News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by tracker1 on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:37PM (#12162826)
I really wish that Apple would release a pci card for hackintoshes, so you could just do a direct install... said PCI card would be for the sole purpose of qualifying as a licensed, but unsupported mac clone.

Have a limited number of supported chipsets, and if people want to do their own beyond that, so be it.

I'd happily pay $200-300 to be able to run macOS on generic hardware... My home desktop (windows 10) is far more powerful than any mini, I don't like the iMac's use of an integrated display, and the Mac pro is just too overpriced.

Having to do a manual upgrade cycle about once a year or so, and limited support for new hardware really removes a lot of the appeal. Apple makes a lot of money on their other hardware, which requires OSX to develop for... and I don't know how many people are buying their desktop/laptop gear. Not sure if they could do a better job than their last generation of sanctioned clones though. But a hardware tether device pci or usb for legit clones would go a long way, even if a minimal thing.

Hackintosh legitimacy would make me, and a lot of others very happy.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by adamnemecek on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:41PM (#12162848)
What is in this for Apple? I'm not sure they care about $200-300.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by tracker1 on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:48PM (#12162874)
It's mainly for a licensed user... to get more people running OSX.. more OSX users, more people buying mac laptops... main reason it might be better to only offer a PCIe card, that way it can't be used for mac laptops.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by jolux on Monday July 25, 2016 @10:34PM (#12163019)
They don't want more OS X users, they want more iOS users.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by true_religion on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @03:21AM (#12163877)
The two do feed into each other. If you use OSX, there's a huge benefit to getting an iPhone or iPad as Apple software will mesh across those platforms.

If you don't use OSX though... then you may think Android is a good bet instead.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by Esau on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @09:09AM (#12165308)
I disagree - they want both.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by mcphage on Monday July 25, 2016 @11:29PM (#12163147)
And who would write the drivers for the ocean of hardware options out there?
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by tracker1 on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @01:56PM (#12167506)
The vendors... same as they do for windows, for the oceans of hardware... Although ports of floss drivers may work out for a lot of devices.

For the most part the limitations are limited options for support... Right now operating a hackintosh is a really hard thing to do. With a blessed option from Apple, things would probably be come as, or perhaps better supported than with Linux. As it is, a lot of developers targeting Linux deployments are using Apple laptops.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by HillaryBriss on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:43PM (#12162859)
> I don't like the iMac's use of an integrated display ...

I thought the same thing back when I was Mac shopping some time ago. And I'm not saying that this should convince you or anyone else, but, now that I have one of those large Mac displays, I like it a lot. It raised my productivity.

But, yes, I do agree with your general theme about overpriced macs which don't offer enough flexibility in the available configurations and so on.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by pinum on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:47PM (#12162867)
Having an integrated monitor raised your productivity more than a regular monitor of the same size would have?
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by HillaryBriss on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:51PM (#12162887)
Ok. That's a valid point.

It's just that I'm the kind of consumer who never would've sprung for such a large monitor without being forced to. I know this kind of sounds lame, but, in my case, it's like "Apple knew best." They made me buy that honkin' monitor and it's worked out well in my case.

I don't know if that sort of thinking would apply to many other people.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by mcphage on Monday July 25, 2016 @11:31PM (#12163153)
I don't know if it's still the case, but for a while, buying an iMac with a 5K monitor was cheaper than buying the equivalent 5K monitor by itself from Dell.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by stcredzero on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:43PM (#12162853)
But why? It's just not that hard to make a Hackintosh, and you can buy support from a non Apple company. There are YouTube videos about thrashing the price/performance you can get from Apple with an awesome Hackintosh.

Also, think about it, the cost of developing the PCI card you mention would be more than the cost of developing a model of Mac hardware. You couldn't price such a device competitively.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by tracker1 on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:47PM (#12162868)
it would be totally generic hardware... a simple PCI, or USB dongle device internally would only be for a license checker in the OS.

The point would be so that you can get supported third party platforms, and run software updates with less fear of bricking your install.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by stcredzero on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:52PM (#12162889)
You're missing the point. If they did that, then Apple would still be stuck with the cost of supporting a much larger range of hardware -- so right there, a big competitive advantage they have over Windows disappears. They probably couldn't charge enough to make it worth their while, otherwise, they would probably have done so already.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by nickpsecurity on Monday July 25, 2016 @10:19PM (#12162983)
One extra board with less components than most? That's not a lot of support.
Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by stcredzero on Monday July 25, 2016 @10:48PM (#12163052)
If Apple were to certify a range of equipment all of the other hardware that could possibly be also installed in your PC, then Apple would have to test against all of those components as well.

So to eliminate the extra support, they could only support the hardware they have already tested against. For one thing, this wouldn't include the extra work to certify against the different combinations of hardware. But even if we ignore that, if Apple were to only support the hardware components they were using in other models anyway, then they would simply be undercutting their own hardware sales.

The suggestion simply doesn't make sense.

Re:What makes a Mac a Mac by nickpsecurity on Monday July 25, 2016 @11:01PM (#12163080)
I'm saying one, good board they might even make money on. One set of components. With or without PCI part. Take it or leave it deal. It can't be a high support cost given all the small firms doing many boards with few employees.

"then they would simply be undercutting their own hardware sales."

There's truth in that. Of course, Hackintosh and non-Mac people aren't buying their stuff anyway. They want the OS but not the hardware. So, hard to see big losses from this.