Re:Hitchhiker trees: functional, persistent, off-heap sorted...
by rdtsc on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:25AM
(#12230415)
Identical blocks of code, I think make sense for copyright cases -- "they copied our code, look here it is lines 12 through 25". Instead I believe patents are about a particular implementation of an idea.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hitchhiker trees: functional, persistent, off-heap sorted...
by beagle3 on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:10AM
(#12230738)
They are supposed to be about a particular implementation, but the USPTO awards then for ideas (stuff like "treat years less than 50 as 19xx and above 50 as 20xx" and LZW, which are each implementable in many ways).
Courts assume the USPTO is competent, so overturning a patent is extremely costly. The bottom line is: practically speaking, ideas are patentable but without complete certainty of prevailing in court.
Re:Hitchhiker trees: functional, persistent, off-heap sorted...
by sitkack on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:03AM
(#12231577)
Not only are ideas patentable, just recognizing a need or problem is patentable. One doesn't even need a solution.
Re:Hitchhiker trees: functional, persistent, off-heap sorted...
by rrobukef on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:18AM
(#12230767)
Isn't one of the prerequisites of a patent also a 'new and novel idea'? Since the author did not base his work on the patent it is by definition not novel anymore. This is exacerbated by other implementations like libbruce (see other comments).