And while I'd rather they be paying me to have my eyeballs available to them, driving up the cost of my eyeballs still benefits me even if I do not monetarily profit from it.
A business doesn't have an inherent right to exist. If it exists because it annoys people in a particularly profitable way I don't know where this sympathy is coming from.
I wasn't referring to killing clickbait as being unhealthy. I was referring to the practice of implementing policies that kill businesses because FB isn't getting their cut. There have been several much less cut-and-dry situations - for example, the drastically reduced organic reach of Facebook page posts for small businesses.
Like, I get why other things named in this thread are unhealthy. Particularly twitter pulling the rug out from app developers (which facebook also did, and I think was also relatively unambiguously unhealthy). I am not saying that all control of a platform is necessarily healthy, but you seem to be saying that it is unhealthy because it made an action that most see as undesirable unprofitable (thus causing businesses to fail).
Thus, you seem to believe that these businesses have some kind of inherent right to succeed on the good graces of another business allowing them to. I'm asking you to explain how that's in the public good.
Developers were monetizing the Twitter platform until Twitter pulled the rug out. Facebook has similarly neutered their API to the point where it is nearly useless, and many businesses were crushed in the wake of the changes. You seem to be saying that it's only unhealthy when developers are affected, but that isn't the case. Developers have no "inherent right to succeed on the good graces of another business allowing them to" either, yet you see that as unhealthy.
Publishers and developers are just users of the system, getting crushed when Facebook doesn't believe it's getting a big enough cut. I would also argue that Facebook actively blocking the sharing of external content that its users choose to share with each other simply because they aren't getting their cut is different than the affected businesses believing they have an "inherent right to succeed on the good graces of another business". Businesses that don't directly do anything on Facebook will be affected by this, because if their visitors wish to share their content, they will likely attempt to share it through Facebook.
I do not fear whatever Facebook turns into because I can decide to stop using it. If they want to continue doing evil things, I can stop logging in, no? Why would someone fear that FB is turning into something?
It doesn't matter if you log in or not. Facebook policies can affect the fortunes of nearly every type of business.
I am really struggling to see the problem with what you describe; how is it any different that advertising anywhere else? You decide if the cost of the ad is worth the ROI. Part of that decision includes knowing that your competitors might also advertise.
Does Pepsi get mad that Coke spends millions of dollars on Super Bowl commercials so they have to, too?
Facebook holds a near monopoly on social networks, and it's exploiting that to extract rents in the form of advertising
Probably. Advertising is somewhat analogous to mutually assured destruction.
Is a crowd that uses FB the most also the one with enough spending power to have such an influence?
Additionally, all sectors of the market use it here.
However, I definitely recognize this isn't the case in the US and many European countries.
This is no different to word-of-mouth reviews, that came from people who found out about a restaurant from a paid advert in a newspaper in 1950. If your restaurant didn't list in the paper (i.e. you didn't want to pay the premium for the advert) then you were at an immediate disadvantage.
That is, FB is a behemoth, is a major source of current events for a large swath of people, and their decisions unfortunately may have wider consequences than we or they necessarily predict.
Yes. I don't use Facebook, but my significant other does, and of the few news items here that I think are relevant to her, she usually sees them shared through someone's wall post 12-48 hours later. For some people it's a giant peer-to-peer new sharing site, and it's the primary source of news they have. That's extremely powerful position for Facebook, which is also why they got into so much trouble when it came out a while back that they were tweaking people's feeds slightly based on political views.
Ultimately it's like saying you aren't concerned about drug laws because you aren't in the drug economy... It has a high possibility of affecting your life in some way regardless.
I mean... facebook needs to make money too. These clickbait companies are making money of of facebook's audience, facebook's hardware and software... it's only fair that facebook gets a cut, isn't it?
Facebook's behavior is getting more and more territorial, anti-competitive, and revenue driven. They are turning into the scary behemoth that many people feared they would.
[1] https://www.facebook.com/georgehtakei
[2] https://medium.com/@jbialer/influencers-partnerships-are-vir...