I'd guess that the manual module exports are a design decision inherited from Erlang, where you specify exported functions with the -export() macro.
As for the rest of the syntax; it appears (to me, at least) that LFE doesn't deviate terribly much from traditional Lisp syntax, while still being transparent about the underlying Erlang data types being used. Clojure took the opportunity to introduce a more opinionated Lispy syntax. This really boils down to personal preference.
All in all, I think that the various design decisions of LFE and Clojure make a lot more sense when you consider their respective host languages/VMs.
Completely agree it boils down to personal preference.
Seems like it would be a good idea though, since Clojure is a new lisp that has gotten a decent amount of traction in industry.
End users, I think, end up using clojure wrappers around java libs instead of java libs directly.
For end users (application writers), the single most important thing are the easy to use yet very powerful data structures.
update_in
put_in
get_in
http://elixir-lang.org/docs/stable/elixir/Kernel.html#update...These are basically right out of Clojure. It may seem like a small thing, but consistent, well thought out functions like this makes working with immutable data structures much easier.
[0] http://erlang.org/doc/man/maps.html
[1] http://erlang.org/doc/reference_manual/records.html#id86378
[2] https://github.com/rvirding/lfe/blob/develop/doc/user_guide....
Note that other languages on BEAM are much more "first-class" than other languages on the JVM, meaning interoperability is usually a lot easier.
I think that's a feature, since Clojure basically has no Lisp compatibility at all. No prior Lisp code runs in Clojure as it has zero backwards compatibility. Clojure has randomly renamed concepts which were known in Lisp already or removed them. Lists are no longer lists, ATOM means something entirely different, etc etc.
Though the compatibility of LFE with other dialects isn't that great in general:
Particularly:
- No data structure literals (?) - (except e.g., '(1 2 3) for lists)
- Manual module exports, instead of just having 2 versions of def
- Other small syntactic annoyances, like plain parens everywhere, instead of brackets in some cases like Clojure, and atoms (like keywords in clojure) started with "'" rather than ":"