News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Neon2012 on Thursday March 25, 2010 @12:47PM (#1218802)
It's odd that certain societies don't value discovering or reporting the truth, but instead attempt to create it.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by MikeCapone on Thursday March 25, 2010 @01:11PM (#1218859)
Don't confuse a whole society with the people who hold power (and thus control the guys with the weapons).
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by ahk on Thursday March 25, 2010 @01:45PM (#1218959)
Unless I'm mistaken a majority of Chinese actually support their government and matters such as this are viewed through the prism of nationalism.

One could argue it's because of the education/brain-washing but the facts remain.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by albertsun on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:48PM (#1219316)
It's entirely possible to support one's government overall while disagreeing with many of the things it does. I support the US government as a whole, but I think many of it's policies concerning Iraq, Guantanamo, the "War on Drugs," immigration, etc. are despicable.

I think the same holds true for most of China's citizens. Most certainly realize that the government does bad things but this is far outweighed by the good things that it has done for the country in terms of economics development and stability.

Remember that a majority of China's population remembers a time when starvation was a very real risk and most were resigned to a future as subsistence farmer's living in a commune. Then realize that for someone who has lived through that to where China is now in terms of economic opportunity, free speech is just not that big of an issue.

Edit: Just to clarify, I'm not suggesting that there's a necessary trade-off between economic development and free speech. My point is that most of China's population is too busy celebrating the miracle of development to care about free speech. Instead of taking for granted that economic development happened, they still remember the very real prospect that it might not have happened and still see improvement's that can be had there.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by hyperbovine on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:24PM (#1219252)
Says who? The government-sponsored opinion poll? Or perhaps the independent one where everybody was too scared to answer truthfully.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by papersmith on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:58PM (#1219333)
My impression is that the "nationalists" (as in blind patriotism, the word has a different meaning in Chinese) are a vocal minority among the priviledged urban youths who grew up during the economic boom. The older generations who lived through Mao's days, the less priviedged middle-class kids, and the rural population tend to have very mixed opinions.

Also, Chinese opinions tend to be very mixed to begin with, which can give off the wrong impression to someone from a society that is used to partisanism.

This artwork portrays "opinions" among German and Chinese very well:

http://www.imgx.org/pfiles/2783/1.jpg

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Perceval on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:23PM (#1219397)
Here's a good article on young nationalists in China: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2008/07/28/080728fa_fact_...

It's not clear that nationalism in China equates with blind support for the Party.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by elai on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:29PM (#1219073)
It's also a bit of a survival tactic. Saying you don't support the government can be bad for you.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by grandalf on Thursday March 25, 2010 @01:52PM (#1218984)
Much as opposition to it by people in the US is viewed through the prism of nationalism.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Groxx on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:45PM (#1219125)
Because the rest of the world doesn't like free speech? Americans may throw the term around more often, but I wouldn't equate holding it important to nationalism. If anything, American nationalism has forced free speech on America, not the other way around (and yes, I'm aware of the many failures. Not saying it's perfect).
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by grandalf on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:55PM (#1219157)
In America there is not any particular issue that is so contentious that free speech is actually curtailed. But there is tremendous social pressure for people to voluntarily curtail certain forms of speech.

If the US had a less stable society, chances are certain kinds of speech would be considered more dangerous, and we'd progress from certain forms being considered socially inappropriate to being banned outright.

This has happened in our past... and the usual framing of it is that we've progressed past such mistakes. In reality the pressures that force such things have abated.

China still faces these pressures...

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Groxx on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:12PM (#1219219)
If the US had a less stable society...

I'd be interested to see what happened with free speech during the civil war days... I really don't know, no class has covered it and k-12 grade school has made me sick of US-history (flat-out fabrications and ridiculous exaggerations in tons of cases, and super super super dry info with few connections for the remaining). It'd be a good measuring point for this, though, as that's about as unstable as you can get. Yeah, slave-free-speech was blocked, but that's arguably mostly because they weren't really viewed as people, thus didn't have that right in the first place.

