News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slow-motion replays can distort criminal responsibility by imaginenore on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @05:22AM (#12208699)
But the article doesn't explain why it calls it "distortion", and not "clarification".
Re:Slow-motion replays can distort criminal responsibility by throwanem on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @05:29AM (#12208731)
>The researchers believe that the slow motion version is giving observers the sense that those carrying out the violent acts on tape have more time to think and deliberate - and the observers therefore believe there is more intent in the violent actions.

Premeditation makes the difference between first- and second-degree murder, and being convicted of the former tends to bring much harsher sentences. The article describes the paper as finding that people who view (e.g. store CCTV) recordings of a murder only in slow motion and without a timecode, thus lacking any clear reference to the real speed of events, are much more likely to impute premeditation than those who don't. That's what "distortion" means here.

Re:Slow-motion replays can distort criminal responsibility by a3n on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @05:33AM (#12208738)
It's a distortion because it didn't happen at slow motion. Not to say slow motion can't be useful, but it's not how it happened.

Think of the ultimate slow motion, a photograph. Emotions and muscle movements sweep across a face, but depending on the photographer's or editor's choice of moment, the same person can look scary or beatific.

Re:Slow-motion replays can distort criminal responsibility by mcguire on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @12:58PM (#12211318)
Let's say that A punches B, causing B to fall backwards onto a hard surface, resulting in death.

If A intended to kill B, that's murder.

If A did not intend to kill B, it's manslaughter, a lesser crime with lesser punishment.

You are sitting on the jury, with the prosecution flashing between two frames of a video of the punch and arguing that A altered the trajectory of the punch to cause B to fall onto the hard surface.

Two frames is, say, 33 milliseconds, or somewhere between 2cm and 4m (I admit, I was surprised by that speed) of neural pathway, taking the lowest and highest nerve conduction velocities I can find. How many intentions and motor changes can you perform in 33ms?