While I realize that the majority of users will be 20-40 year old web app creators buy don't alienate anyone. Going forward can we look to keep non-hackers away? I think everyone enjoys this community, let's not strangle the spirit of it trying to keep it from changing.
Of course, some people will act like "mental 14yo's" no matter what, and others never visit reddit anymore - but it seems intuitive that most people are somewhere in between.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=121137
So far it's civil... But they're the kinds of things that end up drawing people into often lengthly, fruitless debates - they end up being philosophical differences that might be ok to discuss over a bottle of wine, but often end up badly on the internet...
The decision to broaden news.yc's scope to include other "interesting" information instantly adds fuzziness to the selection criteria. I have seen submissions that fly over my head, but other submissions in areas where I know more than the author.
Next, "interesting" content usually involves a mental challenge just slightly beyond the comfort zone. And so, given greater breadth of topics, which compromises depth, there will be enough submissions that are "interesting" to most people, including the 14 year-olds. To phrase differently, my knowledge in Latin American history might be comparable to a 14 year old, so we both find similar articles interesting. A BBC documentary link can easily be top quality, but appeals to all experts and novices alike.
The way you write it, is like 14 yos have an aversion to knowledge. Even if many Diggers seem immature, I'd bet they are more educated and tech-inclined than most in the same age.
I think that safeguards need to be at least thought about to try and keep the quality of the site up. Case in point: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=121534
I suspect the site's already being gamed.
"This is what the up arrow should mean."
"This is what karma should be."
"This is how to get it to behave like..."
And we're all talking about OUR app, the one we all know and love. These are my favorite threads and one of the best ways to learn and get to know each other a little better.
What we already have is better than anything any one of us could have designed.
Keep the fluff coming (just not too much).
(EDIT: This was the 2nd comment posted. One hour later, there are 22 comments about OUR app. This is EXACTLY what I was talking about. Great thread!)