Anyone know?

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by plinkplonk on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:28PM (#1219264)
"I'd be interested to see what happened with free speech during the civil war days."

Lincoln greatly expanded the power of the Presidency in the name of War time expediency, but there were people within the Union who fiercely criticized Lincoln and his government and its policies till the very end of the war. Very different from the situation in China. (Just try criticizing the Party 60+ years after the Revolution!).

Besides, any flirtations with restrciting Freedom Of Speech lasted hardly 4 years, not half a century as in China. But then the USA had a very strong tradition of Freedom OF Speech wheras such a concept was alien to China. That said, Hong Kong seems to be relatively politically vibrant, in spite of being ruled by the MAinland. I suspect once people get used to thinking for themselves and having the freedom to express their thoughts for a generation or two, it is hard to eradicate completely.

Coming back to the point of freedoms during the US Civil War, see http://www.etymonline.com/cw/habeas.htm

Excerpt

"the full question of whether the Constitution gave the president a special power to suspend the writ of habeas corpus during wartime never got to the Court. In large part that's because the administration made sure it didn't. It had a valid fear that the Court would rule against there being such a power under the Constitution, and such a ruling would undermine the war effort. On the other hand, by keeping the matter away from the Court, the administration could largely accomplish its policy.

Opposition, especially in the press, clamored for a test case to settle whether the arbitrary arrests were legal. Secretary of War Stanton thought it would be wise to do so, too, but Attorney General Bates talked him out of it. In a letter of Jan. 31, 1863, Bates wrote to Stanton that a Supreme Court decision against the habeas corpus policy "would inflict upon the Administration a serious injury," and would do more good to the rebels "than the worst defeat our armies have yet sustained."

Bates said he would support a test case if he thought it had a chance of success. "I confess to you frankly, that, knowing as we do, the antecedents and present proclivities of the majority of that Court (and I speak of them with entire respect) I can anticipate no such results." This was after Lincoln had appointed three justices to the bench. Bates had intimate contact with the justices, and his judgment of their likely verdicts was well informed.

"Many loyal men deny this power to the President," he wrote to the Secretary of War, "and, however confident we may be that he possesses it, it is no imputation on the loyalty of the majority of the Court to presume that on this point they agree with their political school."

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by grandalf on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:17PM (#1219380)
George W. Bush suspended Habeas Corpus simply by putting detainees on a plane and "renditioning" them to a jurisdiction where the constitution didn't apply.

Do you think it's a coincidence that they decided to build a prison at Gitmo (conveniently close to the US but outside of US constitutional jurisdiction).

Detainees were taken renditioned to yet another jurisdiction when their captors wished to do things to them that were forbidden by laws that do apply to Gitmo.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by dpatru on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:13PM (#1219371)
from an article "The American Gulag" at http://www.lewrockwell.com/dilorenzo/dilorenzo79.html

Lincoln certainly did unconstitutionally suspend habeas corpus. But the tens of thousands of Northern citizens who were imprisoned without due process by the Lincoln administration (as many as 38,000 by one estimate in the Columbia Law Journal) were overwhelmingly plain citizens from all walks of life who simply expressed doubt over the administration’s unconstitutional and despotic policies, including the shutting down of more than 300 opposition newspapers and the mass arrest of political dissenters by the military. Tens of thousands of Northern political prisoners spent months in a series of gulags, such as Fort Lafayette in New York Harbor, which came to be known as "the American Bastille."

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by grandalf on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:41PM (#1219302)
I think you ask an interesting question... But it's important to consider that during the civil war the US was still largely pre-industrial and there was very little Federal power.

I think a good example of the general trend I mention is from WW2 when the US decided to set up internment camps for peaceful Americans of Japanese descent.

We did the same thing immediately after 9/11 but this time the victims were mostly immigrants who were minor immigration law violators.... but the spirit was the same.

