Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by mabbo on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:19AM
(#12153517)
"All the food you need" is a bit of a stretch for me. Maybe I'm mistaken. A human needs around 2000 kcals per day, or a little less than 100 joules/second. Easy to remember: we use as much energy as a 100 watt incandescent light bulb.
Solar energy has a maximum output of 1120 W/m2 at the surface of the earth. So theoretically, a square meter could support 10 people. But there are one or two efficiency losing steps that throw this all off.
There's only light for half the day. Plants only are about 3-6% efficient at absorbing solar energy. The plants also are only taking up a fraction of the ground they're using, let's be liberal and say half. Then there's the whole 'how much of the energy the plant used was actually converted to edible calories' question, which is beyond my ability.
Multiplying that together, the best I can imagine is around 12 m^2 per human.
I'd love someone to show me a mistake in that logic, because I am super excited about things like this. I know I'm going to own one of these someday in the future.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by roel_v on Sunday July 24, 2016 @12:54PM
(#12153789)
I do some work on crop modeling. A few years ago at a project meeting, in the evening in a bar, we did some rough calculations; there were agricultural engineers and agricultural economists in our group, so it wasn't completely amateur hour (but not scientifically robust either, of course). Anyway, the result was that in Western Europe you need about 100m2 per person to grow enough food to sustain oneself for a year. This took into account that you need to grow crops that keep a long time to last you through winter etc. It didn't particularly consider variety in crops (neither for taste not for soil management purposes), but it wasn't potatoes year round either. You need to be a competent farmer as well, but it didn't consider really high tech closed-greenhouse-like setups either. Still, that was a sobering number for many in the crowd - it completely undermines the whole 'self-sufficiency = sustainable' mantra.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by justin_vanw on Sunday July 24, 2016 @02:14PM
(#12154127)
100m^2 doesn't seem like so much to me at all, certainly not sobering.
This would mean one acre of land would sustain about 40 people (or 100 per hectare).
Taking wikipedia's number of 13,958,000 km^2 of arable land in the world, this would mean a maximum world population of 137,963,876,580, which is about 20x the current world population.
Of course, this assumes equal quality of land to the land in your rough calculations, and I am guessing your number is assuming far more intensive cultivation than is typical (typical numbers I've seen are 1-2 acres / person).
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday July 24, 2016 @03:05PM
(#12154345)
The full calculation would also need to take in to consideration wastage / spoilage; crop failure; loss to pests; nutrient density (probably can't thrive off potatoes and corn only); animal feed (pets as well as animals for food).
Having said that, I'll now go on to say: with one inhabited planet there are limits to resources, but the limits to human resourcefulness are undefined.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by rahkiin on Sunday July 24, 2016 @04:16PM
(#12154660)
Don't eat animals. One problem solved. Might want to have some cows for milk and using their waste as fertilizer
Edit: the not eating animals is not in a vegatarian way. I love meat. But if you want to fully sustain yourself on the smallest area possible, animals do not aid your cause.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by mattgrice on Sunday July 24, 2016 @04:31PM
(#12154736)
Did you drop a zero?
On an all-potato diet, assuming intensive cultivation (40,000 lbs/acre yield) you could feed about 20 people on one acre. That's 200m^2 per person. For a varied diet that might contain chicken and eggs, 1000m^2 (a quarter acre) is more reasonable.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by mabbo on Sunday July 24, 2016 @05:27PM
(#12154994)
It's possible. I dumped a lot of variables into Wolfram Alpha in a big equation and it came out with an answer in "m^2 per person" units.
Also, it's not a practical minimum but a theoretical one, like supposing we had so many plants absorbing light that it's dark underneath them, etc.
In reality, potatoes can do about 17m cals per acre per year, and a human needs nearly 1m per year. In short, Matt Damon definitely wasn't growing enough potatoes (in the film version at least).
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by mikekchar on Sunday July 24, 2016 @12:06PM
(#12153654)
Has something changed? I don't see the string "All the food you need" in the article (or anything like it... possibly I missed it).
Anyway, in Japan the amount of rice that one person historically has eaten for one year is 1 koku (which is about 150 kg). The yield for rice is about 0.41 kg per square meter. So you need well over 300 square meters to grow enough rice for one person for one year. That doesn't include other vegetables or fish (or whatever).
In Walden, Thoreau describes self sustenance and living off the land. I believe he talked about farming a quarter of an acre, which is about 1000 square meters. Many people doubt he was able to rely completely on that quarter acre.
