would have no idea how to start a practical engineering project, whether it's bridge building or aerospace or electronics, believe they can talk with authority about quantum theory.

There's a subtext which is even more disturbing - the idea there's a democratic right to have opinions about these things (which is fair enough) and to have the opinions taken seriously by professionals (which isn't.)

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by _polymer_ on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:00PM (#12269320)
I've often felt I'm not smart enough to be a theoretical physicist, but smart enough to know the difference between a real explanation and word vomit.

And that is extremely stressful for me. There is a desire to feel like you can understand some key part of the world you live in.

Failing to get into academia feels like I've personally failed at calming this desire. And I hate it.

Sometimes I think people refuse to believe this course of life is necessary, it feels elite and exclusionary. Knowing your world shouldn't require this, it cant't.

But it does.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by mizzao on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:38PM (#12269685)
Speaking as an academic, "getting into academia" requires some combination of luck, perseverance, and personality fit. It has very little to do with being "smart enough".

Also, you end up being a specialist in a very, very tiny aspect of the world, rather than having a lot of general knowledge. A good illustration:

http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by _polymer_ on Thursday August 11, 2016 @01:31PM (#12270136)
I mean sure. It's just when I look at my heroes, Feynman, Polya, Dirac, etc. They all went to places like princeton.

And near as I can tell, that seems to be important. The only person I can think of who blew the door open was faraday, a spooky good experimentalist.

Granted it's rediculous to compare oneself to people like this. I'm worried I'm half depressed.

Worrying about specialization seems, to me, misleading. At least in math. People regularly use their entire experience on problems. The specialty just reflects your values and talents. I dunno, maybe I am wrong, I appreciate your thoughts.

My goal with my original post was to explain a strong desire to be "right" about things one cares about. I think this emotion is destructive, and unproductive, but I see it in myself. I think others might cope by not fighting it, pretending to know, then moving on with their life. Then some scientist comes along, tells then they don't, and they get defensive.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by effie on Thursday August 11, 2016 @04:51PM (#12271457)
If you want to be like them, focus on the process of science, not on being right about how nature "really" works. Those guys were driven by the desire to figure things out, to get some understanding of things but they knew when to stop worrying and move on to the next interesting thing where progress could be made. They were not so religious as to spend their life trying to achieve some sort of final absolute understanding.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by drauh on Thursday August 11, 2016 @02:22PM (#12270519)
Would people argue over the proper treatment for cancer as prescribed by physicians and oncologists?

Don't answer that.

Physicists who need a little help with the math become experimentalist. JK. (I was an experimental physicist.)

Physics is already open in a real way. It's just that the natural language of physics is math. And people don't like math, for whatever reason.

Re dismissing things out of hand: unfortunately, sometimes the errors are so obvious that all it takes is one look to see that it's wrong. I mean, if it's easy for a practicing musician to identify a chord by ear, why should one think a physicist is arrogant if they can spot the error right away?

(See my other comments here on arguing about conservation of energy and momentum in an online forum.)

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by _polymer_ on Thursday August 11, 2016 @03:09PM (#12270847)
You know, I suspect it's much more common to find people arguing over proper cancer treatment, because they want to believe their care is right. And if they don't like math, or science, they'll make sweeping wrong statements about their health, because they don't know how to make the right explanation feel right.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by heeen2 on Thursday August 11, 2016 @07:59PM (#12272616)
> Would people argue over the proper treatment for cancer as prescribed by physicians and oncologists?

of course they would. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amygdalin

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by internaut on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:28PM (#12269588)
There is a general problem where for laypeople it is difficult to tell the difference between bullshit and non-bullshit. Witness the success of Deepak Chopra.

The confounding factor is that the layperson's suspicion that some academics are lying or involved in some conspiracy is not always wrong. Then there are the culture wars between various factions. Witness how computer scientists think of the social scientists in general. Not much love being exchanged there, they might as well be different species.

