News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case against teaching math by jerf on Saturday March 27, 2010 @10:16AM (#1222979)
Bear with me here, I have to lay down some foundation to get to my point.

Bias has a specialized definition in machine learning; in a (really thin) nutshell, it represents the set of concepts a given technique can represent. If your banana vs. ball classifier can only represent "roundness" and "yellowness", the bias will prevent it from seeing a yellow cube as anything but a banana. (If you really dig in, I find this concept is really a superset of the traditional meaning of "bias" and find it a lot more edifying, but that's beyond this post.)

A learning agent, even a human, can only learn what their biases permit. Much of intellectually growing up is the process of learning better biases, for instance putting away "magic" and replacing it with "chemistry". If you've ever felt your brain stretching as you learn something (a foreign language, Haskell, etc), that's your biases growing. Characterizing growing biases mathematically has been a great challenge for machine learning, but it clearly happens to humans.

Alright, getting up to the payload here: I have actually had similar concerns about our educational patterns before because you can't effectively teach something until you have the necessary biases in place. Unfortunately, you can't stop learning, you are always learning. So what happens when you "teach" something to students that lack the ability to apply the correct biases? You get the square yellow cube effect above... one way or another it will fit the biases you have (give or take growth, which takes time). The result is semantic gibberish. Now, by itself it is inevitable that you will go thorough quite a lot of gibberish as you grow up (see also "Kids Say the Darndest Things"), but why are we using precious school time to do that for math?

Furthermore, it is transparently obvious that things can be taught too soon. My 18-month-old is frolicking around my feet now, and he can't add. There's not much I can do to correct that right now. At some point he will, but this suffices to prove the point that there is a "too soon". So, when is it no longer "too soon"? Are we really sure that our traditional answer is anything more than traditional, that it has any actual truth?

Teaching things early is not harmless, either. Think about it; how many adults have downright childish issues with math? Childish misunderstandings, childish opinions, childish beliefs? Coincidence? Bad motivation? Or a schooling system that jammed it into their brains before they were ready. And those that don't have childish problems... is it merely because we were ready soon enough, rather that necessarily any actual unique skill? Some people never recover.

It is at least a question worth research and thought before we knee-jerk an answer of "if it was good enough for my grandpappy it's good enough for you".

(Getting a little more controversial, this is why I don't support really early sex education (i.e., elementary school). You will accomplish nothing except hilarious misunderstandings on a very important topic. This can have real, negative consequences, and the intentions count for nothing.)

Re:The case against teaching math by epochwolf on Saturday March 27, 2010 @11:37AM (#1223093)
Think about it; how many adults have downright childish issues with math? Childish misunderstandings, childish opinions, childish beliefs? Coincidence? Bad motivation?

Right here. I taught myself programming and I got pointers (references, same difference) within the first week I started reading about php. I enjoy learning new concepts except for math. I really want to learn math but I am so afraid of just opening a math book and not understanding anything in it. (Posttraumathematic stress disorder?)

Re:The case against teaching math by jrp on Saturday March 27, 2010 @01:29PM (#1223267)
I would try to find a book that balances managable and brain stretchy. _Calculus made easy_ was good for me at a certain level of understanding (yes algebra and geometry, no calculus). Try things at a library, and get recommendations, until you find one that turns you on. There's no penalty for trying a book and aborting after 1 page ;)
Re:The case against teaching math by rw on Saturday March 27, 2010 @01:33PM (#1223275)
Are you in school? Get an independent study going with a professor on a topic she likes and you wouldn't mind learning. Emphasize that you want to get your training wheels for autodidactic math education.
Re:The case against teaching math by epochwolf on Saturday March 27, 2010 @02:02PM (#1223318)
Sadly, I'm graduating in 6 weeks. I think I'll have to figure it out on my own.
Re:The case against teaching math by buckler on Saturday March 27, 2010 @02:50PM (#1223412)
May be you've seen these HN threads about self-learning maths already... if not, hopefully you'll find these textbooks useful. Here's a little HN link dump, in the order of time at which the discussions took place (from the oldest to the most recent):

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=108723

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=201913

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=458926

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=755043

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1058359

- http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1193352

One caveat is that many of these textbooks do not come with a solutions manual. So, in terms of practice, I think that's where the dearth of uploaded lecture materials could come in. Sometimes, there might be no e-learning/opencourseware material for the topic you're interested in. In such cases, I found that if you look through universities' Websites closely enough, professors upload a lot of course materials on their personal pages. You can do this by finding a random university's math dept. page, then searching from course/faculty listings.

Last of all, I'm pretty certain you've heard of this site already, as it's being circulated quite a lot lately, but many have professed that videos from khanacademy.org to be quite helpful when grasping basic mathematical concepts.

Re:The case against teaching math by epochwolf on Sunday March 28, 2010 @12:26AM (#1224212)
Thanks for the list. Saves me from cluttering HN with a another similar thread. :)
Re:The case against teaching math by restruct on Saturday March 27, 2010 @11:25AM (#1223068)
I agree with you except for the last paragraph about early sex education. If you wait until people are already having sex, it's too late.