You can get some extra efficiency if you build vertical grow systems, but even your 12 m^2 is a pipe dream. Their 3.5 m^2 system will provide snacks at best. So I think you are right to be skeptical.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by mabbo on Sunday July 24, 2016 @06:05PM
(#12155121)
"All the food you need" is in the video. The 12m^2 is a theoretical limit, like the minimum one could do without violating the law of physics. It's not practical.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by underbluewaters on Sunday July 24, 2016 @12:49PM
(#12153781)
For reference, I had a very productive set of raised beds for a while in sunny coastal California that represented about 7.5 square meters. I could produce more than enough vegetables for my wife and I for about 1/4 of the year. That did not include meat, and various carbohydrates like rice, pasta and bread. I felt very confident though, that a with a total of 8 8x4ft raised beds that I could feed us all the fruits and vegetables we needed. We ate quite a few vegetarian meals so when the garden was doing well it reduced our food budget enormously.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by officialjunk on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:35AM
(#12153559)
There is also all the molecules from the local environment that play a part as well. Sunlight energy is used by the plant to convert the available local resources into a different form. The total energy available isn't limited to sunlight energy, but includes plants' local environment.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by fanquake on Sunday July 24, 2016 @09:33AM
(#12153244)
Precision agriculture is all about controlling variability. When you have a small plot of all the same soil, under the same weather conditions, your really not going to have much, if any variability, and probably won't actually need any precision agriculture. As opposed to a 400ha paddock where you can have 3 different soil types and different weather at either end of the field.
As for this technology being used on a larger scale, I'd be really interested to see the cost for a similar setup over a few thousand hectares, and what sort of efficiencies might be gained compared to our current system. However I'm not convinced it'll replace our machinery any time soon.
The other interesting use for this would be, if it gained a large enough user base, the sharing of different planting setups and rotations for nutrient replacement. i.e planting crop x and y in rotation, or interrow with crops a and b.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by krisgee on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:15AM
(#12153507)
> i.e planting crop x and y in rotation, or interrow with crops a and b.
I think this will be the real win of this technology eventually. Most if not all first world farmers understand that over the lifetime of their farm doing proper crop rotation increases yields but there is still a very reasonable instinctual reluctance to give up the short term profit of a high yield crop in order to plant a rotation crop of less profitable plants to keep the soil up correctly. Evening out that profit per field would probably be a great boon to operations that are too small to rotate entire fields.
It would also probably be an excellent way to get non farmers involved in the food production chain, especially in semi-rural areas. I grew up just in front of a community pasture which served as a grazing ground for three or four different farmer's herds and a couple of people who kept a couple of milk cows for local cheese making and stuff like that. Extending that concept to plants would be great, a giant community garden where people could plant crops that they are interested in and receive the yields at the end of the growing period. Larger farming outfits could plant around the regular people and ultimately keep costs down because of subsidy. Round out five or six gardens with some cash crops like wheat, soy or corn while locals use some of the field to grow their own grocery vegetables.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by chriswarbo on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:54AM
(#12153615)
> Extending that concept to plants would be great, a giant community garden where people could plant crops that they are interested in and receive the yields at the end of the growing period.
> Round out five or six gardens with some cash crops like wheat, soy or corn while locals use some of the field to grow their own grocery vegetables.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by krisgee on Sunday July 24, 2016 @01:29PM
(#12153952)
Sort of except instead of one person being responsible for each of their plots all of the plots are tended by a small number of farmers with electronic assistance.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by mikebelanger on Sunday July 24, 2016 @09:29AM
(#12153235)
Like 3d printing, I think this only solves problems for a small subset of the people who will buy this. In the case of 3d printing, industrial engineers could prototype things much faster, before ultimately sending it to a factory for large scale production. In the case of FarmBot, I can see some agriculture scientists working in greenhouses benefiting from automating the planting, testing and controlling of certain crops. Especially if precise timing and its documentation are needed.
But for the average consumer, this doesn't seem particularly economical. Automation of this kind of thing only makes sense when you have a significantly larger field. I still think this is a great idea, but I think its reach is a bit overstated.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by randomdata on Sunday July 24, 2016 @12:15PM
(#12153680)
But for larger scale operations, does it scale any better than the existing technology, which is also pretty much fully automated these days?
Take soybeans. Typically you want to plant around 130,000 seeds per acre. I estimate by the video that it takes about three seconds to plant a single seed. That's four days just to plant a single acre of land. The John Deere DB120 planter claims to be able to plant 75 acres per hour.
Naturally, you can add more of these machines, but with that goes up the cost and complexity. I'm not so certain the economics would favour such a device.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by criddell on Sunday July 24, 2016 @09:04AM
(#12153193)
They didn't really explain how it pulls weeds.
The nerd in me has my credit card out and is ready to overnight one of these things to my backyard.
The suburban dad in me scoffs because one of the best parts of having a garden is planting stuff with my kids and helping them water and care for the garden.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by beardicus on Sunday July 24, 2016 @04:55PM
(#12154857)
Seems like mostly what they've produced is TED talks.
