News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by gioele on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:03PM (#12159561)
> If what you say about "requests" and "responses" is both true and dispositive of the issue of authorization, then you're saying that virtually every SQL injection vulnerability on the Internet is also an "authorized" form of access to people's backend databases.

I would say that the SQL/HTTP equest with the SQL injection is _per se_ legal. The damage that it has intentionally caused is what the law should punish.

"You are free to tell me whatever you want, but beware: if you catch me offguard and make a damage, then you will be punished for it."

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by abstractbeliefs on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:09PM (#12159600)
At this point, what about malformed requests from homegrown browsers that trigger catastrophic bugs in the upstream application, does this now constitute a federal crime?

At no point did either party intent to cause harm, but it happened anyway.

Really, I quite like the British framework for this sort of issue: anything can be illegal or legal, it depends on context and motivation.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by rayiner on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:05PM (#12159995)
The CFAA requires you to have "knowingly (accessed a computer without authorization or exceeding authorized access)." (Under typical statutory construction rules, the mens rea requirement should distribute as shown by the parens; I have not checked whether case law has construed the CFAA specifically that way).

If you had permission to access the website otherwise, and exceeded authorized access because of a bug, you would not have met the "knowing" requirement and would not have violated the CFAA.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by Lawtonfogle on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:48PM (#12160270)
Problem with the British system is that in practice race, gender, and SES are just as relevant as context and motivation.
Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by talmand on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:48PM (#12160268)
Intent goes a long way in many things concerning legal cases in many places around the world.
Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by dpark on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:11PM (#12159618)
So you think only success is punishable? So if someone takes a swing at you, it's only assault if they connect? If someone takes a shot, it's only illegal if the bullet hits you? If someone tries to break into your house, it's legal until they get inside?

Or are computers special for some reason?

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by ploxiln on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:37PM (#12159812)
Computers are indeed not like any of these things.

I would compare to chatting with someone and talking them into committing suicide. Wasn't there a court case about this a couple of years ago? This is something that is only considered a serious crime if it is successful. Otherwise, it's just being creepy and annoying, who would accept those calls/chats anyway.

It's unfortunate that people accept and even love fundamentally unsafe designs of computer operation, where they are not in complete control of what their computer does, and then get upset when their computer does something quite actively opposite of what they wanted. This is inevitable! The biggest difference is in the prevalence.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by dpark on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:43PM (#12159859)
> Computers are indeed not like any of these things.

None of those things are really like the others either, except that they are all still (lesser) crimes even if you're not successful.

> I would compare to chatting with someone and talking them into committing suicide. Wasn't there a court case about this a couple of years ago? This is something that is only considered a serious crime if it is successful. Otherwise, it's just being creepy and annoying, who would accept those calls/chats anyway.

Probably depends on the state. If it's a crime to convince someone to commit suicide, it's probably a crime to attempt to do so. In California, attempting a crime is a crime in itself.

> It's unfortunate that people accept and even love fundamentally unsafe designs of computer operation, where they are not in complete control of what their computer does, and then get upset when their computer does something quite actively opposite of what they wanted. This is inevitable! The biggest difference is in the prevalence.

"Fundamentally unsafe"? Unplug your computer if you want fundamentally safe. Otherwise you are always fundamentally unsafe. Access to your house is not "fundamentally safe", but if someone kicks in your door and barges in, few will tell you that it's your fault that for not living in a concrete bunker.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by rblatz on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:36PM (#12160183)
No it's assault when you make the other person fear for their safety. It's only battery if the punch connects though.
Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by dpark on Monday July 25, 2016 @04:01PM (#12161192)
It doesn't stop being assault when you successfully hit the person. It's assault and battery in that case.
Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by washadjeffmad on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:37PM (#12159816)
Computers are special for some reason.

I can't punch you in the face over the computer, but I can take a swing at you in front of my monitor even I don't know where you are afk. Is that alright under the law?

That was rhetorical; of course it's alright. I'm doing it right now, for all you know.

And yeah, it's not possible B&E until you('re caught) B&E. You might have to commit trespass to get that close, but that's a different law.

The perversion is when you get charged with B&E for walking into a building open to the public just because security didn't stop you from going inside.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by dpark on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:49PM (#12159895)
> Computers are special for some reason.

And what reason is that?

> I can't punch you in the face over the computer, but I can take a swing at you in front of my monitor even I don't know where you are afk. Is that alright under the law?

That's not taking a swing at me. That's you swinging wildly in the air in front of your monitor. Yes, that's legal, if pointless.

> And yeah, it's not possible B&E until you('re caught) B&E. You might have to commit trespass to get that close, but that's a different law.

As Thomas noted, attempted breaking and entering is a crime as well.

> The perversion is when you get charged with B&E for walking into a building open to the public just because security didn't stop you from going inside.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Are you saying that unauthorized access is like breaking and entering? A better analog for the case here is trespass. You won't be guilty of breaking and entering if you enter a mall after being asked to stay out, but you will be guilty of trespass. No one is required to post guards to keep you out. Simply tell you is enough to legally obligate you to stay out.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by tptacek on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:40PM (#12159834)
I'm not following. You can definitely be prosecuted for attempting to break and enter into a house.

The distinction between doing that and entering a building open to the public is exactly the distinction the CFAA makes.

Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ... by dogweather on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:49PM (#12160273)
Sounds like trespass to me because the request explicitly acts like it's conforming to a protocol while it's actually another.