I think the only thing you can really do educationally is teach logic and thinking from first principals as well as heuristics for bullshit detection.

My technique is to pin down the person with a clear definition for a piece of their explanation. I then write this down. Eventually I find their ideas to be either consistent or inconsistent. Being consistent doesn't make them right but it sure does filter out most bullshit. It's like being a detective!

Unfortunately bullshit detection, first principals + basic logic only take you so far because for many real world things you require large amounts of domain knowledge. Teaching all that is impossible. You can however teach about what Neal Stephenson called icongraphies in his book Anathem. There are historical patterns, mental models that are domain specific but which can enable you to rapidly detect whether something fits into a framework or whether it's off the rails.

Here is a fair warning though. There is some interesting ideas about the split between 'American science' and 'Russian science'. That is something that shouldn't have happened but the communication breakdown led to several fields taking different paths. For example Geology supposed in America that Oil was generated from a biological source in the distant past. You might take that idea for granted. But in Russia it was thought seriously for a long time that Oil was generated from a non-biological source. I don't know the real answer myself but it is worth knowing that this does happen. I mean... one of them is almost certainly wrong.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ashark on Thursday August 11, 2016 @02:32PM (#12270596)
I think a few things contribute to this in a big way:

1) Explanations of science (or the findings of science, anyway) in school are often awful and/or wrong, and not always for any good reason. See: how airplane wings work, for an exceptionally bad one. Finding this out for one thing after another as one grows up paints all of science as kinda bullshitty.

2) People who (apparently) know what's going on often have trouble explaining why something that seems like it ought to have a decent intuitive explanation works other than "the math says it does, so it does". See, for an example: basically any place online where several seemingly-knowledgable people try to explain how/why the Oberth effect works. Also the talk section for the wikipedia page about how airplane wings work :-(

3) Most people (I'd guess) are looking for satisfying answers to "why" in science, and often science actually does run out of answers to that question beyond "because the math says so" or "because we've observed that this happens, for whatever reason", and sometimes surprisingly far from the edge of our knowledge on a topic. These spaces are often filled with fairy tales, which may be tossed about as if they're "real", confusing laypersons. This obscures where the satisfying-to-a-layperson part of a given topic ends and where here-be-dragons-and-magic-and-mostly-just-math begins.

4) Common words overloaded to serve as highly specific scientific terminology are incredibly difficult to parse as a layperson, and they're all over in science. It's easy to get fairly deep into a topic before realizing that a term like this is barely mapped to any common meaning, if it is at all. Doubly so if the reason the term was originally used turns out to be wrong, but the term remains in use for whatever phenomenon/term it was describing just because all the experts are used to it. Physics is extremely bad about this, to the point that it comes off as intentional.

Given those things (among others), no wonder non-experts have trouble sorting BS from legit science.

[edit] "there" to "where"

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 11, 2016 @02:50PM (#12270709)
> Explanations of science (or the findings of science, anyway) in school are often awful and/or wrong

One of the biggest problems in science education is the failure, I think, to distinguish enough between the teaching of the results of science (and simplifications of those results) and science itself. Related to that is insufficient teaching of the evaluation of scientific claims. (Which really overlaps with general critical thinking.)

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by jimmaswell on Thursday August 11, 2016 @03:47PM (#12271097)
>Witness how computer scientists think of the social scientists in general. Not much love being exchanged there

A lot of that is because social sciences are often genuinely non-rigorous, hand-wavey, and opinionated.

I was required to take a sociology class once. Some of what was presented was solid, like the observed stages of childhood development with respect to self-awareness and the issues with the poverty cycle, but in other areas a lot of theories were presented as the "right" thing to believe that had some combination of being unverifiable, having insufficient sample sizes in their foundational studies, having glaring methodological problems, contradicting other things also presented as factual, or having reaching conclusions.

