Where I live the state even invented a special tax on digital supports (USB, Hard Drives, etc...) to "favor the authors" because of "piracy". Never met a single author that benefited from that. And trust me I know a lot of them.
Copyright laws were made, and exist, to privilege the industry (which does include authors, at the bottom, if you scrap hard enough).
Just read through the legal code of your country and try to place the "so many" who "work so hard on their craft" along the lines.
But if the tax isn't going to the copyright holders, then sounds like the tax is stealing from the copyright holders also.
Well yes, the storage device is legal. If you meant that this tax legitimised the process of unlicensed content reproduction: You'd probably be better off by lowering your expectations in law makers consistency.
It must be comfortable to judge people from comfort of a couch in 1st world country, right? What about point in constitution of many countries about free access to culture?
Music stars make most of their money out of concerts anyways, and selling music is actual way to make money by huge labels. But you surely knew that only 10% of each CD goes to actual performers.
And tbf - the only reason I am using torrents here in Europe is because there is no alternative. Netflix is 1/4th of what it is in US, there is no other services that would have huge library of movies and despite looking many times torrents are still the only option for someone who likes to see huge catalog of movies on demand.
This isn't a black and white scenario like stealing a car is (and even then there are nuances); the mere fact that millions of people engage in copyright infringement every day without any scruples whatsoever, is an indication that there is a disconnect between the law and reality, and between supply and demand.
Your standpoint can be better presented without the weasel words; it prevents being downvoted as a troll too.
Look at Game of Thrones, it's one of the most pirated content of all time. It's also one of the most popular and lucrative, book sales have skyrocketed, there is a lot of tie-in products and even HBO subscriptions have gone up. All while, and probably because, the show is so much pirated.
Sure piracy is stealing, legally, but it boosts the industry and really never hurts the creator, the only people saying that are big media companies that play victims while making bigger and bigger profits.
No, this is nonsense. As I keep posting here - I personally know of music plug-in makers who dropped out of the industry because piracy killed their revenue stream.
Piracy very much hurt the creators in those examples. It also hurt buyers, because good products disappeared.
Your post is just another version of the "Work for nothing for exposure" bullshit. It's not the George R.R. Martins and the Kanyes who are hurt by piracy - it's the niche start-up artists on (e.g.) Bandcamp who produce quality music without the backing of a huge media corp, and will give up if not supported.
If the rights-holders made their content accessible and at a reasonable price to consumers, torrents would disappear.
Prices in Norwegian kroner (NOK)
Apple Music 99 / 149
Spotify Prem. 99
iTunes Movies 49 to rent 24 hours
159 to buy (~same as DVD in supermarket)
Netflix 79 99 129
HD? x y y
Nr screens 1 2 4
I don't know how much these services think I can spend on entertainment every month, they are all priced as though they are the only service in the market and like I have nothing else I want to spend money on. The film prices on iTunes are mental, I can buy a DVD from as little as kr79, so 49 to rent one seems excessive (also aware that Apple are not solely responsible for setting prices here).As an anime fan too, torrenting is literally the only way to obtain content. THE ONLY WAY. There are 2 good free streaming sites I can think of that are not blocked in my region, and one of them daisuki.net doesn't support flash on Linux (groan) so I have to use the 'wrong' PC at home for that.
The state of legal streaming and content availability was a laughable disaster 5+ years ago. Now it's a case of being indignant and feeling righteous about giving these idiots the middle finger. The entertainment distributors are their own worst enemy.
This is one of the problems with copyright laws - creeping scope to make normal sensible actions illegal. Why is it illegal for me to modify my DVD player to play a DVD I've had to import (at great personal expense) and that is not available (and probably won't ever be available) in my region?
There's a bunch of these.