Re:How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
by pg on Friday February 22, 2008 @01:34PM
(#121454)
Sorry, I know there are thoughtful 14 year olds. I don't want to exclude them. I'm using "14 year olds" as shorthand for people whose mental age is 14. Basically, anyone, whatever their age, whose comments you can imagine being said by Beavis & Butthead.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
by andreyf on Friday February 22, 2008 @04:35PM
(#121589)
I'm not sure users can be neatly split into "mental 14 year olds" versus "mental adults". I act like a mental 14 year old sometimes (usually on reddit), and sometimes I don't (usually here). I think most users are like that, and if we give an appearance of incentive for people to act maturely, then they will. I think this is at heart a psychological problem, not a sorting problem.
Of course, some people will act like "mental 14yo's" no matter what, and others never visit reddit anymore - but it seems intuitive that most people are somewhere in between.
Re:How about this idea to save Hacker News from fluff?
by davidw on Friday February 22, 2008 @01:50PM
(#121458)
One of the things I actually worry about are the "attractive nuisance" threads about things like politics and economics that are actually pretty interesting, or can be, but often end up being fairly divisive and distracting. This, for instance:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=121137
So far it's civil... But they're the kinds of things that end up drawing people into often lengthly, fruitless debates - they end up being philosophical differences that might be ok to discuss over a bottle of wine, but often end up badly on the internet...