In both cases our values go out the window the minute there is the smallest amount of pressure.

Many of the criticisms of China that I've read seem to entail that Chinese citizens are dully unaware of the benefits of free speech, or that they are hapless victims of their government. Neither is a particularly flattering picture of the Chinese as human beings... and I'd argue such criticisms amount to dehumanization and early beating of the war drums -- we never go to war against people who are our moral equals after all, and thus we must first dehumanize our enemy by reducing him to the status of a morally deficient, diminished pawn of an evil state.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by DanielBMarkham on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:49PM (#1219318)
In both cases our values go out the window the minute there is the smallest amount of pressure.

I've always had a problem with this line of reasoning. While I understand that flexibility is given to the executive during times of war, I haven't seen total tyranny by any means. The founders understood that one of the roles of the executive was to take temporary extraordinary powers in time of war. That's one of the reasons for the office. This internment camp example seems especially flawed.

I want to see if I understand it.

During wartime, the national government has the ability (and uses it) to forcefully conscript people and send them off to fight and die. In addition, warring powers have the ability to (and do) use explosives, fire, and all sorts of other means to kill civilians. Furthermore, the government has the ability (and the obligation) to move parts of the population around depending on national need.

Given this, you think going to live in an internment camp seems like tossing our values out the window? Like to tell that to some poor grunt storming the beach at Iwo Jima? The next war where the world loses 60 million people or more, can I go live in a camp without harm for a few years? Hell I won't even complain about it.

EDIT: I'd like to add that I consider Lincoln to be an American tyrant. Having said that, there is simply no comparison with the Chinese examples in this thread.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by grandalf on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:06PM (#1219352)
Since we have had relatively few wars, war powers provisions are among the most naive and ill-tested of any part of the constitution. In fact the need for the recent supreme court cases on Habeas Corpus (one of the oldest concepts in our common law) shows just how untested they are... and even when there is fairly clear legal doctrine, technologies such as rendition to other jurisdictions often renders the courts powerless to check presidential whims.

I would also not agree that just because something is considered (or found after the fact) to be constitutional that it is necessarily right or just.

To respond to your actual point... consider the sanctity of an individual's private, productive life. If soldiers are going to come through the door and put you in prison, they had better have a pretty good reason. In law, those reasons are very clearly articulated. Most Americans would claim that they consider things like due process to be exceptionally important aspects of our legal system... yet we are shockingly capable of ignoring them when the subgroup being violated is a small minority, and we succumb to the weakest arguments in favor of excesses.

Your argument could easily be used to justify any excessive use of power on the grounds that it's better than being blown up. By that logic, short of blowing up the citizenry, the president should have no checks on wartime powers (and calling something like post-911 a "war" gives rise to the question of what exactly constitutes one).

To zoom back out briefly and conclude, I think the letter of the law and legal justification is largely secondary... we can judge ourselves morally by how we acted in various situations, regardless of whether or not it was currently legal.

War, war propaganda, etc., cloud human judgment. Nobody other than a casualty ever really understands war, and so we are all doomed to reason poorly about it always. I'd argue that the pre-war aspect of much of US behavior on China (from Obama's trade war salvos to Krugman's rants) is one reason why Americans are so willing to embrace propaganda again so soon after the Iraq fiasco.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Perceval on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:44PM (#1219446)
>we have had relatively few wars

I don't think that's an accurate representation. We've had a short history compared to European states, but we've packed a lot of fighting into that time: http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/crs/rl30172.htm

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by grandalf on Thursday March 25, 2010 @05:38PM (#1219578)
We've had very few wars compared to antitrust cases, free speech cases, procedural cases, etc.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by mkramlich on Friday March 26, 2010 @12:01AM (#1220231)
I don't think Lincoln qualifies as a tyrant.

He was elected -- though yes a significant percentage went to a third candidate so it wasn't a strong mandate.

