Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by b34r on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:52PM
(#12239599)
Based on current science, there are many geometries of black holes. We can't speak in such absolutes.
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by tazjin on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:35PM
(#12239534)
Black holes are uniformly sized?
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by m_mueller on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:02PM
(#12239644)
Stellar ones have a soft upper boundary. If they are so old and massive that they become planetary or even stellar sized - well the'd start drawing stealing a good chunk of the host galaxy and form their own one - with blackjack and hookers. I.e. a flickering star would be the least of your worries ;-).
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by ethanbond on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:16PM
(#12239694)
What causes the soft upper boundary?
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by wbl on Saturday August 06, 2016 @05:07PM
(#12239941)
The mass of the star before it went and formed a black hole. The bigger a star, the hotter it is, and the more evaporates from the surface, and the shorter it lives. Large blackholes grow through things falling into them.
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by ethanbond on Saturday August 06, 2016 @07:01PM
(#12240281)
Oh I read the parent comment as black holes having a soft upper boundary. Is that the case? Or if more stuff falls in they just get bigger (minus Hawking radiation)?
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by wbl on Saturday August 06, 2016 @09:28PM
(#12240654)
So there is a complication, which is space is filled with vast amounts of nothingness. For a black hole to get bigger objects need to be on a collision course with it, which is somewhat unusual. A black hole doesn't behave any differently from the same mass as something not a black hole. So once a star turns into a black hole, the accretion disk is usually remnants/maybe more if it is in a nebula. Once that's gone, that's it for growth.
Re:Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
by XorNot on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:53PM
(#12239601)
Schwarzchild radius means black holes are small. To dim the light from a star you need something very high in surface area whereas black holes by definition are the most compact objects in the universe
A black hole is also too small to explain the drop in brightness. That would require something planet-sized, but a black hole is only about the size of a city.