Re:Journalists confused an opinion piece for an alcohol-canc...
by jlarocco on Saturday July 23, 2016 @04:33PM
(#12150902)
> While true, they're only supposed to write things that can be independently reproduced and verified.
That's in published, peer reviewed papers. The OP was talking about their blogs, which don't have any requirements like that.
Re:Journalists confused an opinion piece for an alcohol-canc...
by WillPostForFood on Saturday July 23, 2016 @04:35PM
(#12150911)
But better not to confuse economists and scientists.
Re:Journalists confused an opinion piece for an alcohol-canc...
by chestervonwinch on Saturday July 23, 2016 @04:57PM
(#12150978)
Don't economists empirically test mathematical models of the economy? How is this not science?
Re:Journalists confused an opinion piece for an alcohol-canc...
by luckluckgoosed on Saturday July 23, 2016 @06:46PM
(#12151327)
Economists work with data about people's behaviors. Their results don't remain constant, and vary depending on social or cultural trends. So they do social sciences (which is not actually science). It used to be called "social studies" in your grade school.
While true, they're only supposed to write things that can be independently reproduced and verified. If they have to layer narratives on top of their work to get people to care, I don't see any harm in that as long as it doesn't stray outside of the lines of fact.
A problem I've seen myself is that the original scientists aren't always the ones marketing their work. There's someone else (a layperson) at the university paid to do that, and they will often make claims that aren't substantiated by the original research.