He did not end up doing Evil Things like Hitler, Stalin, Mao, etc -- though he did have the misfortune to become President when half the country tried to secede and therefore a civil war broke out over it, and had the misfortune of being in that situation when a rather imperfectly & ambiguously written document was the official rulebook on what he was and was not allowed to do. A document which, to this day, is still debated by thousands of so-called experts as to it's exact meaning.

Also, being a tyrant is not necessarily a bad thing. One could be a wise, benevolent tyrant. Though reality is shades of grey, I'd argue that Lincoln was _at worst_ a benevolent tyrant.

Anyway, the definition or common usage of tyrant has shifted many times. I don't think he qualifies for the one that equates to Evil Dictator.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by DanielBMarkham on Friday March 26, 2010 @06:58AM (#1220708)
We agree. "Tyrant" and "Evil Dictator" are two different things. I'm using "tyrant" in the original sense -- a person who takes most of the power of the state on themselves.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Groxx on Thursday March 25, 2010 @11:08PM (#1220143)
I love HN, this is exactly what I was hoping for. You people are abnormally helpful.

Thanks to everyone replying!

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by raquo on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:09PM (#1219031)
> Unless I'm mistaken a majority of Chinese actually support their government

I also think so, but this statement is as popular as is its opposite. Does anyone know of some real studies on this matter?

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by est on Friday March 26, 2010 @01:08AM (#1220315)
Here is the bottom line:

If it's beneficial to everyone, like Tibet, the Chinese would support the government

If it's government's monopolistic interest, everyone condemn the government.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by MikeCapone on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:35PM (#1219092)
> Unless I'm mistaken a majority of Chinese actually support their government and matters such as this are viewed through the prism of nationalism.

How do you know that? Without free elections and trustable surveys, it's hard to know.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Groxx on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:43PM (#1219120)
Because I, at least, pretty frequently hear from person X about their friend Y in China who supports their government and what's being done.

Yes, it's effectively impossible to actually measure it, but I get that feeling too from my browsing history.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by metamemetics on Thursday March 25, 2010 @11:24PM (#1220165)
From talking to people born in China that live\study in the U.S. One would predict they wouldn't support the PRC as highly on virtue of having left it and perhaps being better educated. But everyone I've met seems to.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by yters on Thursday March 25, 2010 @05:45PM (#1219606)
Why don't all their high speed hackers turn against the gov, then? They have a lot of the gov's power, plus anonymity afforded by the medium of attack.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by jbooth on Thursday March 25, 2010 @01:19PM (#1218887)
Most people don't want the truth, they just want something that feels good to repeat to themselves.

"It's the American's fault!", "It's the Arabs' fault!", "It's the neocon's fault", "Drill baby drill", "Keep the government away from my medicare"...

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by caffeine on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:05PM (#1219022)
Indeed .. most people (see roback's dead comment below) have no clue what their mantras even mean.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by aero142 on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:03PM (#1219017)
That is a nice list of things you don't like.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by jbooth on Thursday March 25, 2010 @05:33PM (#1219565)
Actually a bunch of them contradict each other, so it's almost impossible for me to dislike or like all of them.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by stcredzero on Thursday March 25, 2010 @02:06PM (#1219024)
Go to your public library and check out _Manufacturing Consent_. It's about how the US and its allies create it.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by drunkpotato on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:27PM (#1219259)
I haven't read Manufacturing Consent, but I did try to read Hegemony or Survival. It was an exercise in frustration and ultimately I didn't finish. Chomsky, on the rare occasions when he does back up his assertions with references, almost invariably references only himself. Combine that with a bombastic style that yet still manages to be obtuse, boring, and repetitive, and it's a recipe for a disastrous book that can convince only those who are already convinced and angry and looking for an argument from authority.

