Re:9th Circuit: It’s a crime to visit a website after being ...
by tptacek on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:25PM
(#12159721)
I'm not sure I follow. This is a case where Facebook made it clear with an explicit cease & desist letter that the company was not authorized to use their API. Your argument seems to depend on some notion of compulsory licensing for APIs published to the Internet. There is no such concept.
Instead, I think we should look at the authorization angle. The company in question appeared to be using the widely accepted OAuth scheme for exactly the purpose that it was intended: acting on a user's behalf to get data (here, contact information). That's why the whole thing exists, and that's why companies like Facebook and Linkedin have as much information about their users as they do--because they themselves pursue this exact behavior.
It seems kinda incongruous to say that user authorization is fine when you have the lawyers to back it up, and not fine when you don't. This seems like Facebook being anticompetitive against the wishes of their users.