AKA (A, B, C, A, D, A, E) = 1 person out of 4 went back (25%). But, A went back 3 times so out of 7 stays 3 of them repeated (43%).
Yet another way of counting is to look at people at one point in time (C, A, D, A,). But, someone in prison regularly is much more likely to be in prison while your studying. This is mitigated by very long studies, but 10 or even 20 years is not enough.
PS: When you consider some homeless people use prison as a way to get free medical care it's easy for someone to be in and out a lot for minor reasons. Another group that's likely to come back are people who go to prison for failure to pay fines because prison tends to make you even more poor.
Your materialistic assumptions are a wonderful way to do science, but a terrible way to be human or govern.
Maybe that we are influenced far more by uncontrollable environmental factors than by our "freely* willed" decisions.
>Free will: the power of acting without the constraint of necessity or fate;
When you are hungry, you need to eat. But if you don't have any money and take an apple from the market you will be punished. So technically in this situation, the person acted out of necessity and therefore did not act out of free will.
In that case the perpetrator is just as much victim, which alters the entire balance of justice, and creates all kinds of ugly rabbit holes to deal with with respect to societal effects and morality.
2. Morality is irrelevant. We don't have free will either.
Although I don't think people here are interested in hearing arguments that don't click in desired ways with their economic interests.
Rather sadistic, the graying-out option, when used on posts like this.
On the one hand, if the perpetrator is not "responsible", then it seems inhumane to punish them.
On the other, if the perpetrator has demonstrated that they cannot or will not abide by society's rules and we have no way of reprogramming them to do so, then the only rational response is to remove them from society. Permanently. And as early as possible in their career.
And fortunately, questions of "inhumanity" do not arise---we don't have any free will to worry about, either.
- chaos; - quantum phenomenum; - creative thoughts;
Not saying it's not causal, but since we can't prove it is, yet, we can't state for sure there is no free will. Which would bother the hell out of many people :)
The thing is, in order to not be hypocritical, we'd need to look as closely as possible.
Once we do that, we'll be looking at the molecular structure of not only the brain of the perpetrator but also the whole body (as there is of course infinite interaction). We'll be asking for the causes that led to the body being as it was at the moment of the thing will currently call "crime".
We'll end up understanding that there is no free will, which will force us to rethink what we call "punishment".