It sounds like Manufacturing Consent has an interesting thesis. I would like to read more about it but preferably from someone more readable, more scholarly, and less prone to hyperbole and unsupported claims.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by Perceval on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:38PM (#1219432)
While I'm neither a Marxist nor a Chomskyite-anarcho-syndicalist, I have read Manufacturing Consent, and I'd say it's a pretty straight-forward application of Gramsci's theory of hegemony to the United States. Gramsci, the leader of the Italian Communist Party, wrote his theory while in jail, outlining two forms of domination: direct coercion, and rule through civil society. Hegemony is the latter—the production of seemingly spontaneous consent for the policies of the (capitalist-controlled) state. The capitalist ruling class accomplishes this through the production of an intellectual class and related institution that support and justify the current order. The public absorbs these ideas and narratives and thus consents to the exploitative capitalist order.

Chomsky just applied that idea to the United States during the Cold War (although I'm sure he would say it's still applicable). The capitalists control the corporate media, they set up foundations that fund think tanks, they lobby the government. All reporting is dependent on advertising from corporations that won't brook deviations from the current order. So an overall discourse is created in the U.S. by corporate control which makes sure the debate stays within certain bounds of dissent, but never goes so far as to be dangerous to the capitalist system.

If you don't buy Gramscianism and don't see capitalists as capable of running society's discourse in a coordinated and conspiratorial manner, you probably won't buy Manufacturing Consent's argument.

On a side note, I was reading it in a Starbucks in London in 2003 during the run-up to the Iraq War. A Canadian reporter approached me for the purpose of interviewing me about the Iraq War, simply because I was reading Chomsky. She was hoping to get an anti-war quote from an angry young Brit, but was surprised that I was American. An interesting selection bias on the part of the reporter.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by stcredzero on Friday March 26, 2010 @07:12AM (#1220723)
I haven't read Manufacturing Consent, but I did try to read Hegemony or Survival.

Big mistake. Note the difference in publishing dates. References in Manufacturing Consent are backed up by things like "column inches per unit time in the New York Times." Also note that he is not the only author of _Manufacturing Consent_.

You remind me of an old USENET poster who used the logic: "I didn't read X by author, but I read Y, and it sucked, therefore X must suck."

Sorry, but that only has a passing resemblance to real logic.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by drunkpotato on Sunday March 28, 2010 @04:02PM (#1225128)
Only because you're using propositional logic, which also only has a passing resemblance to "real logic". Good job there.

The likelihood that a book sucks is higher given that another book by that author has sucked.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by foldr on Thursday March 25, 2010 @09:59PM (#1220054)
Ironic that none of your criticisms of the book are backed up with references.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by jbooth on Thursday March 25, 2010 @10:57PM (#1220128)
Yeah, because he's writing a comment on a message board. Read some Chomsky. He's a brilliant linguist, but his political screeds are ridiculous, he takes a set of somewhat reasonable assumptions and then builds layer upon layer on top of them as if they were bedrock or something, then winds up with a ludicrous, self-serving conclusion. (and this is coming from someone on the left side of the aisle)
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by foldr on Friday March 26, 2010 @01:14AM (#1220320)
I've read his political work, but I don't think any of what the OP said is really true. For example, the claim that Chomsky only (or mostly) cites himself is simply false. You can check this for yourself by looking at the notes for Hegemony or Survival on books.google.com:

http://books.google.com/books?id=7idg2XjTVroC&lpg=PP1...

There are only a handful of references to work by Chomsky, and all are perfectly legitimate (i.e. they're not being used as a substitute for citing independent sources). The vast majority of the references are to newspaper articles and books by other authors.

Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by adrianwaj on Thursday March 25, 2010 @06:39PM (#1219736)
At some point, a journalist switches from using reality to create perception and instead uses perception to create reality.
Re:China's instructions on reporting on Google by kunley on Thursday March 25, 2010 @08:45PM (#1219949)
On the contrary, the freedom is something very new and fragile in our civilization, and always people had to fight it quite hard. It's our ignorance that we take freedom for granted in western societies, and staying in this comfort zone may unfortunately lead us to loosing it.