There was an assignment to make a food plan based on an average food stamp allocation, that let you eat 2000 calories per day along with some other requirements that I don't remember. The professor claimed only one person had ever been able to do it. You weren't expected to be able to do it, but if you couldn't, you had to write an explanation of it and how the experience made you feel - assumedly an "eye opening experience" was expected. It was conveniently not mentioned that food stamps are intended to be supplemental, not for all of your food. The program even has the word supplemental in the title: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supplemental_Nutrition_Assista...

Regardless, even with unrealistic restrictions, I was able to do it without any trouble. Taking the high values of what the food prices ranged at the local budget food store, I had a result that was well-balanced and below-budget. Of course, the professor had to make some snide comment about "sodium poisoning" to the class about it, which this diet certainly cannot cause.

Here's a paste of it: http://pastebin.com/QnmnHXbA

Not everybody has access to as good of a budget store as ALDI, so results can vary, but this particular ALDI is located in a low-income area, and there's clearly no epidemic of malnourished low-income individuals nationwide given that poverty is correlated with obesity. This was just one example of the many problems in that curriculum. For another example, the wage gap was simply stated to be indisputably the common 77 cents per dollar figure, which carries certain implications of it being entirely discrimination when stated without any qualifiers; however, when just looking at the Wikipedia article, it can be seen that the problem has more subtleties to it, including which portions are "explained" vs "unexplained," and that widely varying figures have been reported. Motivating more women to participate in male-majority fields is a good thing, along with other proposed solutions to help the problem, but none of that was mentioned in the class.

Aside from this one biased professor, I've read from others that these problems are very common in social science classes. It would be nice if there were some data available on how students rate their professors' bias in this field.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by erroneousfunk on Thursday August 11, 2016 @04:59PM (#12271495)
Completely off-topic note, but I actually lived on food stamps for a while in 2009, and, yes, it's extremely easy to stay under-budget if you have access to a well-stocked kitchen, and you know how to cook and plan meals for yourself and your family (not a difficult skill, but not a trivial one either). Fortunately, I'm a decent cook, but for a couple months I lived in illegally-run housing where you had five units sharing a tiny unventilated kitchen and an old fridge.

The landlord would go through and unplug the communal appliances (including the fridge) regularly to reduce energy consumption. I thought it was odd that the fridge was empty, except for sodas, when I got there, but I found out why pretty fast. Food would get stolen, I was regularly harassed (not "oh, that guy hit on me and I didn't like it" harassment, but huge dudes with mental illnesses, prison records, and nothing better to do threatened to beat me up, and yelled at me over imaginary things they suspected me of, one guy threw a block of my cheese out the nearby bathroom window -- as a single female, I was an easy target), there was just a single bathroom for everyone, connected to the kitchen, and I watched people empty soda bottles of urine into the kitchen sink (yeah, super gross). The oven was so dirty the unventilated kitchen filled with smoke when you turned it on, and you had to stay there to make sure no one fucked with your food. Towards the end, everything I ate basically had to be shelf stable and require no preparation. Also, there were mice, so if you don't like mice in your tiny bedroom, keeping large amounts of food around is a problem.

Anyway, I was fortunate to have the resources to get out of that situation extremely quickly, but a huge problem for many people on food stamps is that they just don't have the ability to reasonably store and prepare food. Having your own kitchen (or a kitchen with responsible people you trust), buying appliances, providing electricity, and maintaining everything is expensive. My own kitchen, big-ticket appliances aside, probably has thousands of dollars worth of gadgets, dishes, and cutlery in it right now -- I certainly don't take that for granted anymore! We often assume that people have access to a kitchen where they feel safe, AND the knowledge to cook and plan meals. The next place I was at, I could get six meals out of a roast chicken and a few potatoes and was under-budget every month. But the first apartment was awful. I ate terribly, felt exhausted, and was struggling at the end of the month, with the exact same budget and skill set.

Preparing "food stamp menus" in a text file demonstrates very little about the program one way or another. There are much larger issues around food supplement programs that people don't often understand.