In the case of Btrfs it's a laudable effort, but has yet to approach production readiness in an awfully long time. Even if the licences are incompatible, the on-disk structures of ZFS could have been used to create a compatible implementation.
So I'm afraid I'm increasingly using other systems such as FreeBSD (with ZFS) and leaving Linux behind somewhat. Ultimately open systems, open standards and free software and software freedom are more important than a single implementation.
If Linux was a research experiment with exposure but little use compared to the other Unix systems, we would probably all look at it much more favorably, not because they are doing things right, but because they are willing to try crazy shit that we would all get to see the post-mortems for. The problem is that Linux is not some semi-obscure OS, so instead of these experiments being interesting reading for the weekend, we're often forced to become users of them, whether we like to or not.
I'd much rather this than the *BSD policies.
Oh and talking about FreeBSD, it's hardly bug free. Look at these Golang issues and tell me it doesn't indicate something wrong in the FreeBSD kernel threads/fork/exec code.
1. https://golang.org/issue/16136 2. https://golang.org/issue/15658 3. https://golang.org/issue/16396
I'd never use raid5/6 on anything. Hardware is cheap.
And how does this approach compare to other UNIXes? And I don't mean UNIXes from the 1970s, I mean ones which are currently in use: FreeBSD, OpenBSD, Solaris, MacOSX. Last I heard, they all had roughly equivalent init systems to systemd.
Frankly this is what should have happened with the likes of Debian regarding systemd as well. A parallel release offering systemd as the default, alongside sysv. Then it would be up to the admins to pick, rather than have to apply contortions during or right after install to switch from systemd to sysv.
Instead Debian adopted systemd, and we got Devuan as a sysv fork...
It's so frustrating to watch this. To see all these projects being developed on Linux where it's easier for others to simply reimplement the idea from scratch than try and remove all the Linux only code from them.
The Linux world only thinks about itself. In a spectacularly selfish way.