For example Enron had to work hard to fool all those accountants, and as a result one of the largest accounting companies in the world went under and many of its partners are still mired in lawsuits. The banks created a very convoluted system to mislead investors as to the value of their securities, which involved a lot of new legislation, somehow tricking or corrupting the ratings agencies, controlling markets, etc.
So scams happen, but they are not as easy. Of course I think securities laws could stand improvement.
But we do not have the case where there are so many scams on the stock market that everybody assumes that everything is a scam and nobody invests, so the stock market is essentially useless. This is the case for many (actually most) countries.
While grellas and I disagree upthread about the intent and ramifications of this proposed change, we concur that the alternative (of an unspecific regulatory environment) is messy, unpredictable, and expensive. Libertarians often point out that disputes are inevitable are best resolved on their individual merits in a court rather than via pre-emptive regulation. This is a fine ideal, but my limited experience as a party to a few legal disputes is that going to court erodes commercial productivity like nothing else.
Second, to turn your argument on its head, why not get rid of the limits altogether? Let anyone invest in anything, whether or not the investment vehicle is registered with or reports to the SEC. Sounds great, right? Unfortunately, historical experience with this approach is that people get ripped off left, right and center, and taxpayers end up holding the bag.
True, taxpayers end up holding the bag for a lot of things anyway. I'm not sure how to fix this, but I'm pretty sure that removing all limits on the size of bags ain't it.
...which limits them to a tiny fraction of the private investment opportunities available to millionaires. Why make things harder on the wise-but-poor? Or those who have wise-but-poor friends-and-family?
...to turn your argument on its head, why not get rid of the limits altogether...
That's not the argument on its head -- that's the argument itself! Net-worth-based discrimination has no place in securities regulation.
If an unwise or gullible person can throw their entire net worth -- and then some, via leverage -- into a single risky real-estate transaction, or risky options trade, or risky loan to an unreliable acquaintance, or risky superbowl wager -- then there's no rational basis for preventing them from buying private securities.
Some will be burned, and learn (and teach others via their example). They'll do better the next time -- as with all the other expensive failures we let people experience with their own money.
Fraud can be prosecuted under existing fraud laws. And the majority of honest entrepreneurs and wise-but-poor investors will have many, many more opportunities to explore the small-business solution-space with angel capital.
And irrational exuberance, not fraud, is how the masses lost the bulk of their money -- then and now.
We just lost trillions in real estate value. Should non-millionaires be prohibited from buying real estate, by law, because circumstances have shown they're just too feeble-minded to make such investments? That would be a modern equivalent to 'accredited investor' rules originating from depression-era biases.
We float in a sea of fraud. The investment laws are not about stopping it, they are about giving Goldman Sachs a percentage of every fraud. Goldman would implode tomorrow if random assholes could just cheat each other directly. Take the fucking red pill, Neo.
The historical evidence is that complete fraud control produces water empires that are destroyed by the first barbarian to ride into town. The destruction is generally so complete that a dark age follows. Forget taxpayers holding the bag, you need archeologists to figure out what happened from the bits of that society that would not burn.
Conversely, the Western Enlightenment showed that you can get growth and prosperity undreamed by the kings of old even in the face of pervasive investment fraud. What counts is a culture of liberty, optimism, and a commitment to basic policing. Or to put it another way, it's worth the life savings of a lot of senile grandmothers if the wild-eyed schemer sometimes actually delivers a goose that lays gold eggs.
- day-trading
- real-estate-speculation
- investing in 'safe' public stocks like Enron, Fannie Mae, Lehman, and GM
- trading forex following rules they learned from late-night-informercials
- gambling in licensed casinos offering rigged games
- buying state lottery tickets
All these often-negative-expectation activities are allowed. So what, exactly, do the 'accredited investor' limits prevent a gullible person from doing? A fool will be parted from his money; these rules just change the form of the transactions that will be used.
Meanwhile, the limits prevent wise-but-poor people from being shareholders in small businesses that they actually have some expertise about, and which are more likely to be positive-expectation than the above activities.