How would you go about showing that something is a dinvariant? You would need to take two objects that are distinct and show that their dinvariants are distinct. I.e. use the fact that a homotopy between the two knots does not exist. This is much more difficult, though it does get done. In particular, it's done whenever we have a complete classification of all objects of a certain type (say orientable surfaces, classified by the single invariant (and also dinvariant) their genus). Though generally here we would be actually approaching this from an invariant perspective but just showing that once you have enough invariants, they collectively become a dinvariant.
Dually, you would want the following: if two knots have identical dinvariants, then they are surely the same. Since "if the knots are equivalent, the assigned values might not be equal", dinvariants cannot accomplish this function, and that makes them mostly useless.
(full disclosure: lawyer who did his undergraduate degree in math, not a topologist)
> if two knots have identical dinvariants, then they are surely the same. Since "if the knots are equivalent, the assigned values might not be equal", dinvariants cannot accomplish this function, and that makes them mostly useless.
That doesn't make them useless. Dinvariants just serve a different purpose:
- invariants serve the purpose of distinguishing knots that are different
- dinvariants serve the purpose of detecting that knots that look very different are actually the same
But why don't we build a systematic theory of dinvariants (similar to the theory of invariants) to get a much better understanding of them?
Not every dinvariant needs to be an invariant. :-)
If you say two knots are equivalent, in mathematics, that means they are equal, one and the same. You can't have a tool that assigns different structures to the same thing. But I see where you are coming from. In mathematics we have the concept of a presentation (of a group or a vector space, for example). You can imagine a presentation of a knot like in a two dimensional representation (typical one) and assign an invariant to that. That wouldn't be an invariant of a knot, that would be an invariant of a knot, as you mention, but it would be an invariant of a knot plus some extra structure. Those objects are also studied in many instances in which the original is two difficult. As simple example imagine a knot plus an orientation. Invariants of that structure might be dinvariants of the knot.
As far as I know a knot is a continuous embedding of S^1 into R^3. Equal means exactly same subset of R^3. Equivalence of knots means that there is a suitable ambient isotopy between the nots (I just looked this up in wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knot_theory#Knot_equivalence). So equality is a much stronger criterion than equivalence.
So 'equal => equivalence', but the other direction 'equivalence => equal' trivially does not hold (just apply some transition in R^3; these knots are equivalent but not equal).
But now let's define a "dinvariant" ("dual invariant" or "different invariant"): A dinvariant assigns to each knot also some object such that if the knots are different (or topological space are different in their class where they come from (say: are different simplical complexes or different CW complexes), the dinvariant will assign different values. On the other hand, if the knots are equivalent, the assigned values might not be equal.
What I want to know is: Why doesn't there seem to exist a theory of dinvariants for knots (or topological spaces)?