That's a bit snarky. I was pretty pumped with the project at first, but it really seemed poorly run, and also seemed to ignore a lot of prior art when designing hardware. Their compressed block machine does seem fully thought out and functional at least, but their first tractor snapped in half on its maiden voyage, and the replacement looks like a post-apocalyptic bobcat. There's a reason most farmers aren't using bobcats in the field.
Anyways, neat idea, and I hope it inspired others to focus on open source hardware for agriculture and small-scale civilization.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by buovjaga on Sunday July 24, 2016 @02:55PM
(#12154297)
Marcin was not able to lead the project coherently. Groups of contributors joined for fairly short periods of time and then left, often disappointed and even angry. No idea, if Catarina has been able to influence him for the better. Let's hope so.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by andyidsinga on Sunday July 24, 2016 @01:31PM
(#12153960)
I have no idea -- I just dug it out of my bookmarks.
When I looked at the progress of the machines I had a sneaky feeling it might have slowed down - I was interested in the "aluminum extractor from clay" a few years back :)
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by okket on Sunday July 24, 2016 @10:29AM
(#12153397)
A bit much for a the simple one time task of planting. Maybe if you need to plant reproducibly a large variety of seeds? But this use case is rather uncommon.
For a more novel approach to farming, see the combination of fish tanks and planting, called "Hydroponics":
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by iandanforth on Sunday July 24, 2016 @10:39AM
(#12153427)
It also waters and weeds with interchangeable heads. Weeding is done by pushing anything unexpected back underground. Watering is done by dropping water on the plants.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by getpost on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:18AM
(#12153512)
This isn't right. You water the soil, and the soil moisture is uptaken by the plants. Watering the area immediately around the stem doesn't work, except for growing seedlings.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by Animats on Sunday July 24, 2016 @05:20PM
(#12154963)
Ignore this article (which I think was on YC a few weeks ago), and follow the link in it to Modern Farmer. Their article links to the AgBot Challenge.[1] That's both more interesting and more useful.
Autonomous weeding robots which roam big fields and take out weeds one by one are being demoed by several manufacturers. Here's the most practical-looking one, out in a huge field of beets, quietly killing weeds one at a time.[2]
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by stonetomb on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:12AM
(#12153496)
Regarding weeding, by virtue of the precision overhead watering the weeds are likely to only grow at the base of the planted crops - how would it differentiate between the two (or more)?
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by fanquake on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:34AM
(#12153557)
There are sensors designed for broadacre cropping that will pick weeds out of crop.[0]
As well as sensors that will pickup weeds from dirt.[1]
This would be in the middle of those two problems. There isn't a dense crop to pick the weeds out of, but it's probably slightly too dense to just pick them up from the dirt.
Re:The FarmBot Genesis Brings Precision Agriculture to Your ...
by ozim on Sunday July 24, 2016 @05:06PM
(#12154898)
Once I had idea about growing plants as service. You would not need to have your own piece of land but you could rent space and check your plants over the internet with mini game where you control watering choosing the fertilizer and other things (Farmeville but with real plants). You could look at your plants through ip-camera or receive pictures by mail. When plant would grow then you could have it picked up and shipped for lunch.
With this farmbot I can imagine it would be doable.
Solar energy has a maximum output of 1120 W/m2 at the surface of the earth. So theoretically, a square meter could support 10 people. But there are one or two efficiency losing steps that throw this all off.
There's only light for half the day. Plants only are about 3-6% efficient at absorbing solar energy. The plants also are only taking up a fraction of the ground they're using, let's be liberal and say half. Then there's the whole 'how much of the energy the plant used was actually converted to edible calories' question, which is beyond my ability.
Multiplying that together, the best I can imagine is around 12 m^2 per human.
I'd love someone to show me a mistake in that logic, because I am super excited about things like this. I know I'm going to own one of these someday in the future.
This would mean one acre of land would sustain about 40 people (or 100 per hectare).
Taking wikipedia's number of 13,958,000 km^2 of arable land in the world, this would mean a maximum world population of 137,963,876,580, which is about 20x the current world population.
Of course, this assumes equal quality of land to the land in your rough calculations, and I am guessing your number is assuming far more intensive cultivation than is typical (typical numbers I've seen are 1-2 acres / person).
Having said that, I'll now go on to say: with one inhabited planet there are limits to resources, but the limits to human resourcefulness are undefined.
Edit: the not eating animals is not in a vegatarian way. I love meat. But if you want to fully sustain yourself on the smallest area possible, animals do not aid your cause.
On an all-potato diet, assuming intensive cultivation (40,000 lbs/acre yield) you could feed about 20 people on one acre. That's 200m^2 per person. For a varied diet that might contain chicken and eggs, 1000m^2 (a quarter acre) is more reasonable.
