Re:Slow-motion replays can distort criminal responsibility
by mcguire on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:23AM
(#12210598)
Rethink punishment in what way?
On the one hand, if the perpetrator is not "responsible", then it seems inhumane to punish them.
On the other, if the perpetrator has demonstrated that they cannot or will not abide by society's rules and we have no way of reprogramming them to do so, then the only rational response is to remove them from society. Permanently. And as early as possible in their career.
And fortunately, questions of "inhumanity" do not arise---we don't have any free will to worry about, either.
On the one hand, if the perpetrator is not "responsible", then it seems inhumane to punish them.
On the other, if the perpetrator has demonstrated that they cannot or will not abide by society's rules and we have no way of reprogramming them to do so, then the only rational response is to remove them from society. Permanently. And as early as possible in their career.
And fortunately, questions of "inhumanity" do not arise---we don't have any free will to worry about, either.