Re:Daring Fireball: On Submarine Patents vis-à-vis H.264 and...
by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 25, 2010 @11:52AM
(#1218656)
I'd actually missed the so-called "clarification" which, ihmo, makes it clear he's trying very hard to create a false impression:
"Ozer: It sounds like you are saying that some of your patent holders own patents that are used in Ogg. Is that correct?
Horn: We believe that there are patent holders who do.
Ozer: It sounds like you’ll be coming out and basically saying that to use Ogg, you need to license it from MPEG LA. Is that correct?
Horn: That is not what we said. We said no one in the market should be under the misimpression that other codecs such as Theora are patent-free"
So specifically asked about the patents in the H.264 pool, he responds with the non-specific "there are patent holders who do" (yes, On2 now Google) and this is couched with a "we believe".
And when asked directly, he repeats his non-statement about Theora having patents on it. Yes, we know that. What about patents held by people who are looking for money for them?
"Ozer: It sounds like you are saying that some of your patent holders own patents that are used in Ogg. Is that correct?
Horn: We believe that there are patent holders who do.
Ozer: It sounds like you’ll be coming out and basically saying that to use Ogg, you need to license it from MPEG LA. Is that correct?
Horn: That is not what we said. We said no one in the market should be under the misimpression that other codecs such as Theora are patent-free"
So specifically asked about the patents in the H.264 pool, he responds with the non-specific "there are patent holders who do" (yes, On2 now Google) and this is couched with a "we believe".
And when asked directly, he repeats his non-statement about Theora having patents on it. Yes, we know that. What about patents held by people who are looking for money for them?