Also, it's not a practical minimum but a theoretical one, like supposing we had so many plants absorbing light that it's dark underneath them, etc.
In reality, potatoes can do about 17m cals per acre per year, and a human needs nearly 1m per year. In short, Matt Damon definitely wasn't growing enough potatoes (in the film version at least).
Anyway, in Japan the amount of rice that one person historically has eaten for one year is 1 koku (which is about 150 kg). The yield for rice is about 0.41 kg per square meter. So you need well over 300 square meters to grow enough rice for one person for one year. That doesn't include other vegetables or fish (or whatever).
In Walden, Thoreau describes self sustenance and living off the land. I believe he talked about farming a quarter of an acre, which is about 1000 square meters. Many people doubt he was able to rely completely on that quarter acre.
You can get some extra efficiency if you build vertical grow systems, but even your 12 m^2 is a pipe dream. Their 3.5 m^2 system will provide snacks at best. So I think you are right to be skeptical.
As for this technology being used on a larger scale, I'd be really interested to see the cost for a similar setup over a few thousand hectares, and what sort of efficiencies might be gained compared to our current system. However I'm not convinced it'll replace our machinery any time soon.
The other interesting use for this would be, if it gained a large enough user base, the sharing of different planting setups and rotations for nutrient replacement. i.e planting crop x and y in rotation, or interrow with crops a and b.
I think this will be the real win of this technology eventually. Most if not all first world farmers understand that over the lifetime of their farm doing proper crop rotation increases yields but there is still a very reasonable instinctual reluctance to give up the short term profit of a high yield crop in order to plant a rotation crop of less profitable plants to keep the soil up correctly. Evening out that profit per field would probably be a great boon to operations that are too small to rotate entire fields.
It would also probably be an excellent way to get non farmers involved in the food production chain, especially in semi-rural areas. I grew up just in front of a community pasture which served as a grazing ground for three or four different farmer's herds and a couple of people who kept a couple of milk cows for local cheese making and stuff like that. Extending that concept to plants would be great, a giant community garden where people could plant crops that they are interested in and receive the yields at the end of the growing period. Larger farming outfits could plant around the regular people and ultimately keep costs down because of subsidy. Round out five or six gardens with some cash crops like wheat, soy or corn while locals use some of the field to grow their own grocery vegetables.
> Round out five or six gardens with some cash crops like wheat, soy or corn while locals use some of the field to grow their own grocery vegetables.
Like allotments? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allotment_(gardening)
But for the average consumer, this doesn't seem particularly economical. Automation of this kind of thing only makes sense when you have a significantly larger field. I still think this is a great idea, but I think its reach is a bit overstated.
Take soybeans. Typically you want to plant around 130,000 seeds per acre. I estimate by the video that it takes about three seconds to plant a single seed. That's four days just to plant a single acre of land. The John Deere DB120 planter claims to be able to plant 75 acres per hour.
Naturally, you can add more of these machines, but with that goes up the cost and complexity. I'm not so certain the economics would favour such a device.
The nerd in me has my credit card out and is ready to overnight one of these things to my backyard.
The suburban dad in me scoffs because one of the best parts of having a garden is planting stuff with my kids and helping them water and care for the garden.
Robots vs kids....
Hmmm. That gives me another idea...
..and the construction set: http://opensourceecology.org/gvcs/
That's a bit snarky. I was pretty pumped with the project at first, but it really seemed poorly run, and also seemed to ignore a lot of prior art when designing hardware. Their compressed block machine does seem fully thought out and functional at least, but their first tractor snapped in half on its maiden voyage, and the replacement looks like a post-apocalyptic bobcat. There's a reason most farmers aren't using bobcats in the field.
Anyways, neat idea, and I hope it inspired others to focus on open source hardware for agriculture and small-scale civilization.
When I looked at the progress of the machines I had a sneaky feeling it might have slowed down - I was interested in the "aluminum extractor from clay" a few years back :)
For a more novel approach to farming, see the combination of fish tanks and planting, called "Hydroponics":
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydroponics
Autonomous weeding robots which roam big fields and take out weeds one by one are being demoed by several manufacturers. Here's the most practical-looking one, out in a huge field of beets, quietly killing weeds one at a time.[2]
[1] http://modernfarmer.com/2016/05/2016-agbot-challenge/ [2] https://vimeo.com/140036163
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6451350
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11856915
As well as sensors that will pickup weeds from dirt.[1]
This would be in the middle of those two problems. There isn't a dense crop to pick the weeds out of, but it's probably slightly too dense to just pick them up from the dirt.
[0]http://www.spaa.com.au/projects_details.php?project=16
[1]http://www.weed-it.com/
With this farmbot I can imagine it would be doable.