How is downloading not creating a copy? There was one file before you downloaded it, now there are two.
It's about as legal as buying a stolen TV.
Re:Book Piracy as Peer Preservation
by snovv_crash on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @12:20PM
(#12166714)
I think a knockoff TV would be a better analogy.
Copyright only prevents producing and distributing unlicensed copies, i.e. uploading or sharing - it does not cover viewing or downloading.
You may not agree with the law but nonetheless there is no prohibition against viewing an unauthorised copy.
-- can't reply below ? So replying here.
> as legal as buying a stolen tv.
Buying stolen goods is an offense in law. Buying an unauthorised copy is not.
> How is downloading not creating a copy? There was one file before you downloaded it, now there are two.
Yes, but it is not copyright infringement. Making a local copy for the purposes of viewing a web page, a picture or other digital media is not copyright infringement, this is well established by precedent.